The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Amendment 43-b (The Latent Inventory Clause)

MS 6751.88 · Documents and ordinances

Amendment 43-b (The Latent Inventory Clause) is the forty-third amendment to the Third Concordance and the instrument by which the Principle of Latent Cataloguing entered the Tower's binding law. It establishes that a thing need not be present, assembled, or indeed extant to be catalogued, provided that its absence has been properly recorded and witnessed. It is a short document — four folios, two annexes, one erratum — and it has generated more shelf-metres of commentary than any text of comparable length except the Third Concordance, Amendment VII.

The Amendment was sealed in the winter of 1789, following eleven years of dispute between the Bureau of Static Inventory and the cartographers of the lower spiral over whether an empty shelf could be listed as an item. The clause that resolved the matter is short enough to quote in full:

"What is not held shall nonetheless be entered, and the entry shall be as binding upon the Inventory as if the article were held, save that it be marked with the character of its latency."

— Third Concordance, Amendment 43-b, Clause 1 (The Latent Inventory Clause)

Background

The empty-shelf controversy arose on Floor 2211 (the Register of Registers) in the winter of 1782, when a junior clerk named Halverine Mott submitted a return listing forty-one holdings, of which nineteen were shelves that had been intended to contain holdings but did not. The return was rejected by the Bureau of Static Inventory on the grounds that Mott had "inventoried an intention." Mott appealed, arguing that the intention had been entered in the accession ledger in good hand and counter-signed, and that a counter-signed intention was by definition an administrative fact and therefore a species of holding.

The Bureau's reply, often cited and never loved, runs:

"The Bureau does not dispute that the intention exists. The Bureau disputes that it takes up shelf."

— Bureau of Static Inventory, Return of Rejection 4412, annotation of the Second Recorder

Mott's appeal was heard four times and decided three times. By the time Amendment 43-b was sealed, Mott had been reassigned to the stairs and the question had become one of precedent rather than of the shelves themselves.

Provisions and the erratum

Clause 1, quoted above, is the operative text. Clause 2 sets out how a latent entry is to be marked — in practice a marginal sigma and the date of the witnessing — and Clause 3 forbids any floor from counting its latent entries toward its stated capacity. It is Clause 3 that is most often enforced and least often obeyed. The School of Latent Precedence has recorded that of the floors audited between 1840 and 1851, "upwards of two-thirds" had at some point lent against their latent entries.

The Amendment's single erratum concerns its own numeral. The clause was drafted as 43-c, was amended on the floor during sealing to 43-b, and the superseded numeral was struck but not struck cleanly. The School of Latent Potential maintains that the original 43-c is the true designation and that 43-b is a ghost entry which ought itself to be marked as latent — an argument the school has pursued with notable consistency and no success.

Readers consulting the Amendment in the reading room should note that the second annex is bound facing outward and must be turned before the first.

Relationship to the Latent Topography Clause

Amendment 43-b governs inventories; Amendment 14-f governs spaces, and the two are frequently confused because both descend from the same drafting hand and use the same character for latency. The distinction, set out in the commentary of Status of Latent Amendments, is that 43-b catalogues what is not on the shelf, while 14-f catalogues the shelf that is not in the room. That 14-f was sealed to the Seventh Concordance and 43-b to the Third Concordance has caused further difficulty, since the two instruments do not share a numbering scheme or, in places, a vocabulary.

The two clauses were reconciled only once, in the ruling on the Incident of the Wandering Gallery, where it was held that a gallery which had been catalogued under 43-b and subsequently relocated under 14-f remained a single holding with a dual entry, "and the clerk shall not be required to choose."

Disputes

The principal scholarly disagreement turns on the word binding in Clause 1. The School of Latent Precedence reads it as evidentiary: a latent entry binds the Inventory to remember. The Bureau of Static Inventory reads it as proprietary: a latent entry is a holding for all purposes of ownership, which would make the Latent Acquisitions of Floor 1640 a species of purchase. The School of Latent Potential rejects both readings and holds that "binding" was intended to mean merely "written down carefully."

A secondary dispute, ongoing since the Nineteenth Concordance Amendment 7 clarified inheritance of latent volumes, concerns whether a clerk who dies having witnessed a latent entry passes the witnessing to their successor or takes it with them. The Bureau of Contradictory Cartography, established under 14-f, has been asked to rule on this three times and has declined twice.

Interested parties may also consult Ordinance 707.12, Sub-clause 9.α, Amendment to Clause 19, and the cautionary record of The Self-Excluding Inventory (PA-882).

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Nineteenth Concordance Amendment 7: what does it set out?

Nineteenth Concordance Amendment 7, commonly designated Amendment VII or the Amendment of the Latent Implication, is a supplemental clause to the primary Nineteenth Concordance document that governs the attribution of ca…

Nineteenth Concordance Amendment 7
Amendment 14-f (The Latent Topography Clause): what does it set out?

Amendment 14-f, commonly referred to as The Latent Topography Clause, is a codicil to the Seventh Concordance that establishes the jurisdictional primacy and procedural requirements of the Bureau of Latent Cartography in…

Amendment 14-f (The Latent Topography Clause)
School of Latent Potential: who are they?

School of Latent Potential is the administrative body responsible for the interpretation, quantification, and institutional application of Clause 14.7.δ (The Statute of Latent Potential). Founded concurrently with the ra…

School of Latent Potential
Principle of Latent Cataloguing: how is it conducted?

The Principle of Latent Cataloguing is a doctrine of the Tower's bibliographic order holding that a subject's persistent absence from the catalogue may itself constitute sufficient grounds for that subject's provisional …

Principle of Latent Cataloguing

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.