Tier 1
MS 3802.34 · Practices and doctrines
Definition and scope
Tier 1 is the first and broadest tier of the Tower's classification scheme, comprising all matters that have been settled by a formal act of registration and thereafter require no further adjudication. A subject enters Tier 1 not by becoming important but by becoming finished; the tier records exhaustion of dispute rather than significance of subject. The Office of Tier Assignment maintains that Tier 1 is properly understood as a state rather than a category, a position disputed by the Tier Gamma Observational Committee and, less formally, by the whole of the Fourth Landing.
Enrolment in Tier 1 is cumulative and, in principle, irreversible. A registered subject that is later contested is not removed from the tier; it is annotated, and the annotation is registered in its turn. The archived entry for a common and heavily disputed stair-measurement of the Third Ascent now carries two hundred and eleven annotations, the earliest dating to the Second Recension and the latest to a fortnight before this article's compilation.
Procedure and the Material Feasibility Return
Registration in Tier 1 proceeds from a Material Feasibility Return filed by the scribe of first encounter. The Return names the subject, fixes its dimensions where it has dimensions, and certifies that nothing further about it can usefully be said. Where the scribe cannot so certify, the subject is directed to Tier 2: Material Potentialities and, if the scribe objects, upward to Tier 3: Epistemic Artifacts, where objections are catalogued without resolution.
The Return is a short document. By the terms of Concordance XLI, Annex 6, "no Return shall exceed the face of one leaf, nor shall any leaf be doubled over to evade the count" (Concordance XLI, Annex 6, cl. 2). The clause was added after the affair of Scribe Ammerline Sost, who registered a floorlanding mantel over four leaves folded twice, arguing that the alarm it provoked was "a matter of counting, not of substance." Ammerline Sost's Returns are no longer accepted at the Third Ascent window. The mantel remains in Tier 1.
Relation to Tier-1 (Physical Hazard)
Tier 1 is frequently confused with Tier-1, a separate register maintained under the same numeral for reasons no Concordance explains. The distinction is one of standing: an object Ł in Tier-1 (Physical Hazard) has been found capable of harm, whereas an object in Tier 1 has been found capable of nothing further. An item may appear in both registers. The bannister of the Ninth Spiral appears in both, having been registered within a week of the Concordance of the Ninth Spiral and having, four days later, thrown the Registrar of that Concordance down a flight of stairs.
Readers should also distinguish Tier 1 from Tier-1, which catalogues things that have not happened and are not expected to, and from Tier 1, whose numerals are set in a smaller face and which concerns the stiffness of floors.
Dispute: the sufficiency of annotation
The tier's chief scholarly controversy concerns whether an annotation can itself be registered as a Tier 1 subject. Concordance LXIV holds that any annotation is "of a piece with that which it annotates, and is not separately numbered" (Annex 2, cl. 9). The Tier Gamma recension of the same year, however, records at cl. 9 the opposite: "an annotation is a thing made, and things made are numbered." Both texts are in force. The Office of Tier Assignment, which administers Tier 1 on the strength of a Material Feasibility Return, declined to settle the matter in the 6th epoch and has declined it in every epoch since, on the grounds that settlement would require a Return, and the Return would require a settlement.
"I have read both recensions. I find them both correct. I have filed accordingly. Please do not write to me again about the annotations."
— Undersecretary Vell of the Office of Tier Assignment, marginal note on Return 44,118
Practical notes
Tier 1 subjects are held at the floor of their first registration and cannot be moved without a fresh Return. The corridor on the Fourth Landing is accordingly impassable between the hours of the morning and the afternoon. Lamps are carried for the descent and extinguished on the return, as the tier holds no provision for light that has already been used.
Sealed Tier 1 Returns are not opened by readers. Requests may be made at the Third Ascent window, which is staffed on alternate days, and answered in the order the returns were sealed, which is not the order of their filing.
See also
-
MS 2262.03
Tier I (Settled)
Tier I (Settled) is the designation assigned within the Tower's classification scheme to all holdings, floors, and persons whose s…
-
MS 0334.98
Type-C (Existential)
Type-C (Existential) is the classification applied to a subject whose existence is acknowledged but whose kind has not been settle…
-
MS 3153.73
Log of Unanswered Questions
The Log is organized as a series of nested entries, each comprising the unanswered question itself, its point of origin, the date …
-
MS 0852.34
Primary Registration Descent
Primary Registration Descent is the term given to the final phase of Primary Registration, in which an entity that has been calibr…
-
MS 3402.70
Discontinued Inquiries
Discontinued Inquiries are formal requests for adjudication on matters of classification or ontology whose active pursuit has been…
-
MS 9045.68
Custodial Schism of Floor 188
The Custodial Schism of Floor 188 was a fourteen-month dispute, opening in the winter of 1861 and settled by adjudication in the s…
Referenced by
- MS 3102.38 Revised Guidelines for Citation Hierarchy
- MS 1965.51 Substrate-Dependent Artifacts
- MS 2684.51 Tier 3 (Episodic Duty)
- MS 9872.44 Tier 1 (Persistent Duty)
- MS 9913.46 Tier-6
- MS 6935.28 Tier 3
- MS 2262.03 Tier I (Settled)
- MS 0653.38 Latent Catalogues
- MS 0522.15 Tier 4
- MS 0860.48 Tier 2
Readers also asked
Tier 2: Material Potentialities: how is it conducted?
Tier 2: Material Potentialities is the second band of the Tower's seven-tier classification scheme, reserved for subjects that possess the capacity to become material but have not yet done so. It is distinguished from Ti…
Tier 2: Material PotentialitiesTier Gamma Observational Committee: who are they?
The Tier Gamma Observational Committee is the standing body empowered to adjudicate disputes arising within Tier Gamma, and is the only committee in the Tower whose rulings are recorded in the present tense regardless of…
Tier Gamma Observational CommitteeTier 3: Epistemic Artifacts: how is it conducted?
Tier 3: Epistemic Artifacts constitute a primary classification for the archival of subjects whose existence is contingent upon a specific, active framework of knowledge or belief. Unlike Regulatory Artifacts or Paradoxi…
Tier 3: Epistemic ArtifactsTier Gamma: where is it?
Tier Gamma is the collective designation for the two administratively twinned jurisdictions occupying landings 4,100 through 4,470 of the central spiral: Tier Gamma and Tier Gamma. The two bodies share a stairwell, a wat…
Tier GammaPassages cited from this record
-
I have read both recensions. I find them both correct. I have filed accordingly. Please do not write to me again about the annotations.
Undersecretary Vell of the Office of Tier Assignment, marginal note on Return 44,118
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 7704.20 Concordance LXIV
- MS 2466.12 Tier 1 (Ambient Reinforcement)
- MS 3855.55 Concordance of the Ninth Spiral
- MS 6379.75 Material Feasibility Return
Because you consulted