The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance 288

MS 9132.58 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance 288 is a single-leaf instrument of the Librarians, ratified on 14 March of an unrecorded year and entered into the Spine Register under aperture mark 288-South. It is best known for containing no operative clause: the leaf consists of a preamble, a schedule of nine cancelled annexes, and a closing attestation, but the numbered body between them was omitted at the press. The omission has never been corrected, and Concordance 288 has consequently been cited in more disputes than almost any other short document in the archive, since it can be read as settling nearly anything.

Physical description and manufacture

The holding is a quarto leaf, 31 by 22 centimetres, struck on the lower press of the Scriptorium of the Ninth Landing and bearing the blind seal of that office at the foot. The paper stock is the coarse grey laid familiar from instruments of the middle recension. A repair is noted in the margin: the lower right corner was torn and re-backed in the winter of the year the Ninth Landing flooded, and the re-backing carries a different watermark, a small tower with three windows rather than the customary two.

Foliation is not sequential with the surrounding holdings. The leaf was bound between Concordance 287 and Concordance 289 until the rebinding of the South Aperture series, after which it was moved forward eleven leaves for reasons the rebinding ledger describes only as "convenience." Requests for the ledger's fuller account are directed to the Concordance Reconciliation desk.

The omitted body

Three theories of the omission circulate in the reading rooms. The first holds that the body was struck on a separate leaf, now lost, and that Concordance 288 is properly a wrapper or title-page for a longer instrument. The second holds that the body was struck elsewhere in the same press-run and survives misbound under another number; candidates have been proposed from time to time, most persistently Concordance 288-bis, which is in fact a laundry inventory from the Seventh Landing and has been rejected four times.

The third theory, advanced by the recensions clerk Ovin Marrow in a memorandum of Concordance Amendment Tracking, is that no body was ever composed. Marrow observed that the schedule of cancelled annexes refers to annexes numbered one through nine as "withdrawn prior to publication," and argued that if the annexes were withdrawn before the body was set, the body may simply never have been written. The memorandum is not conclusive and Marrow himself declined to sign it, noting in the margin that he had "formed the view and left it where it lay."

Use in dispute

Because Concordance 288 asserts nothing, it can be cited in support of a position without the inconvenience of quotation. The practice is old and has its own name at the Reconciliation desk, where it is called citing the silent leaf. In the dispute over stairwell access between the Fifth and Sixth Landings, both parties rested their cases on Concordance 288 within the same session; the presiding Librarian recorded that the citation "answered the one side and the other equally, and was accordingly allowed to stand."

The most quoted line in the document, and the only sentence in it that could be mistaken for a rule, appears in the preamble: "What was withdrawn remains withdrawn, and the withdrawing is not to be revisited." It is regularly cited in matters quite unconnected with annexes, including a long contention over the ownership of a reading stand on the Twelfth Landing.

"The leaf decides nothing. That is its whole utility. A document that decides nothing cannot be shown to have decided wrongly, and the parties go away satisfied."

— Concordance 442, marginalia attributed to the Reconciliation desk

Relation to the wider Concordance series

Concordance 288 is named in the schedule appended to Concordance 892, where it is listed among instruments "received and not read." It is also cited by Concordance 664 as supporting authority for the proposition that cancelled annexes retain no force, a use that has drawn objection from those who note that Concordance 664 elsewhere relies on the Third and Seventh Concordances, both of which preserve certain cancelled annexes in force. The contradiction is unresolved and is treated at length in Concordance 1.44.7.

Readers consulting the leaf are reminded that Concordance 23 superseded Concordance 22, while Concordance 22 claims to supersede Concordance IX under the designation XXIII — a confusion of numerals that has never been disentangled and that occasionally leads enquirers to Concordance 288 by mistake, since one of the cancelled annexes was numbered XXIII.

Access

The original may be consulted by appointment at the South Aperture. It may not be photographed, traced, or laid flat on the reading tables, which are of insufficient depth. A certified transcript is available, and the transcript reproduces the omission faithfully, marking it with a gap of the same width as the original. Borrowers may take the transcript to any landing except the one it was issued on.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Concordance 22: what does it set out?

Concordance 22 is a legislative instrument governing the protocols for the creation and classification of textual paradoxes within archival holdings. Promulgated on 15 Floris, 732 (Tower Standard Chronology), its primary…

Concordance 22
Concordance 664: what does it set out?

Concordance 664 is a numbered Concordance of the Tower, promulgated by the Librarians to govern the cataloguing of subjects that are absent from all known floors yet present in the archive's negative indices. It is cited…

Concordance 664
Concordance 892: what does it set out?

Concordance 892, formally titled Interim Provisions for the Cataloguing of Ambiguous Echoes, is a supplementary governance document issued under the authority of The Seventh Concordance and later amended by the provision…

Concordance 892
Concordance IX: what does it set out?

Concordance IX, formally the Ninth Concordance, is a foundational administrative document and the first concordance to be entirely structured around the principle of recursive self-amendment. It established the legal and…

Concordance IX

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.