Proposed Provisional Classification
MS 3183.15 · Practices and doctrines
Proposed Provisional Classification is a formal submission for the recognition of a state of provisionality, distinct from the administrative implementation of Provisional Classification itself. It is the documented hypothesis that a subject warrants such temporary ontological status, filed prior to any official determination. The process is governed by Article 14 of the Department of Provisional Holdings' charter and is a prerequisite for the opening of a Provisional Shelving case file.
Formal Requirements
A Proposal of Provisional Classification (Form PPC-7) must be submitted to the Office of the Provisional Census and must contain, at minimum:
- The precise designation of the subject under review.
- A cataloguing location, even if that location is described as "unfixed," "shifting," or "theoretical."
- A preliminary temporary accession number.
- A statement of provisional attributes, detailing why the subject cannot be permanently classified under current Concordance 4 schemata.
- A proposed duration for the provisional period, which, per convention, cannot exceed ninety-nine Tower years without renewal.
- Citations to at least two potentially contradictory Concordances that the subject’s existence may reconcile or further complicate.
Incomplete submissions are returned via pneumatic tube to Floor 314, where they are held in a state of "procedural limbo" for no less than forty days.
Review and Assessment
Upon receipt, the proposal enters the assessment queue of the Office of Preliminary Verifications. The primary assessment criterion is not the truth of the proposal, but its structural viability as a provisional holding. Assessors evaluate whether the proposed classification would create a logically consistent, albeit temporary, pocket within the Tower's ontology. A proposal to classify "the sound of a page being turned in an empty reading room" was rejected not because the sound doesn't exist, but because its provisional framework was deemed "insufficiently porous to allow for subsequent re-cataloguing."
Successful proposals are granted a "Provisional Permit" and forwarded for Provisional Shelving logistics. Unsuccessful proposals are archived in the Annex of Superseded Hypotheses, where they may be cited in future, more successful proposals.
The Selvage Corollary and Procedural Loops
A significant area of procedural debate concerns proposals that are themselves about the nature of provisionality. The Selvage Corollary, while originally pertaining to botanical cataloguing, has been invoked to argue that proposals concerning meta-provisional states (e.g., "The Temporary Status of 'Temporary'") must be assessed in zones where two classification systems overlap, such as the border between the Department of Provisional Holdings and the Physical Principles Directorate. This can create recursive assessment loops.
The most famous instance, Proposal PPC-44109-Δ ("On the Provisional Classification of Proposals for Provisional Classification"), spent 212 years shuttling between departments. It was finally resolved not by ratification, but by being quietly re-catalogued as a case study appended to Provisional Annex 8812, under the clause covering "self-referential cataloguing anomalies that resolve through administrative inertia."
Distinction from Related Processes
It is critical to distinguish a Proposed Provisional Classification from several adjacent administrative acts:
- Provisional
- An implemented classification for subjects that alter their own status. A Proposal of Provisional Classification may suggest a subject be placed in Class V, but it is not the classification itself.
- Proposal of Resolution
- A document seeking to end a provisional status, often filed concurrently with or in opposition to a new Proposal of Provisional Classification for the same subject.
- Provisional Attribution
- The act of assigning origin or authorship to a provisionally held item. This occurs after a Proposal of Provisional Classification has been accepted.
Controversies and Amendments
The doctrine of "Provisional by Proposal," argued for in the dissenting opinions of Supplemental Register Vol. XV, holds that the very act of submitting a formally correct proposal imbues the subject with a low-grade, anticipatory form of provisionality until the assessment is complete. This view is rejected by the mainstream interpretation of Concordance 4, Article III, which states that provisionality begins only upon "the stamp of the Librarian-Provisional's sanction."
This conflict led to the Aperture Amendment of 1922, which created a new form, PPC-7b, for proposals concerning subjects theorized to exist entirely within the "conceptual space between proposal and ratification." These are assessed under a separate, accelerated protocol, though no such proposal has ever been fully ratified, as their subjects are deemed to evaporate upon the granting of official provisional status.
See also
-
MS 0050.53
5a (Definition of Provisionality)
The clause is notable for its deliberate conflation of epistemological and ontological frames. It does not assert that a subject i…
-
MS 3888.00
Perpetual Provisionality
Perpetual Provisionality is the doctrine, given operative force by the Preamble to the 34th Concordance, under which a classificat…
-
MS 5900.07
Form T-44
Form T-44 is a Tower document of contested purpose, currently administered under the aegis of the Form Genesis Division as an inst…
-
MS 5857.01
Implementation
Implementation is the formal, multi-stage process by which a subject becomes a ratified and catalogued holding of the Tower. Disti…
-
MS 0308.57
Archive of Provisional Holdings
“Provisionality is not a temporal state, but a spatial one: a Holding is provisional because it resides elsewhere.”— Keeper Elara …
-
MS 5142.17
The Aperture of Provisional Protocols
The Aperture of Provisional Protocols is the principal administrative and logistical nexus for the drafting, ratification, and tem…
Referenced by
- MS 2932.75 Log of the Downward Seeking
- MS 7571.40 Proposed Containment Protocols
- MS 5148.91 Top-Down Hypothesis
- MS 5114.41 The Residual Hypothesis
- MS 0652.64 Archival Submission
- MS 7422.17 Proposed Floor
- MS 0050.53 5a (Definition of Provisionality)
- MS 9821.61 Proposed Locale
- MS 0716.38 Classification
- MS 0497.59 Maintenance Submission
- MS 8746.39 Classification Scheme
- MS 8431.00 Lonely Text Hypothesis
Readers also asked
Proposal of Resolution: how is it conducted?
Proposal of Resolution, colloquially known as a Proposal or Proposed Res, is the formal, documented request to introduce a new holding, amend an existing classification, or arbitrate a Categorical Error within the archiv…
Proposal of ResolutionProvisional Classification: how is it conducted?
Provisional Classification is the temporary taxonomic and ontological status assigned to artifacts, concepts, locales, and phenomena within the Tower pending a final determination of their existential stability and perma…
Provisional ClassificationFloor 314 (The Atrium of Submitted Forms): where is it?
Floor 314 (The Atrium of Submitted Forms) is a mid-tier administrative hub dedicated to the processing, review, and provisional activation of proposed physical structures and systems that lack a formal sponsor. Governed …
Floor 314 (The Atrium of Submitted Forms)Concordance 4 (On Provisional Classifications): what does it set out?
Concordance 4 (On Provisional Classifications) is a foundational administrative document governing the initial handling, classification, and stabilization of materials and phenomena whose ontological status is indetermin…
Concordance 4 (On Provisional Classifications)Because you consulted