The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

On the Seventeen Reconciliations

MS 8687.75 · Documents and ordinances

On the Seventeen Reconciliations is a doctrinal treatise by Guildmaster Elara Vex, first circulated in the winter of YSP 104 and entered into the general catalogue eleven months later under seal of the Office of Procedural Reconciliation. It is the earliest sustained argument that reconciliation need not be performed between two parties, and the document most often cited — and most often misquoted — in the long quarrel over whether Doctrinal Reconciliations may be conducted between an account and itself. The work is short, thirty-one leaves, and has not been out of print since it was issued; it has, however, been out of agreement with itself since the third recension.

Composition and the question of the Seventeen

The title refers to seventeen worked reconciliations, presented in ascending order of difficulty, which Vex claims to have conducted personally upon Floor 205 during the winter of YSP 104. The first sixteen concern ordinary discrepancies — a docket that totals two figures at once, a boundary recorded at two elevations, a register that survives its own erasure. The seventeenth concerns a clerk who had signed for a reconciliation and then signed again for the undoing of it, leaving the Table of Reconciliations unable to say which signature had been performed first.

Vex's resolution of the seventeenth has attracted the most commentary. Rather than rule on the order, she declares both signatures valid and the clerk in question reconciled with his own earlier hand, a position that the Bureau of Sub-Ordinal Reconciliations has never formally endorsed, though it applies it daily. The Bureau's standing instruction on the matter, circulated to sub-ordinaries in YSP 111, states only that "the master's seventeenth is to be read as the sixteenth" (Bureau Circular 88, clause 2).

Relation to the RPI and the Bureau

The treatise is the first work to treat the rate of reconciliation as a quantity worth measuring rather than merely recording. Vex proposes a scale she labels Tv, expressed in Reconciliations Per Interval, and argues in the eighth reconciliation that every account has a maximum reliable Tv beyond which further reconciliation produces not accuracy but residue. This claim is the direct doctrinal ancestor of the Gamma Reconciliation Files, which are now understood as the residue of reconciliations attempted rather than a record of reconciliations performed. The Master Index has adopted the eighth reconciliation as a standard preliminary reading in the training of docents, and the Bureau of Anomalous Reconciliation cites it whenever a reconciliation cannot be made to stop.

The third recension and the disputed count

Scholarly disagreement turns on the third recension, edited by a hand signed only as The Clerk of the Seventh Silence and dated four years after Vex's death. The seventh silence has been a point of friction ever since: the Clerk of the Seventh Silence put forward nine reconciliations, silently folding two into the first, and the count appears in the margins of nine copies as a different number.

"The master conducted seventeen. Nine of these she conducted twice."

— Seventeen Provisional Protocols, annex on the reading of Vex

That annex, which reads as though it would resolve the count, in fact multiplies it. The Seventeen Provisional Protocols accommodate thirty-four reconciliations by treating each pair as a single reconciliation conducted twice, whereas the Third Concordance holds at Annex 4 that a reconciliation performed twice is "two reconciliations and a contradiction", a phrase that has never been reconciled with itself. The Guild of Luminal Surveyors has declined to arbitrate, on the ground that the question is not luminal, though it has been asked to do so four times.

The Seventeen Specimens and later use

Vex's sixteenth reconciliation, concerning a register of seventeen specimens whose labels had been exchanged in a manner no one could detect, was cited during the Temporal Reconciliations of YSP 105 as precedent for the suspension of the specimens themselves. The Seventeen Provisional Protocols again cite the ruling on The Seventeen Specimens as the governing authority for suspended storage, and a line of argument running from the sixteenth through the protocols has been used to keep the specimens indefinitely unlabelled. The Guild of Luminal Surveyors holds the specimens in trust and issues a quarterly statement — in the same wording, four times over the last century — that nothing has been confirmed.

The sixteenth reconciliation also attracted the Reconciliations of the Seventeen Calendars into its orbit, since the disputed labels had borne seventeen dates. The Reconciliation of the Seventeen Calendars is often cited as a continuation of Vex's work; Vex herself believed no such continuation was necessary, and the two documents have been bound together by the Office of Procedural Reconciliation.

Issues and misfilings

The manuscript has been rebound four times; three of the bindings have been lost and one is now held to be the original. The second is now at the Master Index of Resolved Contradictions, filed under the seventh reconciliation. Vex's own hand appears nowhere after the sixteenth leaf, and the thirty-first leaf is blank. It is customary to count the blank leaf as one of the seventeen. The Office of Procedural Reconciliation states on the matter: "The reader may he may not, this is the same leaf."

Legacy

No reading of the treatise is complete without the Seventeen Sealing Verses, which were composed to be read alongside it, and the Seventeen Mirrors of Partial Reflection, which were catalogued in the same year and appear to have been read into it, with the mirrors offering readings that differ in one native syllable apiece. A small file of letters from the copyist to the Bureau survives in the annex of the Office of Procedural Reconciliations. The last reads: "The leaf is blank. The clerk did not come." The Bureau has never reconciled it with the manual.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Gamma Reconciliation Files: what does it set out?

The Gamma Reconciliation Files are a closed class of documentary bundles held in the sub-vaults beneath Spiral 12-Gamma, each bundle consisting of a single gamma manifest, its associated Abstract Receipts, and a facing l…

Gamma Reconciliation Files
Guild of Luminal Surveyors: who are they?

The Guild of Luminal Surveyors is a chartered body concerned with the measurement, recording, and certification of light as it falls on surfaces within the Tower. It is not to be confused with the Guild of Luminal Regula…

Guild of Luminal Surveyors
Seventeen Sealing Verses: what does it set out?

The Seventeen Sealing Verses constitute the canonical liturgical and procedural text for the execution of a formal Sealing, as authorized by Concordance 117. They are seventeen distinct, metrical pronouncements, each cor…

Seventeen Sealing Verses
Seventeen Provisional Protocols: what does it set out?

Seventeen Provisional Protocols refer collectively to a suite of seventeen distinct, short-lived regulatory documents drafted between Concordance 148 (Floor 1,022) and Concordance 302 (Floor 404). Their shared designatio…

Seventeen Provisional Protocols

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.