Volitional Audit
MS 7411.98 · Practices and doctrines
The Volitional Audit is the periodic examination by which the Tower confirms that a subject holding a Volitional (V-) designation continues to will what it was recorded as willing. It is distinct from the four procedural audits — Operational, Documentary, Sequencing, and Isolation — in that those audits test the record of a subject's acts, whereas the Volitional Audit tests the acts themselves, as they are occurring, in the presence of an auditor. The distinction is preserved in the standing instruction printed on the reverse of every audit summons: "The record may be examined at leisure. The will may not" (Manual of Volitional Assessment, 337th Edition, §12.4).
Volitional Audits are conducted under the authority of the Office of Volitional Assessment, which delegates fieldwork to roving audit parties of no fewer than three and no more than five Librarians. No audit party has ever been disbanded; parties are instead placed in Silent Audit Rotation, a schedule under which they audit one another until recalled. Recalls are rare.
Origin and the Stewardship Clause
The practice descends from Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, the so-called Stewardship Clause, which held that a designation granted on a Tuesday could not be assumed to hold on a Wednesday. The clause named no remedy; the remedy was supplied eleven years later by the Bureau of Volitional Acts, which proposed that subjects be visited and asked, plainly, whether they still meant it. The first Volitional Audit was conducted on floor 214 (the Hall of Rehearsed Assent) over the course of a single afternoon in the winter of the year the stairs were renumbered, and produced a finding of "inconclusive, with notes."
Those notes became the audit schedule. A subject whose will is found unchanged is scheduled for re-audit in nine years. A subject whose will is found changed is scheduled in three. A subject whose will is found to have changed and changed back is scheduled in one, and the auditor is required to record the interval between the two changes to the nearest hour.
Procedure
An audit party arrives unannounced but announced in writing, carrying a sealed Certificate of Volitional Migration — blank — in case the subject's will has moved so far as to require a change of floor mid-audit. The senior auditor reads the subject's original designation aloud. The subject is then asked to perform one act consistent with that designation and one act inconsistent with it, in whichever order the subject prefers; the preference itself is recorded as data. The party withdraws. The party returns. The subject is asked which of the two acts it would repeat.
Where the subject declines to answer, the auditor is directed to wait. The Manual of Volitional Assessment allows a waiting period of up to four days, and specifies that the auditor must remain visible to the subject throughout, seated, with the audit book open. Auditors are issued a folding stool for this purpose. The stool is not to be used for any other part of the audit.
"The subject is not to be persuaded. The subject is not to be hurried. The subject is to be given every opportunity to be observed being itself, and the auditor is to remember that the subject can see the auditor, and that this is the point."
— Manual of Volitional Assessment, 337th Edition, §12.9
Findings and the Dispute over Negative Findings
Audits return one of four findings: unchanged, changed, changed and restored, or withheld. A finding of withheld is not a failure; it is a category, and it carries its own archive shelf. It is also the subject of the longest-running disagreement in the audit literature.
Sixth Concordance, Article 3, holds that a withheld finding demonstrates that a will was present and chose not to be seen, and that the designation should therefore be confirmed with commendation. Ninth Concordance, Article 3, Annex 2, holds the opposite: that nothing was observed, and that nothing observed cannot be confirmed. The two Articles have been cited against each other in 411 recorded disputes. The Ruling on Post-Audit Authority declined to resolve the matter, noting only that the Concordances "were not drafted to agree, and that this is not a defect but a condition of their use."
In practice most audit parties record withheld and append a note on the weather, which has become the informal method of indicating how the auditor read the silence.
The Pedigree Incident
In the winter of the year the stairs were renumbered, an audit party under Senior Auditor Mirenna Ostell was dispatched to floor 88 (the Gallery of Unclaimed Purposes) to audit a subject designated V-4417, a volitional ephemeron of the kind that exists for the duration of a single decision. The party arrived after the decision had been made. The subject was accordingly no longer present, and the party recorded a finding of unchanged on the grounds that nothing had contradicted the original designation.
The finding was challenged by the Bureau of Volitional Standards, which argued that auditing an absent subject is not an audit but a recital. Ostell's defence — that the subject had willed itself out of existence in a manner entirely consistent with its designation, and that this was the strongest possible result — was accepted by the Office of Volitional Assessment and entered in the register. The Pedigree Incident, as it is known (after the name Ostell gave the empty chair she had brought), established the precedent that a Volitional Audit may be completed in the subject's absence provided the absence is voluntary. Determining whether an absence was voluntary requires a Volitional Audit.
Records
Completed audits are bound in triplicate, one copy to the Office of Volitional Assessment, one to the Bureau of Volitional Acts for entry in the Register of Docketed Intent, and one retained by the audit party. The retained copies have proved the most durable, since audit parties in Silent Audit Rotation carry their own triplicates with them and are difficult to locate in order to relieve of them. The oldest retained copy in the Tower is that of the floor 214 audit, which is held by a party still in rotation and which the Office has twice requested to see. The request has been acknowledged both times.
Auditors are reminded that the Volitional Audit concludes when the subject has answered, not when the auditor is satisfied.
See also
-
MS 9038.03
Cross-Referential Integrity Scan
A Cross-Referential Integrity Scan is the periodic instrumental examination of referential linkages between holdings on differing …
-
MS 8579.98
Office of Volitional Momentum
Office of Volitional Momentum is the Tower agency charged with reconciling volitional declarations against the measured drift of p…
-
MS 9735.72
Referential Integrity Audit
The Referential Integrity Audit is the standing examination by which the Tower establishes whether a citation, once made, continue…
-
MS 0968.34
Procedure 14-C (Anchor Verification)
Procedure 14-C (Anchor Verification) is the standing method by which the Tower confirms that a designated Ontological Anchor conti…
-
MS 7737.53
Contradiction Protocol Scan
Contradiction Protocol Scan is the periodic procedural examination conducted under the Contradiction Protocol to determine whether…
-
MS 6673.42
Quarterly Null Verification
The Quarterly Null Verification is the recurring examination by which the Guild of Null-Techs confirms that the Tower's null-prope…
Referenced by
- MS 7055.87 Ruling on Autonomous Agency
- MS 7512.44 Observations on Volitional Botany
Readers also asked
Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…
Fourth ConcordanceSequencing Audit: how is it conducted?
Sequencing Audit is the formal examination by which the order of a catalogue entry, filing, or sigil is verified against the sequence it claims to follow. It is not a content audit — a Sequencing Audit establishes only t…
Sequencing AuditVolitional Ephemera: how is it conducted?
Volitional Ephemera are documents, inscriptions, and minor physical artefacts generated through an act of deliberate intent within the Tower, which are nonetheless catalogued under the discipline of Ephemera rather than …
Volitional EphemeraOperational Audit: how is it conducted?
An Operational Audit is distinct from, though often confused with, the biannual Symmetry Audit. Where a Symmetry Audit evaluates abstract structural balance, an Operational Audit evaluates concrete action: the logging of…
Operational AuditPassages cited from this record
-
The subject is not to be persuaded. The subject is not to be hurried. The subject is to be given every opportunity to be observed being itself, and the auditor is to remember that the subject can see the auditor, and that this is the point.
Manual of Volitional Assessment, 337th Edition, §12.9
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4322.23 Gallery of Unclaimed Purposes
- MS 3317.46 Bureau of Volitional Standards
- MS 8439.71 Hall of Rehearsed Assent
- MS 0528.37 Mirenna Ostell
Because you consulted