Third Concordance, Amendment VII
MS 2635.56 · Documents and ordinances
Third Concordance, Amendment VII is the seventh amending instrument to the Third Concordance, ratified on 4 Ember 11 by the Sub-Committee on Latent Faults and entered into the standing register six days later, after the customary cooling period. It is the single most cited amendment in the Concordance corpus and, by the Librarians' own count, the least read in full. Its four surviving clauses established the Gallery of Superfluous Marks, constituted the Bureau of Procedural Coherence, codified the doctrine of Latent Culpability, and required that any support structure rendered void by legislation or by a shift in cataloguing be entered into the Inventory of Voided Supports. Later scribes appended further schedules under the same designation, including a specification for the Silk of Unmaking under Amendment VII-δ, but these are formally separate instruments and are treated elsewhere.
Origin and ratification
Amendment VII arose from the Winter Assizes of Floor 109, a four-month session convened after a stairwell between the 90s and the 100s was discovered to be supporting a corridor that no longer existed. The corridor had been deaccessioned in the previous year; the stairwell had not been told. Three clerks were injured in the collapse and one, Clerk Amaranth of the Ninth Scriptorium, filed the complaint that became the amendment's first recital. Her grievance was not the injury but the paperwork: the stairwell, she argued, had been performing a function that the catalogue had already abolished, and no instrument existed to record that a thing could be void and load-bearing at once.
"What the register has struck out, the masonry has not. Provision must therefore be made for the support of nothing, and for the persons who stand upon it."
— Third Concordance, Amendment VII, recital 3
The Sub-Committee sat for eleven days and produced a text of uncommon length, of which only four clauses survived the Recension of 14. The excised clauses are known to have concerned the licensing of ladders.
The codification of Latent Culpability
Clause 4 is the amendment's most consequential provision. It establishes that where an adverse outcome arises from a documented process, fault is presumed to lie with the process until the process is shown to have been correctly followed, at which point fault transfers to whoever documented it. The doctrine has been applied to stairwells, seals, weather on the upper floors, and at least one marriage.
Its application is not uniform. The Bureau of Normative Postulation holds that Latent Culpability attaches at the moment of documentation, whereas the Bureau of Procedural Coherence maintains that it attaches at the moment of adverse outcome and may be retrospectively reassigned. The two positions were reconciled in Concordance VII-b by a formula that neither office accepts. A note in the margin of the Vellum Original of Clause VII reads, in a hand not otherwise identified: both offices content; nobody satisfied.
Jurisdiction of the Gallery
Clause 2 confers on the Gallery of Superfluous Marks authority over all marks, impressions, and marginalia that appear in the archive without a corresponding entry in the register. The Gallery's jurisdiction is therefore expansive and its holdings largely accidental. It has ruled on coffee rings, on the pressure-marks left by a lectern removed in the 300s, and on a set of fingerprints on the Vitreous Silica Floor 88 that the Gallery has declined to attribute, on the grounds that attribution would require an entry and the entry would remove the matter from its jurisdiction.
Clause 2 also contains the amendment's most frequently misquoted sentence. The correct reading is that the Gallery "shall have regard to the marks and not to the hands," a formulation drafted to prevent the Gallery from summoning clerks to explain their own handwriting. In practice it has had the opposite effect: clerks are summoned to explain the hands of others.
Amendment 881 and the dispute over precedence
Amendment 881 to the Third Concordance purported to amend Amendment VII by inserting a fifth clause on the disposal of voided supports. The Bureau of Procedural Coherence objected that Amendment VII had been closed to further insertions by its own clause 9, which the Sub-Committee had included precisely to prevent what Amendment 881 attempted. The matter went to the Concordance Amendment Tracking office, which ruled that Amendment 881 was valid because clause 9 had never been read aloud in session and was therefore, in the office's phrase, "procedurally inaudible."
This ruling is cited in Clause 17(vii) of the Third Concordance as precedent for the principle that an unread clause binds no one. It is cited in Clause VII.ii for the opposite. Both citations are current.
Relationship to Annex VII and the rival text
Third Concordance, Annex VII was appended to the amendment in the following year and is often confused with it, particularly by visitors, who are asked to state which they mean before being admitted to the Gallery. The Annex defines conceptual seepage as a routine maintenance issue; Ninth Concordance, Annex VII defines the same phenomenon as a reportable event. Amendment VII says nothing on the subject, a silence that both Annexes cite in support of themselves.
A rival text, the Rival Concordance, claims an Amendment VII of its own with different clauses and an earlier date. The Librarians do not dispute its existence; they dispute its numbering, and have done so continuously since 19 Ember 40. The dispute is considered settled and is re-opened annually.
Textual history and surviving copies
Four copies of Amendment VII are known: the vellum original, held under seal; a working copy in the Ninth Scriptorium bearing Clerk Amaranth's annotations; a fair copy in the Register of Standing Instruments; and a partial copy transcribed into the flyleaf of the Treatise on Unmade Things Vol Vii, which omits clause 4 entirely. The omission was discovered in 22 Frost 47 and has never been explained. The flyleaf copy is nonetheless the one most often consulted, on the grounds that it is the shortest.
Under Third Concordance, Amendment 12, the amendment is subject to the Annual Reconciliation of Inventories, and its voided supports are counted each year against the Inventory. The count has not balanced since the Reconciliation was instituted. The discrepancy is currently 214 supports, of which 3 are stairwells and 1 is a corridor that has since been rebuilt and is therefore void twice.
See also
-
MS 8219.10
Fifth Concordance, Amendment 88
Fifth Concordance, Amendment 88 is the eighty-eighth amending instrument appended to The Fifth Concordance, ratified on 3 Nones, 1…
-
MS 9276.00
Second Amending Annex to Addendum 17
The Second Amending Annex to Addendum 17 is an amending instrument of the Citation Protocols, ratified in the fifty-seventh cycle …
-
MS 6023.33
Amendment Δ to Holding 44.12
Amendment Δ to Holding 44.12 is the instrument, ratified in the ninth session of the Concordance Revisions Committee and recorded …
-
MS 6696.98
Amendment 3 to Guild Standard 114 Delta 7b
Amendment 3 to Guild Standard 114 Delta 7b is the third of the amending instruments appended to Guild Standard 114 Delta 7b on the…
-
MS 9603.86
Fourth Concordance, Amendment 12
Fourth Concordance, Amendment 12 is the twelfth instrument of amendment to the Fourth Concordance, ratified on 3 Ashmonth, Year 60…
-
MS 2044.09
Amendment 712
Amendment 712 is a corrective instrument of unusual length appended to Concordance 44, Amendment 12, ratified in the sixty-third r…
Referenced by
- MS 0467.95 Third Concordance Amendment Xiv Clause 9
- MS 3829.16 Third Concordance, Amendment 17.δ
- MS 8886.16 Inventory of Superfluous Supports
- MS 6675.18 Third Concordance, Amendment 891
- MS 5213.02 Seventh Concordance Amendment 14 B
- MS 6751.88 Amendment 43-b (The Latent Inventory Clause)
- MS 2174.50 Amending Citations
- MS 6408.55 Amendment 9-g (The Protocol of Anticipatory Jurisdiction)
- MS 5166.07 Amendment VII.δ (Year 1,104)
- MS 6606.43 Amendment VII to Annex A
- MS 2127.24 Third Concordance, Amendment 22
Readers also asked
Latent Culpability: how is it conducted?
Latent Culpability is the primary legal and administrative doctrine for assigning causal responsibility within the Tower's operational systems. It functions as the procedural mechanism for investigating systemic failures…
Latent CulpabilityConcordance Amendment Tracking: how is it conducted?
Concordance Amendment Tracking (CAT) is the mandated administrative practice for logging the issuance, versioning, status, and interrelationship of all amendments to the Third Concordance, Ninth Concordance, Twelfth Conc…
Concordance Amendment TrackingThird Concordance: what does it set out?
The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…
Third ConcordanceVitreous Silica Floor 88: what is it for?
From the closing remarks of the Ninth Central Inspectorate of Substrate Integrity, appended to Annex VII of the Third Concordance.
Vitreous Silica Floor 88Passages cited from this record
-
What the register has struck out, the masonry has not. Provision must therefore be made for the support of nothing, and for the persons who stand upon it.
Third Concordance, Amendment VII, recital 3
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4369.72 Register of Standing Instruments
- MS 7205.98 Clerk Amaranth of the Ninth Scriptorium
- MS 9477.15 Recension of 14
- MS 0919.37 Winter Assizes of Floor 109
Because you consulted