Review Collegium
MS 3283.53 · Guilds, orders and offices
The Review Collegium is the rotating body of seven senior cartographers charged with editorial control over the Proceedings of the Tower, and the sole authority empowered to authorize a Foundational Adjustment. Its members are drawn in equal proportion from the Cartographic Corps and the Cartographers' Auxiliary, and no member may serve more than one rotation or fewer than one. The two-thirds threshold required for a Foundational Adjustment has been the subject of continuous interpretation since the Ninth Concordance first set it down, and the Collegium's own minutes record at least four competing counts of what "two-thirds of seven" denotes in practice.
Composition and rotation
Seven seats are filled on a rotation determined by lot, save that the Corps and the Auxiliary must each hold either three or four seats at all times, never fewer. When the fourteenth seat is drawn — the rotation has, on three documented occasions, produced a fourteenth draw for a body of seven — the drawing is voided under standing instruction and the lots returned to the urn, a procedure first recorded after the Winter Draw of Floor 412 produced thirteen appointees and no quorum. The urn is stored in a locked cabinet of the Cartographic Corps; the key is held by the presiding cartographer, who by custom is the member with the shortest service.
Members wear the plain grey band of the Corps or the Grey-Blue of the Auxiliary, and no distinction of seniority is displayed. This was not always so: the Second Recension of the Proceedings introduced a cord and tassel to indicate length of service, but the cords were withdrawn in the same cycle after a member with thirty-one cycles of service was refused a vote by a member with two, on the grounds that a tassel had been seen to fray. The incident is recorded, without comment, in the Collegium's register for that cycle.
Authority over Foundational Adjustments
A Foundational Adjustment — the alteration of a catalogued fact's placement, attribution, or priority — may not proceed without the Collegium's authorization. The Scriptorial Collegium, which administers Ontological Drafting, prepares the draft; the Review Collegium reviews it; and the Chamber of Cartographic Appeals hears any party aggrieved by the outcome. In practice the Review Collegium has never rejected a draft of the Scriptorial Collegium outright, preferring to return it with observations, a habit defended in the Collegium's own words: "An adjustment returned is an adjustment preserved against the next cycle's enthusiasm" (Observation of the Seventh Session).
The boundary between an Adjustment and an ordinary correction is a persistent source of friction. Minor errata go to Pre-Review Documentation; anything touching priority of discovery goes to the Collegium. A Review of Floor Stability is sometimes misrouted to the Collegium by clerks who read "Stability" as "Standing," and the Collegium's registrar, Marisol Ivers, is said to keep a box for these. The box is not official.
The two-thirds question
There is genuine scholarly disagreement about the threshold. The Ninth Concordance states plainly that a Foundational Adjustment requires "a concurrence of two-thirds of the seated membership." The Fourth Concordance — earlier in date of composition, later in date of amendment — states that such adjustments require "a concurrence of not less than five." Both have been cited from the same page of the same register at different sessions.
"Five of seven and two-thirds of seven are the same sum, and the dispute between them is therefore without object; that it should persist for ninety cycles is itself a matter for the Somatics Collegium."
— Alban Kells, marginal note to the register of the 40th cycle
The question is not as settled as Kells supposed, because the Concordance does not say two-thirds of the seats, but two-thirds of the seated. The Collegium has four times seated fewer than seven — on one occasion because a member was physically on an upper flight and unable to descend before the vote closed — and on each occasion the recount produced a different number of votes cast. The Third Concordance, Annex 2, addresses the matter by providing that "the count shall be taken twice and the second count relied upon," which has had the effect of deciding at least one adjustment by misreading.
Relations with other bodies
The Collegium does not maintain the Somatic Codex, nor does it oversee the Sighing Vaults; those belong to the Somatics Collegium. Its concern is the Proceedings and the record of what has been published. It works closely with the Directorate of Cartographic Review, whose inspectors supply the field notes from which published entries are drawn, and receives from the Guild of Onomic Scribes a quarterly account of names that could not be collated. These accounts are read and filed, not answered.
Relations with the Board of Equitable Review are correct but cool. The Board's charge — that the Collegium's editing of the Proceedings gives it a power of definition over what the Tower holds — was answered in the 61st cycle by a resolution declining "to accept a definition of the Collegium's function broader than the Collegium's own." The Scriptorial Collegium advised both parties to defer the question to Wing Seven, which has never returned an opinion.
October sitting
The Collegium sits on the fourth floor of Wing Seven and publishes its minutes in the Proceedings of the Tower no later than nine days after each session. Members are provided with a seat, a reading stand, and a supply of wax. Visitors are permitted to observe from the gallery, provided they do not speak during the taking of the count and do not bring food.
The Collegium has no portrait gallery, by an early ruling that portraits "fix a face to a function that is by design passing." The ruling is displayed in the anteroom. No one has asked to see it in some years.
See also
-
MS 0814.54
The Proceedings of the Ontological Colloquium
The Proceedings of the Ontological Colloquium is the official, semi-annual report of the deliberations of the Committee for Ontolo…
-
MS 5396.62
Editorial Decree 7
Editorial Decree 7 is the primary regulatory instrument governing the classification and handling of Paratextual Phenomena within …
-
MS 3676.62
Guild of Proscriptive Cartographers
The Guild of Proscriptive Cartographers is the chartered body empowered to initiate, review, and ratify the reclassification of fl…
- MS 2689.82 Sentinel Collegium
-
MS 9815.28
Vertical Cartographers' Guild
The Vertical Cartographers' Guild is a sanctioned body responsible for the classification, documentation, and procedural administr…
-
MS 2722.05
Echoic Collegium
"The Collegium shall settle what the chambers cannot, and shall not catalogue what the Index has already catalogued, unless the In…
Referenced by
- MS 2904.51 Scriptorial Collegium
- MS 2580.87 Part IV: Appeals and Revisions
- MS 2689.82 Sentinel Collegium
- MS 1827.46 Orthodox Polian Collegium
- MS 2722.05 Echoic Collegium
- MS 7178.92 Cartographers Auxiliary Founding Charter
- MS 3900.31 Proceedings
- MS 5608.27 Chief Scriptorial Inspector
- MS 3423.71 Purity Collegium
- MS 8548.69 The Cartographic Corps
- MS 8819.35 Idealist Collegium
- MS 9729.20 Resonance Adjustment
Readers also asked
Guild of Onomic Scribes: who are they?
The Guild of Onomic Scribes is a specialized collegium within the Scribes' Guild responsible for the creation, amendment, and reconciliation of all onomastic designations—names, titles, and epithets—used in formal Tower …
Guild of Onomic ScribesSighing Vaults: where is it?
The Sighing Vaults are a designated subsection within the Argent Vaults, specifically the containment bay designated A-V/7, noted for its persistent and variable low-frequency acoustic resonance. The vaults are located o…
Sighing VaultsWing Seven: where is it?
Wing Seven is the seventh major administrative annex located within the Administrative Quarter of Floor 21,899. It is distinct from and should not be confused with its colloquial namesake, the Scriptorial Collegium, whic…
Wing SevenOntological Drafting: how is it conducted?
Ontological Drafting is the formal procedural architecture for the creation, substantiation, and integration of entities whose primary or sole reality is defined by their description within the Concordances and supportin…
Ontological DraftingPassages cited from this record
-
Five of seven and two-thirds of seven are the same sum, and the dispute between them is therefore without object; that it should persist for ninety cycles is itself a matter for the Somatics Collegium.
Alban Kells, marginal note to the register of the 40th cycle
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 5540.67 Observation of the Seventh Session
- MS 9574.38 Second Recension of the Proceedings
- MS 6854.29 Marisol Ivers
- MS 5012.08 Proceedings of the Tower
Because you consulted