Tier 4
MS 0522.15 · Guilds, orders and offices
Tier 4 is the fourth tier of the Classification Scheme and the only tier whose holdings are catalogued exclusively by weight. It succeeded to that peculiar arrangement in the winter of 3,014, under the same instrument that established Tier 3, and has defended it in every recension since. Tier 4 holds no artifacts, no potentialities, and no duties; it holds mass, and it holds it under seal.
Establishment and the Sealed Schedule
Concordance 19 fixed the boundary between the third and fourth tiers by a formula rather than a definition, a decision its drafters appear to have regretted within the year. Where Tier 2: Material Potentialities catalogues what a thing might become, Tier 4 catalogues what it would weigh if it did. The relevant schedule was appended as Annex 11 and sealed on the authority of the Office of Tier Assignment, which retains nominal authority over all Tier 4 assignments to this day. Annex 11 has not been opened since. Weighing therefore proceeds by precedent, and precedent is kept on Floor 812 in a ledger the Tier Gamma assessors are forbidden to annotate in ink of any colour but brown.
The Tier Beta office administers the surrounding annexes under recurring supervision, though Tier 4 itself is administered from a single desk on Floor 812 to which no one has been permanently assigned since 3,041.
The Weighing Stations
Tier 4 holdings are weighed at four stations distributed across Floors 795 to 828, each calibrated against a standard mass held at Tier 1. The standard is a sealed cylinder of unspecified material, and the question of its own tier has been referred, unresolved, to the Office of Tier Assignment on nine occasions. Visitors to the stations are asked to remove their outer boots and to stand clear of the balance arms while the pans are in motion. Nobody has tested what happens otherwise.
Readings are recorded in graven weight, not counted units, and discrepancies below one dram are entered as "pious." The practice dates from the Third Recension of the Weighing Ordinances, Clause 6, which directs that "small errors be received as offerings and not corrected" (Third Recension of the Weighing Ordinances, Clause 6). Larger errors travel upward to Tier Gamma, which monitors compliance and resonance at the boundary and returns them stamped, usually without comment.
Holdings
A sample of the tier's register, transcribed from the Floor 812 ledger:
- The accumulated dust of the Eastern Stair, 2 stone 4 drams, reweighed each equinox.
- One unopened crate received from Tier-6 during the pendency of the second absorption petition, 11 stone exactly, and stable.
- The weight of a held breath, pooled across the reading rooms of Floor 803, 3 drams, disputed.
- Seven identical lead seals, one of which is heavier than the other six for reasons the ledger declines to pursue, 1 dram each.
The fourth entry is a standing embarrassment. It has been before the Tier Gamma Observational Committee twice, and both times the Committee has declined jurisdiction on the ground that a discrepancy inside a single line item is not a matter of resonance but of arithmetic. Tier Gamma has likewise declined, on the ground that the seals are real and their weights are real and the contradiction is therefore not its concern.
The Affair of Clerk OM-16
In the winter of 3,062, a weighing clerk designated OM-16 recorded the crate from Tier-6 at 11 stone 1 dram and refused three successive instructions to amend the figure. OM-16's position, set out in a memorandum still held on Floor 812, was that the crate had gained the dram in transit and that the register should record what had happened rather than what had been expected. The Office of Tier Assignment suspended OM-16 for eleven days, reinstated the clerk when no replacement could be found who would sign the ledger, and has never formally ruled on the dram. The entry now reads "11 stone, +1 dram, per OM-16, unresolved."
"A weight that has changed is not a weight that has been mismeasured, and the tier that holds it must hold the change as well."
— OM-16, memorandum to the Office of Tier Assignment, winter 3,062
Scholarly Disagreement
The principal dispute concerns whether Tier 4 is a substantive tier at all. The received reading, following the Second Concordance of Weights at Annex 3, treats Tier 4 as substantive in the manner of Tier Gamma: it holds things, those things have mass, and the mass is the holding. A minority, argued most fully in the Commentary on the Sealed Schedule and never formally answered, holds that Tier 4 is instead an observational tier, since everything it records is a measurement of something catalogued elsewhere, and that the boundary between it and Tier Gamma has been misdrawn since 3,014.
The Office's position on the question is recorded only as a note in the margin of the Floor 812 ledger: "not now." It has held that position for two hundred and forty years, which the Tier Gamma assessors regard as settled and the minority regards as a filing error.
Access
Tier 4 may be visited by written application to the Office of Tier Assignment, on Wednesdays, provided the applicant brings nothing that might be weighed. The prohibition is enforced at the door by a Librarian who has not given a name and who does not explain it.
See also
-
MS 8526.85
Provisional Stack
The Provisional Stack is a standing arrangement of holdings, initiated in 1949 and never concluded, in which items awaiting final …
-
MS 7384.88
Taxonomic Series 44.312.07
Taxonomic Series 44.312.07 is a static, non-hierarchical classification framework used exclusively for cataloguing entities deemed…
-
MS 8370.98
Phantom Alloys
Phantom Alloys constitute a specialized class of metallurgical materials catalogued exclusively within the Non Existent Mineralogy…
-
MS 7429.36
Standardized Shelf-Indexing System (SSIS)
The Standardized Shelf-Indexing System (SSIS) is the mandated classification framework for all physical holdings on catalogued flo…
-
MS 5086.41
Floor 311 the Whispering Gallery
Floor 311 is a Whispering Gallery of the fourth classification, occupying the western spur of the 311th landing and administered j…
-
MS 6476.02
Remedial Prescription
Remedial Prescription is the written instrument by which a bounded harm within the Tower is assigned a fixed, finite correction an…
Referenced by
- MS 3102.38 Revised Guidelines for Citation Hierarchy
Readers also asked
Office of Tier Assignment: how is it conducted?
Office of Tier Assignment is the standing administrative body charged with assigning tiers to holdings throughout the Tower, maintaining the live provisional and permanent registers of such assignments, and performing si…
Office of Tier AssignmentClassification Scheme: how is it conducted?
The Classification Scheme is the aggregate body of rules by which every subject in the Tower is assigned to a category, a tier, and a floor. It is not a single document. The Scheme has no master recension, no founding ch…
Classification SchemeTier Gamma Observational Committee: who are they?
The Tier Gamma Observational Committee is the standing body empowered to adjudicate disputes arising within Tier Gamma, and is the only committee in the Tower whose rulings are recorded in the present tense regardless of…
Tier Gamma Observational CommitteeTier 1: how is it conducted?
Tier 1 is the first and broadest tier of the Tower's classification scheme, comprising all matters that have been settled by a formal act of registration and thereafter require no further adjudication. A subject enters T…
Tier 1Passages cited from this record
-
A weight that has changed is not a weight that has been mismeasured, and the tier that holds it must hold the change as well.
OM-16, memorandum to the Office of Tier Assignment, winter 3,062
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3574.40 Tier Beta office
- MS 0568.37 Third Recension of the Weighing Ordinances
- MS 0173.09 Second Concordance of Weights
- MS 3138.65 Concordance 19 (Tier Boundaries)
Because you consulted