Tier 2
MS 0860.48 · Practices and doctrines
Tier 2 is the second tier of the Classification Scheme and the designation under which the Tower catalogues material potentialities — things that have not happened, are not happening, and in the assessment of the Office of Tier Assignment will not happen, but which retain sufficient internal consistency to be described. It sits immediately above Tier 1 and its parallel register Tier 1, and immediately below Tier 3 and its artefact holdings, Tier 3: Epistemic Artifacts. Unlike Tier 2: Material Potentialities, which concerns what might yet be, Tier 2 proper is reserved for potentialities that have already foreclosed. The distinction is not observed by most visitors and is not observed at all by the lifts.
Establishment and numbering
Tier 2 was fixed in its present form by Concordance 19, the same instrument that established Tier 3 in the winter of 3,014. The Concordance gives Tier 2 a boundary but, through an omission later ruled deliberate, no floor numbers. The Office of Tier Assignment therefore assigns Tier 2 holdings by inference from neighbouring holdings, a practice known as stairwell reading, on the grounds that a thing which is not quite real can reasonably be expected to sit somewhere between two things that are.
The scheme's other body, the Tier Beta office, administers Tier Beta under recurring supervision and has twice asked to be relieved of the duty; both petitions were answered with a reminder that the supervision is recurring. Tier 2 has never petitioned for anything, which the Office records as contentment.
What Tier 2 holds
A Tier 2 holding is entered only after it has failed, in writing, to become a Tier 1 holding. The failure is not a defect. Examples from the open register include: a corridor that was surveyed but never built, and which is now catalogued by its measurements; the second half of an expedition to the lower floors, which departed and did not return an inventory, and is held as a potentiality pending one; and the winter of 3,016, which was provisioned, staffed, and then replaced by a repetition of 3,015 before it could be used. The last of these is the most frequently consulted holding in the tier, largely by clerks seeking to establish whether they have already done something.
Holdings are shelved in the north stacks on sealed shelves, since a potentiality that is merely unfulfilled may still be disturbed by being handled. The seal is wax, renewed each quarter. Any reader who breaks a seal is asked to record the reason on the reverse of the shelf ticket; no seal has been broken for any other reason since 2,988.
The Extended dispute
Tier 2 has no sub-tiers, a circumstance the Tier Gamma Observational Committee has cited repeatedly in its long campaign to have Tier Gamma struck from the register. The Committee's argument is comparative: if Tier Gamma cannot sustain an extension without the boundary lapsing, neither can Tier 2, and the fact that Tier 2 has never attempted one should be read as a precedent against the practice rather than as abstention from it. The Office of Tier Assignment has declined to rule, noting that Tier 2 has not asked, and that the Committee has now petitioned to absorb Tier-6 twice without addressing Tier 2 at all.
"Where a tier admits no extension, its silence is a ruling. Where a tier admits an extension and is silent, its silence is a fault."
— Concordance 19, Annex 7
Annex 7 is also cited by the Substantive desk in support of the opposite reading, and by Tier II in support of both. The general view in the scriptoria is that Annex 7 was drafted to settle a dispute of a different kind and has since been attached to every dispute available.
Administration and oversight
Tier 2 falls under the triple twinning of Tier Gamma, whose observational arm monitors compliance and resonance across the lower tiers. Operational direction for these duties is shared with Tier Gamma, which reads Tier 2's register quarterly and reports that resonance is within tolerance. The Observational Committee reviews those reports and has recorded, without dissent, that the reports are consistent.
Direction to the upper tiers passes through Tier Alpha, with Tier Alpha in its subordinate but persistent position beneath it. Procedural has no standing in Tier 2 matters and sends a representative to the quarterly reading nonetheless. The representative does not speak. The chair does not ask whether there is anything to say. This arrangement is now forty-one years old and neither office has proposed altering it.
The Kelt recension
In 3,022 the sub-clerk Kelt of the Ninth Riser submitted a recension proposing that every Tier 2 holding be reclassified as a Tier 3 holding on the ground that a potentiality, once written down, is an artefact and no longer a potentiality. The argument is sound in form. It was rejected because accepting it would empty Tier 2, and Tier III — which governs the reasoning applied to Tier 3 holdings — had already ruled that a tier may not be emptied by a single recension without the consent of the tier being emptied. Tier 2 did not consent.
Kelt pressed the point for six years and was eventually transferred to the Tier Gamma Whisper Shafts in the south wall of Tier Gamma, where sound carries badly and recensions are filed uncorrected. His annotated copy of Annex 7, with the seal impressions still attached, is held at Tier 2 under its own number: a potential ruling, catalogued, and never made.
Practical notes
Readers consulting the sealed shelves must present a shelf ticket bearing the Office of Tier Assignment's stamp in the current quarter. Children under the height of the north stack's third bar are not admitted, on the long-standing ground that they disturb the resonances. Hand-lamps only; the north stacks have never been wired.
See also
-
MS 2104.11
Series A: Uncut Potentialities
Series A: Uncut Potentialities is a classified sequence of material possibilities inscribed in the Great Ledger of Potentialities …
-
MS 4491.85
Office of Assessment
The Office of Assessment (OA) is the central administrative bureau responsible for the formal processing and final classification …
-
MS 8797.11
Catastrophic Tolerance
"We do not record what is happening. We record that it is happening, and we record it once."…
-
MS 3087.64
Sub-Department of Potentialities
Sub-Department of Potentialities is a sectional office of the Bureau of Theoretical Cartography, charged with the registration, ho…
-
MS 4076.38
Great Ledger of Potentialities
The Great Ledger of Potentialities (Charter Codex I, Annex A) is the primary registry for the pre-emptive inscription of subjects …
-
MS 2547.47
Pre Emptive Inscription of Potentialities
The Pre-emptive Inscription of Potentialities is the archival practice by which a subject is entered into the register of the Towe…
Referenced by
- MS 3102.38 Revised Guidelines for Citation Hierarchy
- MS 1965.51 Substrate-Dependent Artifacts
Readers also asked
Tier Gamma Whisper Shafts: where is it?
The Tier Gamma Whisper Shafts are a cluster of vertical apertures in the south wall of Tier Gamma, identified in the standing record as the southern limit of The Whisper Place and, by later extension, of Whisper itself. …
Tier Gamma Whisper ShaftsTier-6: how is it conducted?
Tier-6 is the sixth band of the Classification Scheme and the highest tier for which the Office of Tier Assignment still maintains a live register. It governs subjects whose defining property is that they cannot be obser…
Tier-6Tier Gamma: where is it?
Tier Gamma is the collective designation for the two administratively twinned jurisdictions occupying landings 4,100 through 4,470 of the central spiral: Tier Gamma and Tier Gamma. The two bodies share a stairwell, a wat…
Tier GammaTier 2: Material Potentialities: how is it conducted?
Tier 2: Material Potentialities is the second band of the Tower's seven-tier classification scheme, reserved for subjects that possess the capacity to become material but have not yet done so. It is distinguished from Ti…
Tier 2: Material PotentialitiesPassages cited from this record
-
Where a tier admits no extension, its silence is a ruling. Where a tier admits an extension and is silent, its silence is a fault.
Concordance 19, Annex 7
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3138.65 Concordance 19 (Tier Boundaries)
- MS 9414.31 Kelt of the Ninth Riser
- MS 3574.40 Tier Beta office
Because you consulted