Exemplary Intent
MS 0454.13 · Practices and doctrines
Exemplary Intent is a classificatory designation applied to a petitioner's intent where that intent is held to exceed the ordinary standard of sufficiency by so wide a margin that its measurement cannot be reconciled with the Metrices of Intent without adjustment. It is not a kind of intent, strictly speaking, but a finding about one: an intent may be Declared, Demonstrated, or Latent and still be ruled Exemplary, though the ruling is entered only against intents that have first passed through an Intent Gate and been found wanting in nothing.
The designation was created by administrative accident. In the winter of the year the Tower records as 4,112, a petitioner at the North Aperture submitted an intent of such clarity that the presiding Atmospheric Intent Meter returned a reading off the upper end of its graduated scale and then, after recalibration, off it again. The instrument had been certified for readings between nothing and sufficient. The clerk on duty, Clerk Orsinal Vey, recorded the result in his upright cursive as "exemplary — beyond the meter's opinion," a phrasing he later defended before the Seventh Reckoning of Intent on the grounds that no other word in the register would hold the number.
The adjustment of 4,113
Because the Metrices of Intent are graduated only to sufficiency, an Exemplary reading cannot be filed directly. The Refinery of Clarified Intent, which maintains the Metrices and certifies practitioners of Intent Stoking, issued the Adjustment of 4,113, directing that any reading exceeding the upper graduation by more than one part in forty be entered as "sufficient, and noted." The note is the whole of the designation; there is no separate scale for it. Clerks who have attempted to construct one have been referred to the Refinery's standing instruction that no instrument shall be graduated beyond its function.
The Register of Docketed Intent, where Certificates of Clarified Intent are submitted, accordingly holds Exemplary findings in the ordinary columns, distinguished only by a marginal note in the hand of the receiving clerk. The Registry of Provisional Intent has twice petitioned for a dedicated column and twice been refused, the second refusal citing the cost of ruling.
The Cordwainer precedent
The most-cited Exemplary finding remains that of the cordwainer at Floor 2,208, whose intent to repair a stair was ruled Exemplary in 4,140 after three separate meters, brought to the floor in succession, agreed with one another to the last graduation and then continued to agree past it. The Court of Coincidental Intent heard the matter on appeal, the Refinery having argued that agreement beyond the scale was not measurement but repetition. The Court held for the cordwainer in a single paragraph:
"An intent that three instruments cannot distinguish from sufficiency is sufficient. An intent that three instruments cannot distinguish from one another is exemplary. The Tower does not require the cordwainer to be less certain so that the meter may be more comfortable."
— Court of Coincidental Intent, ruling of 4,140, cited in the Doctrine of Latent Intent
The stair was repaired. It is the only repair on Floor 2,208 for which the intent is recorded as Exemplary, and the floor's maintenance ledger notes, in the same hand as the ruling's transcription, that the tread has not moved since.
Dispute between the Schools
The School of Literal Intent holds that Exemplary Intent is a category error, since the Metrices of Intent measure intent against a standard of sufficiency and nothing in the standard admits of excess. Its position paper of 4,161 argues that what the meters record past the upper graduation is not more intent but instrument failure, and that the designation should be struck from the register and the findings re-entered as faults. The School of Accumulated Intent replies that a standard which cannot describe what exceeds it is a defective standard, and that the Refinery's Adjustment of 4,113 is an admission of this drafted by the very office that denies it.
The School of Literal Intent has not been able to secure a vote on striking the designation, as the question was referred to the Senior Librarian of Intent in 4,163 and remains there. The Arbiter of Recursive Intent has declined to hear the matter on the grounds that it is not recursive, merely old.
Use in certification
The Annex of Architectural Intent permits an Exemplary finding to substitute for one of the two demonstrated intents ordinarily required of candidates for Intent Certified Architects, provided the finding predates the candidate's application by not less than one year and is not the candidate's own. The provision has produced a small trade in Exemplary findings among candidates, conducted entirely through the Central Registry of Stated Intent, which logs the transfers without endorsing them.
An Exemplary finding may not be cited by the petitioner who obtained it in support of a second petition. The Tower's position, stated in the Annex and never since elaborated, is that an exemplary act is not a precedent even for the person who performed it. Petitioners who attempt the citation are advised to submit a fresh intent and to leave the margin of the previous one unmentioned.
See also: Attestation of Intent, Declarative Intent, Register of Docketed Intent, Refinery of Clarified Intent, Seventh Reckoning of Intent.
See also
-
MS 2472.23
Contextual Sufficiency
Contextual Sufficiency is the descriptive and procedural standard by which the cataloguing of a subject within the Tower is deemed…
-
MS 2236.22
Form L 22 Declaration of Descriptive Sufficiency
Form L-22, "Declaration of Descriptive Sufficiency" is the triplicate, perforated document prescribed by the Subcommittee for Prov…
-
MS 0627.39
Theorem of Descriptive Sufficiency
The Theorem of Descriptive Sufficiency is the colloquial designation for Concordance 10.b.7, Annex Δ, the instrument by which the …
-
MS 3898.52
Class IV (Displaced)
Class IV (Displaced) is the fourth designation in the Tower's seven-class taxonomy of holdings, applied to any object, document, o…
-
MS 3323.26
The Petitioner's Ink
The Petitioner's Ink is the collective designation for the three inks permitted to enter a Petitioner Identification Dossier at th…
- MS 3774.49 Declarations of Foundational Sufficiency Form Gef 7
Referenced by
- MS 9648.97 Archival (Class R)
- MS 7463.30 Intent Verification
- MS 5732.11 Perimeter of Coherent Intent
- MS 0283.03 Intent
- MS 5163.02 Nexus of Mutual Intent
- MS 3202.44 Protocols of Conditional Intent
- MS 1230.37 Intent is Irrelevant to Substance
- MS 3955.06 Pavilion of Postponed Intent
- MS 5760.19 The Intent-Calibrator
Readers also asked
Senior Librarian of Intent: who are they?
Senior Librarian of Intent is one of the twelve recognized administrative posts within the Librarian Order, holding authority over all matters pertaining to registered, inferred, and unrealized intent as described in the…
Senior Librarian of IntentAtmospheric Intent Meter: what is it for?
The Atmospheric Intent Meter is a calibrated instrument used within The Tower to measure and quantify manifestations of Latent Intent within gaseous or airborne phenomena. It is the standard tool for assessing atmospheri…
Atmospheric Intent MeterArbiter of Recursive Intent: how is it conducted?
Arbiter of Recursive Intent is a conditional judicial title activated exclusively during proceedings concerning Latent Intent and Recursive Nullities. The title does not denote a permanent office but is instead provision…
Arbiter of Recursive IntentCentral Registry of Stated Intent: who are they?
The Central Registry of Stated Intent occupies the entirety of Sub-Aperture Theta-7 on Spiral 42, also known as the Spiral of Declared Motions. It is not a public-facing bureau; access is permitted only to accredited Lib…
Central Registry of Stated IntentPassages cited from this record
-
An intent that three instruments cannot distinguish from sufficiency is sufficient. An intent that three instruments cannot distinguish from one another is exemplary. The Tower does not require the cordwainer to be less certain so that the meter may be more comfortable.
Court of Coincidental Intent, ruling of 4,140, cited in the Doctrine of Latent Intent
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 6391.48 Clerk Orsinal Vey
- MS 2291.93 Intent Stoking
Because you consulted