The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Office of Sustenance

MS 7483.50 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Office of Sustenance is the Tower body charged with the provision, preparation, and delivery of sustenance to all classified holdings, including those holdings which cannot eat. It shares oversight of that delivery with the Office of Sustenance Integrity, a regulatory bureau of the Office of Archival Integrity with which the Office of Sustenance has maintained a written correspondence, uninterrupted since the year 411, on the correct order in which the two offices should sign for the same meal. The Office of Sustenance occupies the service floors of the eastern spiral between 168 and 184, none of which are numbered consecutively.

Remit

The Office provides for every entity the Tower has classified as requiring provision. In most sieges this is straightforward: the holders of a floor are counted, a ration is struck to the count, and the ration is left at the marked threshold before the second bell. Difficulties arise wholly from classification, for which the Office of Sustenance is not responsible and which it has never accepted responsibility for. Since the ratification of the Great Taxonomy of Implied Fauna, the Office's provision rolls have included entities that exist only by implication, and whose needs are therefore inferred rather than observed.

Concordance 44 (“On the Taxonomy of Sustenance”) settled the largest of these questions by establishing the remit of the Office of Sustenance Integrity while legally obligating the Office of Sustenance to provide for all classified entities. It did not define a ration for an implied entity, a detail the Third Concordance later attempted to supply and did not.

The Self-Referential Proviso and the affair of Sigrid Vane

The self-referential case — an entity whose sustenance is the act of being provided for — is governed by the Self-Referential Proviso, Clause XI, the primary statutory basis for the operations of the Office of Sustenance Integrity and the source of the Office of Sustenance's longest-running difficulty. The clause requires that provision be complete before the provision is recorded, and that the record be complete before provision is made.

The practical consequences were set out at length in the finding of Clerk Sigrid Vane, a provisioner of the 171st floor, who in the winter of 512 attempted to close the account of a holding that could be sustained only by the certainty of its own sustenance. Her memorandum of 19 Frost, 512, remains the standard citation:

"The tray was laid, and the record of the tray was not made, and so the tray was not laid. I laid it again. I have now laid it eleven times. I am instructed that the twelfth will be audited."

— Sigrid Vane, Memorandum to the Office of Sustenance Integrity, 512

Vane's grievance — that she had been made an instrument of a proviso she had not written and could not satisfy — was heard by the Office of Sustenance Integrity in 514 and referred onward to the Office of Primary Determinations, which returned it in 517 on the grounds that it was a question of timing. It was then passed to the Office of Temporal Modulation, which has not returned it. Vane transferred to the Dust Abatement Office in 519.

Relations with other offices

Oversight of delivery is nominally shared with the Office of Sustenance Integrity, and in practice is exercised by whichever office arrives first with a seal. The Office of Sustenance has recorded its position — that a shared oversight is not an oversight but a queue — in an annex to its standing instructions, where it has remained unamended since 388 because neither office will sign the amendment.

The Office also maintains an old and unfashionable dispute with the Custodial Office of Actualizations, which asserts that no meal may be counted as delivered until it has been actualized, and the Office of Sustenance, which asserts that no meal may be actualized until it has been delivered. The two offices have declined to exchange representatives since the Concordance of Unclaimed Stairwells assigned the question to a chamber that has not convened.

Within the Office itself, the Department of Sustenance and Illumination prepares food and light together on the understanding that both are forms of provision; the Department was placed within the purview of the Office of Sustenance Integrity by Concordance 44, a transfer the Office of Sustenance did not contest and has not forgiven.

Doctrine and disagreement

Whether the Office of Sustenance feeds things or only certifies them as fed is unsettled, and the Concordances do not agree. The Principles of Self-Sustenance hold that a classified entity is maintained by the fact of its classification, and that the Office's function is therefore evidentiary. The Office's own standing instruction, Instruction 9, holds the opposite: "A ration is not a document. See that it is eaten."

Scholarly opinion divides along a line drawn by the Office of Metaphorical Literalism, which has argued in three successive recensions that "eaten" in Instruction 9 must be read figuratively, and that the Office has therefore never fed anyone and cannot be said to have failed to. The Office of Scriptorial Integrity has declined to rule on the reading, noting only that the Instruction was sealed in 402 and that the seal has not been broken.

Provision rolls and current practice

The Office currently strikes rations on the eastern spiral at the following establishments, in the order they are entered before the second bell:

  • Pantry 168 (implied holdings; inferred portions only)
  • Kitchen 171 (physical holdings; hot service)
  • Pantry 176 (self-referential holdings; see Proviso, Clause XI)
  • Kitchen 184 (light; see Department of Sustenance and Illumination)

Provisioners are reminded that no open flame is carried on the 176th floor, and that trays must be signed for twice where the Office of Sustenance Integrity shares the threshold.

The Office's records prior to Concordance 44 are fragmentary, having been kept on an ad-hoc basis and dispersed among the Curators of the Grand Taxonomy, with whom the Office conducted a jurisdictional dispute over non-physical holdings that was resolved, in the manner of the Tower, by making both offices responsible and neither office answerable.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Curators of the Grand Taxonomy: who are they?

The Curators of the Grand Taxonomy are the administrative and procedural custodians responsible for the integrity, amendment, and practical application of the Grand Taxonomy across the Tower. Constituted under Third Conc…

Curators of the Grand Taxonomy
Office of Temporal Modulation: who are they?

Office of Temporal Modulation is a field station of the Office of Temporal Reconciliation responsible for the licensure, calibration, and oversight of downshifting operations within its designated vertical jurisdiction (…

Office of Temporal Modulation
Proceedings of the Dust Abatement Office: what does it set out?

The Proceedings of the Dust Abatement Office constitute the official, continuous record of all administrative, jurisdictional, and ceremonial activities undertaken by the Dust Abatement Office. Maintained in accordance w…

Proceedings of the Dust Abatement Office
Office of Sustenance Integrity: who are they?

The OSI operates under three core mandates derived from Clause 17 of Concordance 44:

Office of Sustenance Integrity

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.