The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance 712, Clause 3

MS 8149.31 · Documents and ordinances

Scope and status

Concordance 712, Clause 3 is a clause of the Concordance 712 and the standing instrument governing Ceremonial Inks within the Tower. It is catalogued on floor 712a, in the aisle reserved for instruments that have been cited more often than they have been read, and it is provisionally annotated in the margin of the register as "in force, pending clarification of scope." The annotation is unsigned, though the hand has been identified by two separate clerks as belonging to the Scriptorium of Lower Concordance, an attribution both clerks have since declined to repeat in writing.

Clause 3 sets out the conditions under which an ink may be designated ceremonial rather than ordinary; the authority of the Scriptorium to grant and withdraw that designation; and the consequences, for documents already bearing the ink, of a withdrawal. It does not define ink. This omission has been the subject of three separate challenges, none of which has concluded.

Designation of ceremonial inks

The Clause establishes a two-part test. An ink is ceremonial if it is (a) applied by a hand commissioned for the purpose, and (b) applied to a surface that the Sscriptorium has, by register entry, declared receptive. Neither limb is defined within the Clause itself; both are cross-referenced to Seventh Concordance, Annex D, Clause 1, which in turn amends Concordance 19, Clause 7 on an unrelated matter of shelf allocation. The cross-reference is widely regarded as a copying error of great antiquity, and no correction has been issued, because issuing one would require establishing which document the original scribe intended to cite — a question the Scriptorium has referred back to the Registrar of Amendments four times since the twenty-second recension.

Designation is recorded on the Ceremonial Ink Roll, a bound volume maintained at the junction of floors 712 and 714. As of the last counting, the Roll contains 4,318 entries, of which 611 have been struck through. Of those struck through, 48 were subsequently reinstated and 96 were struck through twice. The Roll is not arranged in any order that its keepers claim to understand; it is arranged, they state, in the order in which the inks dried.

Withdrawal and its consequences

Withdrawal of a ceremonial designation operates prospectively, according to the plain reading of Clause 3, subsection 7. Documents already sealed in the ink retain their standing. This reading was overturned for eleven years by the gloss attached to Third Concordance, Clause 809, which held that a withdrawn ink rendered every document bearing it "ornamental rather than operative." The gloss was applied with particular enthusiasm on floor 809, where an entire shelf of adjudications was relabelled and, in several cases, used to level a table. The gloss was itself superseded by Concordance 12, Clause 7, though the shelf has not been restored.

Two positions on the surviving force of pre-withdrawal documents remain in circulation. The Scriptorium holds, citing Third Concordance, Clause 19 and its provision for standing adjustments, that such documents are unaffected; the Registrar of Amendments holds that a document is only as good as the ink that carries it, and has refused, since the winter of the long inventory, to affix the departmental seal in anything but Ordinary Black. The dispute is recorded as unresolved in the margin of Clause 3, again unsigned.

Prohibited inks

Clause 3 names four inks that may never receive ceremonial designation regardless of commission or receptivity: Sedimentary Green, Any Ink Written In, the Ink of Uncertain Provenance (a category rather than a colour), and an entry that has been scraped from the parchment and replaced with a note reading "see Appendix, struck." The Appendix in question does not exist. Two enterprising clerks in the Scriptorium of Lower Concordance spent the winter of the twenty-fourth recension constructing an argument that the missing Appendix must therefore be the fourth prohibited ink, and that mentioning it at all was a contravention; the argument was received warmly and filed without action.

Ceremonial inks in practice

The best-known ceremonial ink is Sovereign Amber, designated in the year of the Fourth Recension and reserved for instruments of the Librarians. Its distinguishing property is that it does not fade; a document sealed in Sovereign Amber remains legible in the dark, which has occasionally caused difficulty in the archive stacks where darkness is used as a filing system. Amber is applied by a single commissioned hand at a time, a post that carries a stipend, a small brass key, and a formal obligation not to leave the Tower during any period in which the ink is wet — a period which, for Sovereign Amber, has not been determined.

The second most common ceremonial ink, Ash Grey, occupies an intermediate status that the Sscriptorium describes as "ceremonial for register purposes only." Its practical effect is that Ash Grey documents may be cited in dispute but may not be sealed, served, or used to close a door. This restriction originated as an emergency measure during the flood on the stairwells and has been retained, on the grounds that nobody has moved to repeal it.

Relation to other instruments

Clause 3 has been amended twice, both times from outside itself. Seventh Concordance, Clause 4 appended Clause D.1, which extended ceremonial designation to inks applied to glass — a provision the Sscriptorium initially resisted on the grounds that glass is not a surface, before conceding the point in the thirty-first recension. Concordance 47, Clause 9, the shortest clause in its document, reads in full: "Clause 3 of 712 stands." It is frequently cited, seldom with context, and has settled more disputes than it was written to settle.

The standing conflict between Clause 3 and the gloss on Third Concordance, Clause 809 remains the principal source of citation traffic on floor 712. Readers are reminded that the aisle is unlit between the hours of the third and fifth bell, and that the Roll may not be removed from its shelf under any circumstance, including fire.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Librarians: who are they?

The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…

Librarians
Concordance 19, Clause 7: what does it set out?

Concordance 19, Clause 7, formally titled "Obligations of Non-Existent Materials During Temporary Transfers," is a regulatory instrument governing the transit of catalogued subjects between floors, shelves, and Librarian…

Concordance 19, Clause 7
Third Concordance, Clause 809: what does it set out?

Third Concordance, Clause 809 is the eighty-ninth clause of the ninth recension of the Third Concordance, and the only clause in that instrument to consist entirely of a list of things that are not to be counted. It is s…

Third Concordance, Clause 809
Seventh Concordance, Clause 4: what does it set out?

Seventh Concordance, Clause 4 is the foundational clause of the Seventh Concordance, from which the recension derives its internal numbering, its order of precedence, and — according to the Office of Clause Integrity — i…

Seventh Concordance, Clause 4
Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.