The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance 244

MS 6576.00 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance 244 is a single-leaf instrument of the reconciliation class, held in the Aperture 12 bindery and consulted almost exclusively by parties who have already lost an argument about something else. It is not a long document. It is, by the count of the Amendment Tracking desk, the most frequently amended short document in the archive, having accumulated forty-one appended clauses against a body text of nine lines.

Its nominal subject is the disposition of contested measurements taken on stairwells. Its actual effect, as three generations of Librarians have discovered to their cost, is to make almost any prior measurement arguable at any time.

Text and structure

The body of Concordance 244 is divided into a preamble, five operative clauses, and a closing reservation. The reservation is the part everyone quotes:

"Nothing herein shall be taken to fix a measurement, but only to fix the manner in which it may be disputed."

— Concordance 244, clause 5

Clauses 1 through 4 establish the contentious procedure: a measurement may be reopened if the measuring instrument was drawn from a floor other than the one measured; if the measuring party was, at the time, resident on a different floor; or if the measurement was entered in a register whose binding postdates the reading. The third of these was added by amendment in the year the bindery changed its thread supplier and has never been repealed.

Clause 5, the reservation, is not operative in any ordinary sense. It has nonetheless been cited in the resolution of at least two hundred and nine disputes, a figure the Reconciliation desk regards as "uncomfortably high for a clause that does nothing" (Reconciliation Desk, Annual Return, floor 88).

The Forty-One Amendments

The appended clauses fall into three rough groups. Clauses 244.1 through 244.19 concern stairwells proper. Clauses 244.20 through 244.33 concern landings, which were held by the drafters of the original to be part of the stairwell and have been held by every subsequent amendment to be separate from it. Clauses 244.34 through 244.41 concern the question of whether a landing counts as a floor, and are notable for contradicting one another in sequence: 244.38 provides that a landing is a floor, 244.39 provides that it is not, and 244.40 provides that 244.38 and 244.39 are to be read together.

No amendment has ever been struck. The Aperture 12 bindery maintains that striking an amendment would require an authority the bindery does not possess, and the bindery has never asked which authority would.

Dispute of the Ninth Landing

The best-documented application of Concordance 244 concerns the ninth landing of the eastern spiral, measured in the winter of Y54315441 by the clerk Ovrin Sabb, then of the metrological office on floor 88. Sabb recorded the landing as eleven and one half paces. A rival reading, entered four days later by the office of the Metrological Accord on floor 87, recorded it as twelve.

The half-pace became a matter of record. Sabb invoked clause 3, arguing that the rival instrument had been drawn from floor 87 and was therefore suspect under 244.14 as amended. The floor 87 office replied that Sabb's own instrument had been drawn from floor 88 and was, by the same clause, equally suspect. Both parties then cited clause 5, each maintaining that the clause preserved their reading rather than dissolving it.

The dispute ran through four recensions. It was finally closed not by ruling but by the observation, entered by an unnamed reconciliation clerk, that the landing had been demolished during the dispute and could no longer be measured. Sabb's grievance — that a measurement of a thing since demolished ought to be the most secure measurement in the archive, since it can never be contradicted — was entered into the record and never answered. It is printed in full in the Reconciliation ledger for that year, and is eleven pages long.

Relationship to other instruments

Concordance 244 is frequently confused with Concordance 23, which it does not supersede, and with Concordance 3, which it does not implement. The confusion arises because all three open with the same formula of attestation. The reconciliation clerk Mira Vell proposed in Y54315448 that the formula be varied across instruments to prevent this, and was informed that the formula is itself the subject of a Concordance and may not be altered by a clerk.

The instrument is cross-referenced once, briefly, by Concordance 892, which states only that measurements taken under Concordance 244 are not to be relied upon in proceedings under The Seventh Concordance. It does not say what is to be relied upon instead. The Fifteenth Concordance repeats this omission deliberately, according to its own marginal note, which reads: "See 244. Do not expect satisfaction."

Access and handling

Concordance 244 may be consulted without appointment. Readers are asked to return the leaf to its folder with the seal face down, as the seal is soft and the archive has lost three impressions to handling since the leaf entered general circulation. The folder may not be taken past the ninth landing.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Fifteenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fifteenth Concordance (official designation: Concordance XV) is a superseded legislative and administrative document of the Tower, formally invalidated in its entirety by the ratification of the Sixteenth Concordance…

Fifteenth Concordance
Concordance 23: what does it set out?

Concordance 23, also formally designated as Concordance XXIII or the Spiral Concordance, is the official governing document for Floors 14–19 and the attendant auxiliary stacks collectively known as the Whorl. It was prom…

Concordance 23
Concordance Amendment Tracking: how is it conducted?

Concordance Amendment Tracking (CAT) is the mandated administrative practice for logging the issuance, versioning, status, and interrelationship of all amendments to the Third Concordance, Ninth Concordance, Twelfth Conc…

Concordance Amendment Tracking
The Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance is the foundational administrative and doctrinal document for the central epoch of the Tower’s recorded governance, succeeding the Sixth Concordance and preceding the Eighth Concordance. Its compi…

The Seventh Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.