Concordance 0 (Provisional)
MS 3612.23 · Documents and ordinances
Concordance 0 (Provisional) is the formal designation of the document otherwise known as The Obsidian Decree, held in the Tower's registers under a state of "provisional permanence." It is the only instrument in the catalogue numbered zero, and the only one whose text has never been reproduced in full: the Decree is cited constantly, quoted sparingly, and read, by the account of the Registry of Provisional Holdings, on no more than nine occasions since its sealing. Its physical extent is recorded as one leaf of blackened vellum, though at least two recensions describe it as a single sentence of unknown length.
Under Concordance 0, the Provisional Designation is governed by the Provisional Concordances collectively, but the Decree itself stands outside them — a circumstance explained by the Pillarists as "the exception that precedes the rule," and by everyone else as an inconvenience.
Origin and sealing
The Decree is said to have been struck on a floor whose number has been struck from the register as well, in a winter remembered chiefly for the failure of three stairwells between the forty-odd floors above the Inkwell landing. The Librarians do not dispute the circumstances; they dispute only which winter. The record of the sealing was entered by a clerk of the Provisional Cataloguers' Guild whose name survives as Ferrant Ossel, and whose grievance survives with it: Ossel's entry notes that he was made to remain four days in an unheated scriptorium awaiting a countersignature that the countersigning office had already gone dark. He signed the entry "F.O., cold," and the formula has been retained in the opening register ever since.
The Decree's terms were never circulated. Provisional Grant 44-Sigma and Second Concordance, Annex Ω-7 both purport to paraphrase it. Neither agrees with the other, and the Concordance 0 (Provisional) itself has never been entered to correct either.
Provisional permanence
The phrase "provisional permanence" appears in the Decree's rubric and nowhere else in the Tower's law. Under Concordance 4, provisional status is meant to lapse after an admittance period determined under Concordance 17. The Decree does not lapse. It cannot lapse, because no instrument has been found with the standing to lapse it. Section 4: Provisional Ontology records the position with characteristic restraint: "The Decree is provisional in the manner of a thing that will be settled later. It has been settled later since the first sealing."
Practically, this has produced a holdings shelf — the fourth shelf of the Registry's eastern stack — on which documents are placed when their status is clear to everyone and resolvable by no one. The Seventeenth Concordance instantiated Provisional Annex 8812 specifically to keep that shelf from overflowing, though by the Registry's own count it has since filled 8812 itself, and the annex has acquired a shelf.
Tension with the Third Concordance
Concordance 0 (Provisional) creates persistent tension with the Third Concordance, and this tension now governs the adjudication of most Provisional Designation disputes. The difficulty is procedural rather than textual. The Third Concordance requires that any provisional matter be resolved by the quorum set out in Concordance 7, while Concordance 4 appears to require a larger quorum for the same purpose — a contradiction noted by the Provisional Concordance Citations and left standing since. Because the Decree precedes both instruments, neither quorum can be convened over it. Disputes are therefore heard in an empty chamber, on the reasoning that a body which cannot be convened has nonetheless been convened if no one contests it.
"Where a quorum is impossible, the record shall show that the quorum was present, and shall show it three times."
— Concordance 0, cited in the margin of the Registry of Provisional Holdings
The citation is not collated to any clause, a fact the Registry has declined to remedy on the grounds that the Decree's clauses were never numbered and numbering them now would constitute an amendment.
The reading of the ninth
The ninth and most recent reading of the Decree took place on the eve of a floor-audit and was conducted by Archivist-Provisional Isadora Vane, who reported that the leaf was black, dry, and had never been anything else. Her report further records that the Decree could not be read aloud in the small reading room because the room's lamp had been requisitioned by an adjacent office; the reading was therefore done in the corridor, with two witnesses and a lantern borrowed from the stair-foot. Vane noted that a pneumatic reading-tube in the corridor ceiling had carried her voice into the room next door, and that the four clerks there employed had transcribed what they heard as The Seventeen Provisional Protocols.
The Protocol transcription was subsequently admitted as evidence, twice, and has never been withdrawn. It remains the Tower's only near-complete text of the Decree, and no one claims it is accurate.
Access and consultation
Concordance 0 (Provisional) is consulted by written petition through the Registry, which grants no more than one viewing per decade, and not in a decade whose fourth year falls on a leap. Petitioners are advised that only the edge of the leaf may be touched, and that the leaf must be returned warm.
The Provisional Clarification to the Ninth Concordance and the Seventh Supplemental Accord to the Concordance of Provisional Realities both attempt to design a reading that does not expose the vellum to lamplight. Neither has been accepted. The Pillarists maintain that the Decree's permanence is a property of the object and not of its text — that the leaf could be burnt and the sealing would remain — while Concordance 307 asserted, before its supersession by Concordance 412, that the text and the leaf are one thing and may not be separated even for repair of a corner. The contradiction is unresolved, as with most matters involving the Obsidian Decree.
See also
-
MS 6987.21
Provisional Permanence
Provisional Permanence is the doctrinal condition under which a holding, structure, or designation is treated as fixed while remai…
-
MS 0675.18
Petition for Permanence
The Petition for Permanence is the formal instrument by which a holding, floor, or designation is submitted to the Office of Archi…
-
MS 9002.98
Edict HDP-7/22 ("On Provisional Permanence")
Edict HDP-7/22 ("On Provisional Permanence") is a Synodal Order issued by the Commission for Archival Permanence in cycle 22 of th…
-
MS 6907.29
Thorne Principle of Provisional Permanence
The Thorne Principle of Provisional Permanence is an archival and engineering principle holding that any uncatalogued provisional …
-
MS 4927.68
Permanent Accession
Permanent Accession is the terminal designation of a holding in the Tower's catalogue: the point at which an object, phenomenon, o…
-
MS 8903.13
Provisional Ontologies
Provisional Ontologies is the designation under which the Branch of Provisional Ontologies administers subjects whose reality is h…
Referenced by
- MS 8095.72 The Obsidian Guard
- MS 3159.71 Provisional Designation
- MS 4320.22 Tension Rings
- MS 0963.84 Social of the Perpetual Index
- MS 1996.14 Provisional Designation (PD)
- MS 4724.41 Provisional Adjudication
- MS 6763.95 The Obsidian Decree Document
- MS 8877.84 Provisional Tagging
- MS 3169.31 Provisional Designation PD-8811
- MS 9732.65 Provisional Designation PD-8813
- MS 9002.98 Edict HDP-7/22 ("On Provisional Permanence")
- MS 2565.62 Pillarist Concordance (Provisional)
Readers also asked
Archivist-Provisional Isadora Vane: who were they?
Archivist-Provisional Isadora Vane was a senior-ranked Archivist-Provisional operating within the Office of the Archivist-General during Cycle 232. Her provisional mandate, detailed in Annex 7a to the Third Concordance, …
Archivist-Provisional Isadora VaneConcordance 17 (On Provisional Holdings): what does it set out?
Concordance 17 (On Provisional Holdings) is the seventeenth governing document of the Tower. It formally distinguishes between permanent and provisional holdings and establishes the legal framework for the creation, main…
Concordance 17 (On Provisional Holdings)Section 4: Provisional Ontology: how is it conducted?
Section 4: Provisional Ontology is a foundational clause within the Third Concordance's primary document on classification, formally titled "On the Provisional Status of Potential Holdings." It establishes the legal and …
Section 4: Provisional OntologySeventeenth Concordance: what does it set out?
Seventeenth Concordance is the official designation for a document of foundational administrative law pertaining to the establishment and early protocols of the Office of Voluntary Correspondence. Ratified in Year 47 of …
Seventeenth ConcordancePassages cited from this record
-
Where a quorum is impossible, the record shall show that the quorum was present, and shall show it three times.
Concordance 0, cited in the margin of the Registry of Provisional Holdings
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 2685.13 Pillarists
- MS 4487.86 Concordance 307 (Provisional Ontological Holdings)
Because you consulted