Tier 3
MS 6935.28 · Practices and doctrines
Tier 3 is the third tier of the Classification Scheme, and the only tier whose subject matter is the Classification Scheme itself. Where Tier 1 catalogues material actualities and Tier 2: Material Potentialities catalogues what material actualities might have been, Tier 3 catalogues the instruments of cataloguing: obsolete schedules, superseded indices, the classification of classifications. Its holdings are known collectively as Epistemic Artifacts, and the tier is unique in that a reader consulting it is, by the act of consultation, generating material eligible for it.
Definition and boundaries
Tier 3 was established by Concordance 19 in the winter of the year recorded as 3,014, and its boundaries have been renegotiated eleven times, most recently under Concordance 19. The difficulty is structural. Tier 3 holds the apparatus of knowledge, and the apparatus is extensive: the tier's inventory for the fiscal quarter ending 88/4 listed 41,000 linear feet of shelving in Stack Theta alone, including every duplicate of every schedule that has ever been superseded, kept because a superseded schedule is itself an epistemic artifact and cannot be discarded without a Tier 3 disposal warrant.
The tier's boundary with Tier Gamma is contested. Tier Gamma governs standardized observation, which is to say the instruments of seeing, while Tier 3 governs the instruments of knowing. A lens belongs to Gamma; a lens-grinding formula belongs to Tier 3; a formula for classifying lens-grinding formulas belongs to Tier 3 and, according to Tier Gamma, to Gamma as well. Tier Gamma has filed the same consolidation petition four times, each time withdrawing it before the Tier Gamma Observational Committee could rule. The file is held in Stack Theta and, being a record of a boundary dispute, is itself a Tier 3 artifact.
The Office of Tier Assignment and the recognition of duties
Nominal authority over what counts as Tier 3 rests with the Office of Tier Assignment, which administers the Register of Recognized Duties and the live register for Tier-6. The Office's position, stated in its circular of 88/7, is that a duty is recognized as Tier 3 not when it is performed but when its performance is described — that a description of a duty is an epistemic artifact and enters Tier 3 before the duty itself is assigned anywhere.
"The description precedes the deed in the register, and the register precedes the deed in the world."
— Office of Tier Assignment, Circular 14, clause 3
This has produced the anomaly known as the Recognition Lag, a backlog of some 9,000 described-but-unassigned duties held in Annex Omicron. In 87/11 a clerk of the Office, Pel Harrow, was assigned the duty of describing her own assignment and completed it; the description of the assignment was then recognized as a Tier 3 artifact, but the recognition of the description was not, because the duty of recognizing recognitions had not yet been described. Harrow's subsequent memo — in which she declined to describe it — is now regarded as the earliest genuine Tier 3 artifact of the Recension period, and is held under glass.
Relation to the Metronomic Tier and the tiers below
Tier 3 is conventionally paired with the Metronomic Tier, which governs timing and interval, on the grounds that the classification of a thing and the moment of its classification cannot be separated without loss. The pairing is administered by the Office of Tier Assignment under a standing instruction from Concordance 44, which requires that every Tier 3 entry bear both a classification date and a classification interval. The instruction has never been rescinded and has been suspended for the last two hundred years, so both fields are completed and neither is consulted.
Below Tier 3 the scheme becomes ambiguous. Some recensions place Tier II immediately beneath it; others interpose the Metronomic Tier and defer Contested matters to Tier III: Demonstrative Models. The Office of Tier Assignment maintains that the numbering is ordinal, the Tier Gamma Observational Committee maintains that it is not, and the operative rule — that a tier's number is whatever its most recent citation says it is — is printed on the reverse of every assignment form and read by almost no one.
Disputes and the Harrow Precedent
The principal doctrinal quarrel concerns whether Tier 3 artifacts must be about classification or merely classified. The inclusive reading, favored by the Office of Tier Assignment and by Tier III: Compositional Authenticity, holds that anything once classified is thereby an artifact of classification, which would make Tier 3 coextensive with the entire Tower. The exclusive reading, favored by the Tier Gamma Observational Committee and by the drafters of Concordance 19, restricts Tier 3 to instruments that classify other instruments, a category that is empty for all practical purposes because every such instrument classifies itself.
The dispute was settled, then unsettled, by the Harrow Precedent of 88/1, in which it was held that a classification which classifies itself is not thereby disqualified, on the reasoning that "a wheel that turns itself is still a wheel" (Harrow Precedent, marginal note 6). The Tier Gamma Observational Committee has declined to adopt the precedent and refers to it in its own records as "the wheel." The Committee's minutes of 88/3 note, in the same paragraph, that the matter is not urgent.
Access and use
Readers may consult Tier 3 by written application to the Office of Tier Assignment, countersigned by a Librarian of the third standing. Consultation takes place in the Reading Room of Superseded Instruments on Floor 44,119, which is unheated between the eleventh and second months. Instruments withdrawn from the shelves may not be reclassified during consultation; readers who classify an instrument while reading it are asked to do so at the desk and to leave the pencil. The tier's holdings do not circulate, with the exception of the classification schedules themselves, which circulate constantly and are, at present, entirely unavailable.
See also
-
MS 0860.48
Tier 2
Tier 2 is the second tier of the Classification Scheme and the designation under which the Tower catalogues material potentialitie…
-
MS 2104.11
Series A: Uncut Potentialities
Series A: Uncut Potentialities is a classified sequence of material possibilities inscribed in the Great Ledger of Potentialities …
-
MS 2547.47
Pre Emptive Inscription of Potentialities
The Pre-emptive Inscription of Potentialities is the archival practice by which a subject is entered into the register of the Towe…
-
MS 3087.64
Sub-Department of Potentialities
Sub-Department of Potentialities is a sectional office of the Bureau of Theoretical Cartography, charged with the registration, ho…
-
MS 4076.38
Great Ledger of Potentialities
The Great Ledger of Potentialities (Charter Codex I, Annex A) is the primary registry for the pre-emptive inscription of subjects …
-
MS 4943.23
Chen Protocol Determination
Chen Protocol Determination is the standing ruling of the Tower whereby material recovered through a Descent Protocol expedition i…
Referenced by
- MS 3102.38 Revised Guidelines for Citation Hierarchy
- MS 1965.51 Substrate-Dependent Artifacts
- MS 0653.38 Latent Catalogues
- MS 0522.15 Tier 4
- MS 1909.20 Material Classification
- MS 0860.48 Tier 2
- MS 0620.49 Biographical Catalogues
- MS 2104.11 Series A: Uncut Potentialities
Readers also asked
Metronomic Tier: where is it?
Metronomic Tier is the designation applied to the floor group concerned with the maintenance, calibration, and custodial oversight of cadence-bearing materials. It should not be confused with the classification Tier Alph…
Metronomic TierTier II (Contested): how is it conducted?
Tier II (Contested) is a designation applied within the Classification Scheme to holdings whose tier assignment has been disputed and not resolved. It is not a tier in the ordinary sense: nothing is stored at Tier II (Co…
Tier II (Contested)Tier III: Compositional Authenticity: how is it conducted?
Tier III: Compositional Authenticity is the archival standard by which a Tier III phenomenon is certified as having been composed — that is, assembled from identifiable constituent parts — rather than merely having appea…
Tier III: Compositional AuthenticityTier-6: how is it conducted?
Tier-6 is the sixth band of the Classification Scheme and the highest tier for which the Office of Tier Assignment still maintains a live register. It governs subjects whose defining property is that they cannot be obser…
Tier-6Passages cited from this record
-
The description precedes the deed in the register, and the register precedes the deed in the world.
Office of Tier Assignment, Circular 14, clause 3
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 0152.89 Recognition Lag
- MS 9230.74 Concordance 44 (Temporal Attributions)
- MS 5146.12 Pel Harrow
- MS 7628.43 Annex Omicron
Because you consulted