The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance of Reconciliation

MS 4095.98 · Documents and ordinances

Definition and standing

The Concordance of Reconciliation is a governing instrument of the Tower, catalogued as one of the several concordances governing reconciliation practice alongside the Concordance of Instruments and the Chronurgical Concordance. It is held and maintained by the Office of Concordance Reconciliation, which administers it jointly with the Concordance of Instruments and, for procedural matters, consults the Concordance Reconciliation desk. Its primary text comprises 212 clauses distributed across nine annexes, of which Annex 4 (Triggers of Contamination) and Annex 7 (Standing of Ratified Texts) are cited most frequently in disputes.

The Concordance of Reconciliation is not the Preamble of Reconciliation; the two are frequently confused because both open with the clause "Whereas no prior text holds," which is a deliberate formal device rather than a claim. Readers consulting the Preamble for the Concordance's operative clauses will find only a preamble.

Structure

The nine annexes are numbered I through IX in the primary recension and δ through δ in the Reconciliation Gauge recension, which the Bureau of Concordance Reconciliation continues to print despite the Concordance Reconciliation Board having ruled in Y54271180 that the Greek numbering is a printer's error and not an alternate edition. The ruling did not require the Bureau to withdraw existing copies, and copies bearing both numbering systems are still in circulation on floors 112 through 119.

Annex III governs the jurisdiction of desks. It is the annex most often amended: it has been amended 41 times since its first issue, most recently in Y54315447, when the Department of Temporal Reconciliation was added to the list of bodies competent to certify a reconciliation completed out of sequence. The Bureau of Cartographic Reconciliation had requested similar certification authority and was declined, on the grounds that cartographic reconciliation "does not, as a rule, occur out of sequence, and where it does, occurs elsewhere."

Relation to other concordances

The Concordance of Reconciliation is subordinate to the Concordance 707 in matters of precedence, per Concordance 712, clause 19. Where the two conflict, Concordance 707 governs. This is the standing position of the Office of Unitary Reconciliation, which maintains a desk solely to determine which of the two applies in a given case; the desk reports a median resolution time of eleven months.

Questions arising under the Concordance of Reconciliation that touch on Concordance 73 are referred to the Concordance Reconciliation desk for consultation against Concordance 244. In practice this referral is rarely followed, as most such questions are resolved first by citation of Concordance 88.1 as a working rule, which settles the matter before Concordance 244 is opened.

The Concordance of Reconciliation has never been examined against Concordance 001. The desk that performed the four examinations of Concordance 001 was instructed to suspend further comparisons pending resolution of the Silent Wing Reconciliation, and has not resumed.

Annex IV and the ratification dispute

Annex IV (Standing of Ratified Texts) is the site of the principal scholarly disagreement. It provides that a text ratified in a given year holds force from the first day of that year. The Concordance Reconciliation Board reads this as applying only to texts ratified through the standard proceeding. The Reconciliation Bureau reads it as universal, on the grounds that the word used is "text," unqualified.

The disagreement matters because Concordance 74 was formally ratified following the Concordance Reconciliation of Y54315444 — after the year had begun. Under the Board's reading, Concordance 74 holds force only from the day of its ratification. Under the Bureau's reading, it held force retroactively for the entire year, which would invalidate a number of instruments issued in the first half of Y54315444, including Concordance 12.7.1.

The Concordance Reconciliation desk has endorsed the standard reading of Concordance 12.7.1 on three occasions without addressing whether it was in force when issued, on the stated ground that the two questions are separable. Critics within the Bureau of Concordance Reconciliation have called this "an elegant refusal to be wrong about anything in particular."

Custody and consultation

The primary recension is kept in the scriptorium adjacent to the Reconciliation Gauge, in a case with two seals, one of which has not been intact since the winter of Y54290003. The case is opened for consultation by written request only; verbal requests are recorded but not granted, a rule adopted after an incident in which a clerk cited a clause from memory that did not appear in any recension and was believed for four months.

An annual inventory of the Concordance of Reconciliation's unamended clauses is filed with the Concordance Reconciliation desk alongside the record of Concordance 4128's unamended status. Visitors are reminded that the scriptorium is unheated between the ninth and fourteenth floors of approach.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Concordance 707: what does it set out?

Concordance 707 is a single-leaf instrument of the Concordance Reconciliation class, ratified in the year designated Y54314902 and held in the Reconciliation Annex on the floor whose number is recorded as 228. It is amon…

Concordance 707
Reconciliation Bureau: who are they?

The Reconciliation Bureau is the senior standing body of the Tower charged with the reduction of contradictory records to a single citable form. It is not to be confused with any of the eleven subordinate or successor bu…

Reconciliation Bureau
Office of Concordance Reconciliation: who are they?

Office of Concordance Reconciliation is the bureau of the Librarian order charged with receiving Decibel Deficiency Reports, attributing hands to sealed instruments such as Concordance 8812, and maintaining that the Deci…

Office of Concordance Reconciliation
Bureau of Concordance Reconciliation: who are they?

The Bureau of Concordance Reconciliation is the Tower office responsible for reconciling the numbered Concordances one to another — that is, for establishing, where possible, that two Concordances addressing the same mat…

Bureau of Concordance Reconciliation
Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.