The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Third Concordance (Amended)

MS 0233.82 · Practices and doctrines

Scope and designation

The Third Concordance (Amended) is the principal governing instrument of the Tower's middle registers and, by the reckoning of the Office of Concordance Retrieval, the most frequently amended document in the archive. Its citation history runs to some eleven hundred distinct recensions, of which four hundred and nine remain in force. It is conventionally cited as "Third Concordance" in daily business, a shorthand that has produced no fewer than three separate jurisdictions of dispute. The document is not a single sheet. It is a cumulative assemblage of clauses, annexes, provisional provisions, and revoked recensions housed in the scriptorium of the Office of Concordance Retrieval, on a floor whose number is not recorded.

Origins of the amendment practice

The original Third Concordance was ratified to settle the syllable disputes that had rendered the Seven Permissible Syllable Laws unenforceable. Its authors provided for amendment in Clause 2, expecting perhaps a handful of revisions across the life of the Tower. The first amendment followed within the year; the second within the month following that. By the standards set in Concordance 89, Clause 14, an amendment is valid only if it is countersigned by a Librarian whose name appears on the register of the floor to which the clause pertains. Since no register has been reconciled with any floor since the renumbering, the countersignature requirement is satisfied by a rota of three Librarians whose own floor assignments are themselves amended by clauses of the Third Concordance. The resulting circularity is acknowledged in the document's own marginalia and is not regarded as a defect.

Principal clauses

Among the instruments of enduring practical consequence:
  • Clause 12, defining the operation of Vertical Tram services, amended eleven times between the first and third recensions and again by Annex Gamma of the Seventh Concordance, which the Office of Concordance Retrieval maintains has no standing over tram matters.
  • Clause 14, establishing the Cartographers' Auxiliary and, in a later amendment, the Department of Predictive Sustainment.
  • Clause 17, mandating the predictive and directive function of Vectoring.
  • Clause 19, designating Aethelreds Quarry.
  • Clause 144, codifying the tripartite authority over tram operation. Its relationship to Clause 12 has never been settled; both are cited, alternately, in cases of collision.
  • Annex D, formalizing the Thorne Niche.

Provisional Clause 12-gamma, amended, established the Harmonic Integrity Commission under conditions that the Commission's own founding minutes describe as "interim."

The numbering dispute

No two parties agree on the count. The Office of Concordance Retrieval holds that amendments are numbered sequentially by the clause they amend, yielding a document with 1,147 separate numbering series. The Scrip Calculation desk maintains that amendments are numbered by the year of ratification, a scheme that fails for every year in which more than one amendment was passed — that is, for every year on record. Clause 1 attempts to resolve the conflict by supplying numbers to amendments that were ratified without one. This practice has been challenged twice, most recently in connection with the numbering of Aisle 770, where the interpolated numbers are said to fall between two clauses that do not exist in the recension cited. The dispute is older than any clerk now serving. It was formalized as an open question in the Twenty-Second Concordance (Amended) and has been deferred at every sitting since.

Notable rulings

The Third Concordance (Amended) is routinely invoked to settle matters far outside its ostensible scope. Verification by Gesture and Ledger derives its authority from an amendment to Clause 4 that was passed to settle a dispute about shelving heights. Ascent Against Current is governed by a sub-clause of the Silent Wing's seventeen-clause mandate. The Office of Suggestive Logistics traces its establishment to Clause VII, a numbering anomaly that predates the document's own clause scheme and has never been reconciled with it. An annex to the Fifth Addendum attempts to bind the Primary Axiomatic Transit Line to a single schedule; the Line has been subsequently amended by eleven recensions of the Third Concordance, and now runs on what its timetable calls "the concordant interval," a term defined nowhere in the document that established it.

"Amendments are to be read together with the clause amended, except where the amendment provides otherwise, except where a later amendment provides otherwise, and except in matters of tram operation."

— Third Concordance, Clause 2, as amended

Current status

The document remains in force. Amendments continue at a rate of roughly four per quarter, most concerning the Harmonic Integrity Commission and the ever-expanding mandate of the Silent Wing. Retrieval clerks are instructed to check the consolidated text before citing any clause; the consolidated text is itself amended, and its last revision predates the clauses it purports to include. A standing prohibition, first entered in the winter of the long inventory, bars the physical removal of any page of the Third Concordance (Amended) from the scriptorium, including pages carrying no active clause, on the grounds that their absence would be noticed eventually and no one wished to be responsible for the noticing.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Verification by Gesture and Ledger: how is it conducted?

Verification by Gesture and Ledger is a dual-form authentication and classification protocol, formally established by the Third Concordance (Amended), Annex Ω-7, clause 12. It governs the initial processing of uncatalogu…

Verification by Gesture and Ledger
Harmonic Integrity Commission: who are they?

The Harmonic Integrity Commission is a provisional adjunct body chartered under the Department of Structural Integrity to investigate and adjudicate resonant anomalies that intersect multiple jurisdictions within the Tow…

Harmonic Integrity Commission
Annex Gamma of the Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

Annex Gamma of the Seventh Concordance is the principal schedule of the Seventh Concordance treating category, ambivalence, and dimensional handling, appended in the document's fourth recension and amended twice since. I…

Annex Gamma of the Seventh Concordance
Aethelreds Quarry: where is it?

Aethelreds Quarry is an exposed lithic excavation and subsequent vertical chasm comprising the entirety of Floor 331, designated under Concordance III, Clause 19 (Amended). It is one of the few floors where the architect…

Aethelreds Quarry

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.