The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Bureau of Anomalous Reconciliation

MS 0342.51 · Practices and doctrines

Scope and standing

Bureau of Anomalous Reconciliation is a standing body of the Tower administration charged with the disposition of reconciliations that cannot be assigned to any ordinary reconciling authority without that authority objecting. It is the successor-of-record to the arrangements displaced by the Reconciliation Bureau, and it is chronically confused with that body, with the Office of Procedural Reconciliation, and — on at least three documented occasions — with the Bureau of Concordant Reconciliation, a confusion that has cost the archive four volumes and one stairwell.

The Bureau occupies Floors 411-C, 411-D and a half-floor between them that appears on no register of the Bureau of Architectural Integrity but which the Bureau has held under seal since the winter of the Long Indexing. Its founding instrument is the Eighth Concordance, Annex 19, though the Bureau's own seal reads "by Provision," and it has never satisfactorily explained which provision.

Origins

The Bureau was constituted to receive matters referred by the Bureau of Dimensional Reconciliation after that body declined, in the matter of the Landing of Asymmetric Hours, to rule on a discrepancy it described as "not a disagreement between parties but a disagreement between outcomes." The referral travelled for eleven months through the Office of Unitary Reconciliation before arriving at a door marked, in a hand later attributed to the Sub-Warden of Seals, anomalous.

The word did the work. Once "anomalous" was attached, no existing bureau could decline the file without conceding that the matter fell within its own definition of the ordinary. The Bureau of Anomalous Reconciliation was therefore created as a place where files could rest without anyone having to define them. Its first Registrar, Havelok of the Fourth Antechamber, recorded the founding in a single line of his daybook: "Opened. Twelve doors. None of them the one they meant."

Methods

The Bureau does not adjudicate; it receives. A matter before it is entered in the Anomalous Register, given a Provisional Concordance Number, and then held pending clarification of what sort of thing it is. In practice this means the Bureau maintains, at any given time, between nine hundred and one thousand four hundred open entries, of which the standing internal estimate is that approximately sixty will ever close.

Where clarification becomes unavoidable, the Bureau applies the technique known as adjacent citation: it cites a nearby axiomatically reconciled matter whose facts are close enough to be instructive and far enough to be unbinding. The technique was formalised by Registrar Ilva Thenn in the Winter of Papers, and remains contested. The Bureau of Conceptual Reconciliation has criticised it as "citation at a distance," and the Office of Procedural Reconciliation has twice attempted to require that adjacent citations be filed at least three corridors from the matter they annotate; the second attempt was withdrawn when it was discovered that no corridor in the relevant wing measured three corridors from anything.

"An anomalous reconciliation is not a reconciliation that has gone wrong. It is a reconciliation whose wrongness is the finding."

— Registrar Ilva Thenn, Eighth Concordance, Annex 19, marginal gloss

Disputed jurisdiction

The Bureau's principal difficulty is that other bodies continue to refer matters to it that they are in fact obliged to settle themselves. The Bureau of Concordant Reconciliation refers anything bearing the word "discordant"; the Sub-Bureau of Temporal Reconciliation refers entries whose dates disagree with the Temporal Reconciliation Protocol by more than a fiscal season; and the Acoustic Reconciliation Bureau has, since the Screaming Pillars dispute, referred all resonant cases on the grounds that the Tower's own structure is "anomalous with respect to silence." The Bureau has accepted none of these claims in full, and has accepted all of them in part, which is why its register contains a section headed simply accepted in part with no corresponding heading for the remainder.

A more durable feud concerns the definition of "anomalous" itself. The Bureau of Anomalous Topology holds that anomaly is a property of a floor's geometry and has asserted standing claim to any matter where the two parties cannot be located at a stable distance from one another. The Bureau of Anomalous Reconciliation counters that distance is not the anomaly but the symptom. Neither position has prevailed. The two bodies maintain parallel registers, and a matter may now be open in both, closed in one, and never opened in the other, with no rule governing which sequence is authoritative.

Notable entries

Among the Bureau's longest-running open entries is Provisional Concordance Number 4, the matter of the Stairwell That Reported Itself Already Counted, held since the winter of the Long Indexing and referred three times to the Bureau of Architectural Integrity, which returns it each time with the note that a stairwell cannot be a party. Entry 217 concerns a set of ledger discrepancies that Procedures for Ledger Reconciliation formally addresses but which the Bureau retains on the grounds that the discrepancies reconcile only when unobserved, a condition the Procedures do not contemplate.

Entry 911 — the missing annex of the Third Concordance — is believed by the Bureau's own archivists to have been misplaced during the Winter of Papers, though the Bureau of Concordant Reconciliation maintains it never existed. The two offices have agreed, in a rare instrument, to file their disagreement as a single joint entry rather than two opposing ones; the entry remains open, which both parties regard as a success.

Notes on visiting

Visitors are admitted to Floor 411-C on the third and ninth day of each month. Tea is not permitted in the register room; the reason is recorded in the Sixth Concordance but the clause has been struck and re-inscribed so often that the current text reads only tea, and the reason. Visitors are asked not to bring their own numbering systems, as these have been known to be adopted.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Bureau of Concordant Reconciliation: how is it conducted?

The Bureau of Concordant Reconciliation is an administrative office of the Tower charged with identifying and adjudicating conflicts between the Concordances. It is distinct from the Committee of Concordant Reconciliatio…

Bureau of Concordant Reconciliation
the Tower: where is it?

The Tower is an administrative-territorial entity and archival structure of indeterminate vertical extent, operating under the aegis of The Librarians. It is the sole known locus for the formal cataloguing and containmen…

the Tower
Sixth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…

Sixth Concordance
Office of Unitary Reconciliation: who are they?

The Office of Unitary Reconciliation (OUR) is a constituent bureau of the Reconciliation Apparatus, established by the Third Concordance and charged with the sole authority to certify, unify, and where necessary provisio…

Office of Unitary Reconciliation

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.