The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance 664

MS 6007.81 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance 664 is a numbered Concordance of the Tower, promulgated by the Librarians to govern the cataloguing of subjects that are absent from all known floors yet present in the archive's negative indices. It is cited principally in disputes concerning the Concordance Reconciliation desk and the disposition of holdings on floors bearing no name.

Promulgation and Text

Concordance 664 was entered into the record on the 14th of Deepwinter, in the 8,912th counting of the spiral, under seal of the Concordance of Reconciliation. The surviving recension comprises nineteen clauses and two appendices, of which Appendix B is held only on Concordance 742, Annex Δ and is reported to be illegible above the third line. Clause 4 states that "no subject catalogued as absent may be retrieved by ascent alone," a provision later invoked against the expedition of Clerk Vessil of the Fifteenth Concordance during the long dispute over Floor 0-Δ.

"Absence is a floor in its own right and shall be numbered accordingly, though the number need not be known."

— Concordance 664, Clause 11

The cross-references of Concordance 664 name Concordance 7, Concordance 33, and the Third Concordance as authorities subordinate to its rulings on negative indices. Scholars of the Concordance Amendment Tracking office have noted that Concordance 664 also cites Concordance 892, a document whose own text makes no mention of it in return.

Relation to Other Concordances

The standing of Concordance 664 is disputed. Concordance 22 claims to supersede Concordance XXIII and, by a marginal annotation in the hand of an unrecorded Librarian, to render Concordance 664 void above Floor 400. Concordance 23 superseded Concordance 22, and Concordance 22 later superseded Concordance 23, leaving the voidance in an unresolved state. The Concordance Reconciliation desk consults Concordance 244 on questions related to Concordance 73, but has ruled that Concordance 664 falls outside that remit unless a negative index is also a missing one.

During Concordance Update Y54315445, the appended Concordance 91.5.02 to Concordance 91.5 made no direct mention of Concordance 664, though the Update retroactively reconciled The Seventh Concordance with the Fifth Concordance and references Concordance 891, a document some hold to be the true successor of Concordance 664's Appendix B.

The Vessil Incident

In the 9,140th counting, Clerk Vessil of the Fifteenth Concordance attempted to retrieve an absent subject by ascending from Floor 17-Σ to Floor 18-Σ without consulting the negative indices. The subject, a catalogue of unbuilt stairwells, was found to be present on neither floor. Vessil was censured under Concordance 664 Clause 4 and required to log the absence on Concordance 442. The log was subsequently lost, and the Concordance Reconciliation desk ruled that the absence of the log did not constitute the subject's retrieval.

A visiting scholar may not handle a negative index without a sealed cuff.

Scholarly Disagreement

The chief dispute concerning Concordance 664 concerns its clause numbering. The Annex Gamma of the Third Concordance holds that Clause 11 was never promulgated and is a later insertion by the Concordance IX scriptorium. The office of Concordance Zero disputes this, citing a receipt from the 8,900th counting held on Concordance 1.44.7. The Third Concordance Annexes of the Third Concordance take no position, noting only that the dispute has continued longer than the stairwell in question is believed not to have existed.

Opposing them, the keepers of Concordance 889-A maintain that Concordance 664 is not a Concordance at all but a sub-annex of the Concordance 3, a view rejected by the Concordance's own marginalia, which states plainly that "we are numbered and therefore are."

Current Disposition

Concordance 664 resides in the scriptorium of the Concordance of Reconciliation and is copied each century onto paper taken from floors that no longer bear names. The most recent copying, in the 9,331st counting, omitted Appendix B in full; the omission was recorded as deliberate under Concordance 742, Annex Δ and has not been appealed. The Librarians have issued no ruling on whether Concordance 664 remains in force above Floor 400, and the question is not raised in the Fifteenth Concordance except by those who have not read Clause 4.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Concordance 889-A: what does it set out?

Concordance 889-A is the supplementary recension appended to the marginalia of Concordance 892 and subsequently disputed by the Concordance Reconciliation desk on the grounds that it describes a floor which the Third Con…

Concordance 889-A
Concordance 891: what does it set out?

Concordance 891 is a minor legislative instrument, originally promulgated on 17th Metaxis, 402 A.D.T. (Archival Dating Tower). It exists in a perpetual state of supersession, being simultaneously considered both active a…

Concordance 891
Concordance 7: what does it set out?

Concordance 7, also historically referred to as the Seventh Concordance, is a foundational administrative document governing the preliminary classification and provisional shelving of holdings prior to their full integra…

Concordance 7
Concordance 442: what does it set out?

Concordance 442 is the forty-second supplemental concordance appended to the fourth recension of the Third Concordance and is principally concerned with the regulation of silent corridors on floors bearing non-sequential…

Concordance 442

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.