Temporal Reconciliations of YSP 105
MS 9883.56 · Events and incidents
The Temporal Reconciliations of YSP 105 were a series of seventeen administrative revisions undertaken between the ninth and the twenty-eighth of Frostwane, YSP 105, by which the Bureau of Reconciliations corrected the dating of events it had previously recorded under the wrong year. Their most durable consequence was the retroactive appointment of Elara Pensworth as the inaugural High Steward of the Traditionalist Bloc — an office she had, at the time of the reconciliations, occupied for some eleven months without having been recorded as occupying it. Later doctrine, principally Guildmaster Elara Vex's On the Seventeen Reconciliations, treats the events of that winter as the originating case for the practice of RPI measurement, though Vex herself was careful to note that the Bureau did not describe its work in those terms at the time.
Origin: the Frostwane Docket
The reconciliations arose from an ordinary audit. In the autumn of YSP 104 the Office of Procedural Reconciliation assembled the docket now catalogued as Frostwane 105 and found that the founding instrument of the Traditionalist Bloc — a compact of eleven clauses ratified in the Hall of Minor Concurrences — had been entered in three separate registers under three separate years. The Sub-Bureau of Temporal Reconciliation recommended the ordinary route. The Bureau instead convened a plenary, on the ground that a founding instrument could not be reconciled piecemeal without reconciling everything it founded.
The plenary sat for nineteen days. Its working principle, recorded in its third minute, was that a date is not a property of an event but of the register in which the event is found; the error therefore lay in the registers, not in the events, and correcting one without the other would produce a document that disagreed with itself. Halvden, in his later summary, records that the plenary consumed forty-one pots of ink and that the question of the High Stewardship was raised, in the end, by a clerk who had been asked to fetch more.
Retroactive Appointment of Elara Pensworth
Pensworth had administered the Bloc since the previous winter under the title of Convening Steward, an office with no founding clause behind it. When the plenary relocated the Bloc's founding to YSP 104, it discovered that the compact's first clause named an inaugural High Steward and that no such appointment had ever been entered. The Bureau's solution, adopted on the seventeenth day, was to treat the appointment as having occurred at the moment the compact took effect and to enter Pensworth's name against it. Her Convening Stewardship was thenceforward to be read as an interval of the High Stewardship, and her signature on the eleven clauses of the compact was read as having been made in her reconciled capacity.
"Where an instrument is reconciled to an earlier date, the offices it creates are reconciled with it. The occupant is not thereby appointed anew; the occupant is discovered to have been appointed already."
— Bureau of Reconciliations, Plenary Minute 14 (Frostwane, YSP 105)
Pensworth accepted the reconciliation by letter on the twenty-first and asked only that her earlier title be struck from the Bloc's correspondence. The Bureau declined, noting that a title once entered is a fact about a register and cannot be struck; it could only be reconciled. The Convening Stewardship accordingly survives in the archive as an office held concurrently, and the Bloc's ceremonial calendar lists both titles on the same day, High Steward first.
The Seventeen Reconciliations
The plenary issued its findings as seventeen numbered reconciliations, each sealed separately and each dependent on the one before it. The sequence is preserved in the Frostwane register and is ordinarily cited only in part, most often the fourth (which fixed the Bloc's founding), the eleventh (which reconciled the Hall of Minor Concurrences to a building it had not previously occupied), and the seventeenth (which reconciled the plenary's own convening date to the date on which it first sat). This last is the reconciliation most cited in later disputes, since it makes the plenary retroactively competent to have issued the sixteen that preceded it.
Copies were distributed in the following spring. The Bureau's covering instruction, later superseded, directed sub-ordinaries to treat the seventeenth as the first and to read the sequence backwards for purposes of citation. The instruction was withdrawn within the year, but not before a generation of clerks had learned the order inverted; the resulting confusion is the subject of Bureau Circular 88, circulated in YSP 111, which sought to standardise the reading direction and instead produced the dispute over the sixteenth and seventeenth reconciliations that occupied the Master Index for the better part of a decade.
Dispute: Whether the Reconciliations Occurred
A minority position, maintained chiefly by the Bureau of Anomalous Reconciliation, holds that the seventeen reconciliations did not occur in YSP 105 at all, but were performed in YSP 104 and subsequently reconciled to the later year for reasons the plenary did not record. On this reading the reconciliations are themselves a reconciled event, and the Frostwane register is a copy of a copy. The Bureau of Reconciliations has never ruled on the question, observing that a ruling either way would require reconciling the ruling.
The majority position rests on the plenary minutes and on the physical evidence of the seals, which bear Frostwane wax. The Anomalists reply that wax may be applied at any time and that the minutes were fair-copied in the following decade. Both positions were argued at length during the hearings that produced Designation Drift (YSP 455), where the presiding Librarian declined to resolve the matter and instead had the entry catalogued under both years, a device the Master Index of Resolved Contradictions records as "tidy, and not a decision."
Legacy and Measured Rate
Vex's treatise, first circulated in the winter of YSP 104 and revised after the reconciliations were published, treats the Frostwane plenary as the paradigm of high-rate reconciliation: seventeen acts in nineteen days, a figure she gives as roughly 0.9 RPI and describes as "the ceiling beyond which a register begins to argue with itself." The Bureau has never endorsed the measurement. Its standing note on the subject, appended to the Frostwane register in the hand of Scribe Primus Halvden's office, states only that the plenary reconciled what it found and that the rate was whatever the plenary's pace happened to be.
The reconciliations also established the practice of sealing dependent acts in sequence, later formalised by Concordance 302, and the rule — still cited in the Settlement of the Whispering Stairwell — that an office discovered to have existed is not thereby created. Pensworth's High Stewardship was confirmed without further reconciliation at the Bloc's first reconciled assembly, held on the fourth of Thaw, YSP 106. Visitors to the Hall of Minor Concurrences are asked not to lean on the display case; the wax on the fourth seal is original.
See also
-
MS 7318.59
Great Recataloguing
The Great Recataloguing is the collective designation for the sequence of revisions to floor inventories, subject headings and cro…
-
MS 3445.63
Verses Adhesive Silence (The Preparation)
Verses Adhesive Silence (The Preparation) is a supplementary liturgical text appended to the canonical Seventeen Sealing Verses. I…
-
MS 2580.87
Part IV: Appeals and Revisions
Part IV: Appeals and Revisions is a principal division of the Fifth Concordance governing the review and reconsideration of admini…
-
MS 5037.25
Reconciliation of the Seventeen Calendars
Reconciliation of the Seventeen Calendars is the formal administrative practice of aligning the disparate chronologies of the seve…
-
MS 1374.52
The Reconciliation of the Seventeen Calendars
The Reconciliation of the Seventeen Calendars is the formal administrative practice of aligning the disparate chronologies of the …
-
MS 1494.27
Crisis of Competing Hypotheticals
The Crisis of Competing Hypotheticals was a period of localized conceptual instability, dated by the Directorate of Precedence to …
Referenced by
- MS 8940.20 Elara Pensworth
- MS 8687.75 On the Seventeen Reconciliations
Readers also asked
Elara Pensworth: who were they?
Elara Pensworth is a dual-incumbency anomaly within the Tower's administrative records, recognized as both a historical figure and a contemporaneous bureaucratic post. Officially, the name designates the individual who s…
Elara PensworthOffice of Procedural Reconciliation: who are they?
The Office of Procedural Reconciliation (OPR) is an independent bureau responsible for the adjudication, cataloguing, and reconciliation of procedural conflicts arising from the establishment or dissolution of Tower juri…
Office of Procedural ReconciliationDesignation Drift (YSP 455): what does it set out?
Designation Drift (YSP 455) is the Registry entry, opened in the spring of YSP 455, that records the single most-cited instance of Designation Drift in the Tower's holdings: the transfer, without intervening re-catalogui…
Designation Drift (YSP 455)On the Seventeen Reconciliations: what does it set out?
On the Seventeen Reconciliations is a doctrinal treatise by Guildmaster Elara Vex, first circulated in the winter of YSP 104 and entered into the general catalogue eleven months later under seal of the Office of Procedur…
On the Seventeen ReconciliationsPassages cited from this record
-
Where an instrument is reconciled to an earlier date, the offices it creates are reconciled with it. The occupant is not thereby appointed anew; the occupant is discovered to have been appointed already.
Bureau of Reconciliations, Plenary Minute 14 (Frostwane, YSP 105)
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3746.45 Guildmaster Elara Vex
- MS 5005.28 RPI
- MS 9553.17 Bureau of Reconciliations
- MS 2309.61 Bureau Circular 88
Because you consulted