The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Chamber Seal Affidavit

MS 7987.37 · Documents and ordinances

The Chamber Seal Affidavit is the instrument by which a party attests, under seal, that a chamber has been validly sealed, and that the sealing was performed by an officer competent to perform it. It is distinct from the Chamber Review Seal itself — the wax-and-lead device impressed upon the instrument — and from the petition that precedes it. The affidavit does not create a sealing; it certifies that one has already occurred, a distinction that has occupied the Chamber of Review & Concordance for the better part of four centuries and continues to occupy it.

Filing is by triplicate. The first copy is retained by the sealing officer, the second is deposited with the Stack Custodial Hierarchy, and the third is returned to the affiant, who is advised not to open it. Affiants who open the third copy must file a supplementary affidavit explaining why.

Form and execution

The affidavit is executed on laid paper of not less than 90 gsm, ruled at eleven lines, and bears the deponent's mark at the foot of each page. The seal is impressed in the upper left quadrant only; impressions elsewhere are void but are nonetheless retained, catalogued, and bound, because the Registry of Displaced Impressions holds that a void seal is still evidence of an intention to seal, and intention is not nothing.

The operative clause is fixed and may not be varied:

"I attest that the chamber named above was sealed in my presence, by an officer whose authority I have not examined, on a date I am prepared to defend."

— Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, Standard Clause (Sealing)

The phrase whose authority I have not examined is not an oversight. It was inserted in Cycle 4,118 after the Matter of the Unqualified Sealer, in which a deponent's examination of the sealing officer's credentials was held to have invalidated the sealing retroactively, on the reasoning that a sealing examined is a sealing reopened. Deponents are therefore required to remain ignorant of the authority they certify, and are examined, under oath, as to whether they have accidentally learned anything.

Relationship to the Review Seal

An affidavit without a Chamber Review Seal is a statement. An affidavit bearing the Seal is a statement the Chamber has determined to be validly constituted. The distinction matters chiefly at the point of dispute, where the first is read aloud and the second is not.

Confusion arises because the Seal is impressed on the affidavit and the affidavit is filed under the Seal, so that each appears to authenticate the other. The Seal-Wardens have declined to resolve the circularity, noting in their annual return for Cycle 5,401 that "the recursion is stable and has not, in living memory, produced a chamber that was not there." The Review Chamber has audited Seal failure rates annually since being moved to Floor 1801 and reports no failures attributable to the affidavit itself, though it records eleven attributable to the paper.

The Terminal Exhaustion question

A persistent scholarly disagreement concerns whether a Chamber Seal Affidavit may be filed in respect of a chamber that has been sealed so long that no living officer recalls the sealing. The Scriptorium Affidavit of Terminal Exhaustion holds that an affidavit of descriptive exhaustion presupposes taxonomic exhaustion — that is, that a deponent who cannot describe a sealing cannot be said to have classified it, and must say so rather than attest to it.

Against this, the Fifth Concordance, Annex 2, provides that "a sealing unremembered is a sealing undisturbed," and permits the affidavit to be filed with the date given as before. The two instruments have never been reconciled. The Office of Reconciliations was established in Cycle 5,209 to reconcile them and has to date issued four hundred and six interim memoranda, none of which is cited by either side.

The practical consequence is that long-sealed chambers on the lower floors carry two affidavits apiece, one sworn to the fact and one sworn to the impossibility of swearing to the fact. Both are sealed. Neither is opened.

Notable irregularities

In the winter of Cycle 5,388, a deponent on Floor 2,204 filed an affidavit attesting to the sealing of a chamber that had not been sealed, had never been sealed, and — on the evidence of the Survey of Unsealed Volumes — did not exist. The affidavit was accepted. The Chamber of Last Recourse, asked to annul it, declined on the ground that the Chamber Seal Affidavit is an instrument of attestation and not of fact, and that the deponent had attested honestly to a sealing he sincerely believed had occurred. The chamber was subsequently entered in the register as sealed, presumed, and remains so.

A separate irregularity concerns the Affidavit of Epistemological Readiness, which is required for a valid filing of Form Ω-7A and which several deponents have attempted to substitute for the Chamber Seal Affidavit on the theory that readiness to attest is equivalent to attestation. The Chamber has rejected the substitution eleven times, most recently in Adjudication 77b/, where it observed that readiness is a condition of filing and not a filing.

Retention and access

Executed affidavits are retained in perpetuity in the Sealed Annex and may be consulted by any Librarian of the fourth grade or above, on written application, in the presence of a custodian, without removing the seal. Affiants wishing to consult their own affidavits must apply in the same manner and are not given precedence. The reading room is unheated between the eleventh and the twenty-second of each month.

Copies are not issued. The Primary Witnesses have twice petitioned for a copying privilege and been refused, on the ground that a copy of an affidavit is an affidavit of an affidavit, and the Tower has enough of those.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Review Chamber: who are they?

The Review Chamber is an administrative body charged with the preliminary assessment and triage of conceptual irregularities submitted from across the Tower’s archival floors. Its primary function is to determine whether…

Review Chamber
Affidavit of Epistemological Readiness: what does it set out?

The Affidavit of Epistemological Readiness is a Tower instrument filed to certify that a petitioner possesses the minimum required cognitive and conceptual framework to meaningfully engage with, or file for, a specific a…

Affidavit of Epistemological Readiness
Stack Custodial Hierarchy: who are they?

The Stack Custodial Hierarchy is the ordered body of offices, orders, tiers and licensed claims through which custodial authority is apportioned across the Tower's stacks. It is not a governing body and possesses no cham…

Stack Custodial Hierarchy
Chamber of Review Amp Concordance: who are they?

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.