The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance 1022

MS 5198.01 · Documents and ordinances

Scope and designation

Concordance 1022 is a governance document of the Tower, catalogued under the four-digit series begun in the late recension period. It is best known for establishing the procedure now called the 1022 Stipend, by which a floor may petition the Librarians for the right to catalogue a subject it has not yet finished describing. The document comprises fourteen clauses, three annexes, and a preamble whose wording has been revised twice — in Y54315445 and again under provisions of Concordance Amendment Tracking. Concordance 1022 is frequently confused with Concordance 892 and with the earlier 72nd Concordance, on the grounds that all three address the matter of incomplete catalogues. The three are not compatible. See §Disputes below.

Text and structure

The document opens with the standard formula of the four-digit series:

"No floor shall be compelled to complete what it has begun, provided it has begun in good faith and recorded the date of beginning."

— Concordance 1022, Clause 1

Clause 4 establishes the Stipend itself: a floor holding an incomplete entry may file for a temporary designation, rendered in the ledger as a suffix (for example, 1022/a), which permits the entry to circulate among the desks without triggering the deficiency review ordinarily applied by Concordance Findings. The suffix is not permanent and lapses on the third renewal unless a reader objects in writing. Annex II of the document lists the seven floors that filed for Stipend designations in the first year of its operation. The list is annotated in a second hand, believed to belong to the scriptorium at Floor 912, and includes one floor that does not appear anywhere else in Tower records.

The 1022 Stipend

The Stipend is administered by the Concordance Reconciliation desk, which consults Concordance 244 on all renewal applications. In practice the Stipend has proven more durable than its drafters intended. As of the most recent count, sixty-one floors hold active Stipend suffixes, of which nineteen have been renewed more than four times. The record is held by Floor 3307 (designated 3307/f), whose entry on Concordance IX has been incomplete since the Y543 era and shows no sign of resolution. The Stipend's most contentious provision is Clause 9, which permits a floor to defer completion indefinitely provided it "continues to add to the record." Several floors have interpreted this to mean that appending a single line every third year constitutes continued labour. The Concordance Update Y54315445 was issued in part to address this reading, though its retrospective reconciliation of The Fifth Concordance with the Seventh Concordance did not extend to 1022.

Disputes

The relationship between Concordance 1022 and Concordance 23 (superseded in its entirety by Concordance 22) has been the subject of three separate rulings. The first, recorded in the Third Concordance, Annex VII, held that 1022's deferment provisions were void where the subject was itself a superseded document. The second ruling, entered under Concordance 3, reversed the first on procedural grounds. The third has not been located. A separate line of argument, associated with the scriptorium of Floor 912 and with the annotator known as Redacteur Δ, holds that Concordance 1022 was never properly issued at all, and that the text now circulating under that number is a composite of two draft fragments. Redacteur Δ's memorandum on the point runs to eleven pages and concludes with the observation that the Tower's difficulty is not that it catalogues what does not exist, but that it cannot agree on what it has already written. This view is not adopted by Concordance Reconciliation.

Subsequent influence

Though Concordance 1022 is a mid-numbered document of the later series, its Clause 4 has been cited more often than any other provision in the four-digit range. The Metrological Accord borrows its definition of "good faith beginning" verbatim. The Fifteenth Concordance refers to it obliquely. Floor 912's annotation, meanwhile, is now itself catalogued as a separate holding, and has been the subject of a Stipend application in its own right — an application that has been renewed, without comment from the desk, for eleven consecutive years. See also: Concordance Update Y54315445, Concordance Zero, Chronurgical Concordance

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

The Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance is the foundational administrative and doctrinal document for the central epoch of the Tower’s recorded governance, succeeding the Sixth Concordance and preceding the Eighth Concordance. Its compi…

The Seventh Concordance
Concordance IX: what does it set out?

Concordance IX, formally the Ninth Concordance, is a foundational administrative document and the first concordance to be entirely structured around the principle of recursive self-amendment. It established the legal and…

Concordance IX
Third Concordance, Annex VII: what does it set out?

Third Concordance, Annex VII is a supplementary legal and procedural document, one of forty-seven known annexes to the Third Concordance. While the primary Concordance established foundational principles for the Tower’s …

Third Concordance, Annex VII
Concordance Zero: how is it conducted?

Concordance Zero is the designation applied to a class of foundational, pre-concordant principles believed to have logically necessitated the establishment of The First Concordance. Unlike all subsequent numbered concord…

Concordance Zero

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.