The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Echoic Collegium

MS 2722.05 · Guilds, orders and offices

Definition and standing

The Echoic Collegium is a deliberative body of the Tower charged with the adjudication of matters arising from echoic phenomena, and with the maintenance of a single procedural standard across the chambers that record, dispute, or steward such phenomena. It sits by rotation on floors 41, 42, and 44, and its seal — a circle enclosing a broken circle — appears on all concordats governing the registration of Echoic Resonances. The Collegium is not numbered among the original Collegia; its instrument of establishment is the eleventh recension of the Third Concordance, which is also the instrument most frequently amended in the Tower's possession. The Collegium's jurisdiction overlaps, and at times conflicts with, that of the Scriptorial Collegium, the Review Collegium, the Sentinel Collegium, and the Somatics Collegium. These overlaps are not defects in the founding instrument. They are the reason the founding instrument has eleven recensions.

Composition

The Collegium comprises nine sitting members, of whom three are drawn from the Chamber of Echoic Reconciliation, two from the Orthodox Polian Collegium, one from the office of the Senior Archivist, and three whose appointment is recorded only as "by turn." The three by-turn seats have never been filled in a manner the Register considers settled; the last confirmed appointment to one of them was withdrawn by the appointing office before the member took seat, and the seat has since been described in proceedings as occupied, vacant, and "under notice" in three consecutive years. Members serve for terms of nine winters. A member may be reseated immediately, but must absent themselves for one full session between terms. This rule was inserted after the incident of the long winter (see below) and is cited in the eleventh recension as clause 4(b), though older copies of the clause number it 4(a) and describe a different prohibition entirely.

Relation to the Index

The Collegium does not itself catalogue. Its authority runs to procedure, precedence, and the settling of disputes between recorders; the taxonomy of echoic forms remains with the Index of Echoic Morphologies, designated SI-711, which recognises eleven distinct types. Where the Collegium and the Index disagree — as they did over the standing of a morphology recorded on floor 44 during the frost-year — the Collegium issues a finding and the Index notes it in the margin without altering its entries. The margin note on that entry runs to four columns and has been transcribed twice, incompletely. The Collegium consults the Register of Echoic Phenomena for the definitive record of transpositions, and defers to the Doctrine of Echoic Value on questions of worth. It does not defer on questions of procedure, which is the distinction the Doctrine itself declines to draw.

"The Collegium shall settle what the chambers cannot, and shall not catalogue what the Index has already catalogued, unless the Index has catalogued it wrongly, in which case the Collegium shall say so and the Index shall write it in the margin."

— Third Concordance, Eleventh Recension, clause 2

The long winter session

In the winter recorded as year 419 of the current reckoning, the Collegium sat continuously for eleven weeks on floor 42 in order to resolve a dispute between the Chamber of Echoic Reconciliation and the Manual of Echoic Stewardship over the correct handling of a particular class of Echoic Imprints. The session is notable for producing the clause now numbered 4(b) and for the death of two members in seat, whose votes were subsequently counted. The counting of these votes was challenged by the Scriptorial Collegium, which observed that its own house rule regarding the franchise of the deceased had been cited in support of the challenge. The Review Collegium declined to hear the matter on the grounds that it had already been decided, and the decision was that the votes stood. The winter session also produced the standing prohibition against hot liquids being carried into the chamber during a divided vote, which appears in the manual of chamber practice without explanation.

Disputed standing

Whether the Collegium is a Collegium at all is a question the Tower has never closed. The HIC Directive 012 refers to it as a "commission," the Somatic Pluviometer records its sittings under a heading reserved for committees, and one recension of the founding instrument describes it as "an assembly convened to decide whether a Collegium is required." The Collegium uses the seal and the title without qualification, and has done so since its third sitting. Attempts to raise the question in session have been ruled out of order four times, each time by a different chair, and the rulings are consistent with one another only in their outcome.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Register of Echoic Phenomena: what does it set out?

The Register of Echoic Phenomena is the canonical list of names that have been spoken, recorded, or otherwise discharged within the Tower's jurisdiction. It is maintained by clerks of the Department of Nominal Integrity,…

Register of Echoic Phenomena
Echoic Resonances: how is it conducted?

Echoic Resonances are the class of recorded auditory phenomena arising when an Echoic Imprint persists in a space after the conditions of its making have lapsed. They are distinguished from the Imprints themselves by the…

Echoic Resonances
Scriptorial Collegium: who are they?

The Scriptorial Collegium is the permanent advisory and drafting body responsible for the composition and preliminary review of all Concordances. Established under Clause 4. of the Second Concordance, the Collegium occup…

Scriptorial Collegium
Somatics Collegium: who are they?

The Somatics Collegium is a permanent administrative body tasked with the codification and regulation of physical phenomena classified as non-essential under the Tower’s ontological framework. Its primary mandate is the …

Somatics Collegium

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.