Draft 5
MS 0209.23 · Documents and ordinances
Draft 5, formally Draft 5: "The Aperture Precedent and Draft-Based Transit", is a working document of the Concordance Revision Office, first circulated in the winter of the floor consolidation and never withdrawn. It advances the argument that a Draft may be said to travel — between floors, between offices, and between its own recensions — without any copy of it moving, on the strength of what its authors call the Aperture Precedent. Draft 5 is catalogued at Draft-Trace Analysis, where it is the division's most frequently requested holding and its least frequently completed one.
The document runs to forty-one leaves, of which nine are annexes and one is a fold-out diagram in which the arrows are drawn but the boxes are not. Its commissioning is recorded in Draft Pronouncement P-Ω7-Draft/87, submitted to the Precedent Register in the same session as the dispute that occasioned it.
Clause 9 and the Draft-Phantom
Clause 9 is the provision for which Draft 5 is chiefly cited. It states that a Draft-Phantom is the Draft's recollection of having been spoken. The clause is four lines long, the commentary beneath it is eleven leaves, and the two do not entirely agree. Annex 12 of the Draft Concordances supplies the definition now in ordinary use — "the sound a Draft makes when it is being taken seriously" — which is narrower than Clause 9 and, on most readings, describes a different phenomenon.
The divergence has never been reconciled. The Concordance Revision Office treats Clause 9 as governing for purposes of transit and Annex 12 as governing for purposes of audit, a division of labour that functions until a phantom is both transported and audited in the same quarter, which occurs at least four times a year.
The Aperture Precedent
The precedent itself is not reproduced in Draft 5. It is referred to throughout as "the matter of the second aperture," and the Office's copy carries a marginal note in an unidentified hand: see the file, which is not this file. What can be reconstructed is that a Draft read aloud at an aperture on a lower floor was subsequently found to have been heard at a higher one, and that no physical transmission of the document could be established. The authors of Draft 5 take this as evidence that transit is a property of the Draft's standing rather than its substance, and proceed from there at considerable length.
"A Draft that has been taken seriously in one place has, by that act, been taken seriously in the places that are prepared to take it seriously. The remainder is carriage."
— Draft 5, Clause 14
Clause 14 has been cited in eleven disputes and applied in none. The distinction is maintained by the Precedent Register, which accepts Clause 14 as authority without accepting that any case has yet arisen under it.
Relationship to the Draft Provisions
Draft 5 is often confused with the Draft Provisions and does not deserve to be. Draft Concordances are drafted language for Concordances not yet adopted; Draft Provisions are amendments to provisions already in force; Draft 5 is neither, being a paper of argument commissioned to settle a question and which instead lengthened it. The distinction matters chiefly to the Office, which has twice been obliged to write to the Librarian of the Ninth Ascension explaining it.
Its influence on actual drafting has been indirect but real. Kaelen, Scribe-Adjunct of the Cartographers' Auxiliary, cited Draft 3 in Draft Provision 881.α after reading Draft 5's treatment of the earlier draft's failure, and the Gtmgedelta Draft was prepared as a proposed amendment to that provision. Draft 5 therefore stands at the head of a line of documents it did not intend to produce.
Reception and the numbering dispute
Two schools dispute what Draft 5 is a fifth of. The first holds that it continues an unbroken sequence from Draft 3, with the fourth item suppressed following the events recorded under Alpha Draft. The second holds that the number refers to the fifth aperture session and that the continuation theory was invented retroactively by the Office to avoid renumbering its shelves. The Chill Draft is cited by both sides and supports neither. The Dispute of the Damp Draft turned in part on this question and was resolved by an amendment to the numbering annex that was itself numbered inconsistently.
The Infestation of Draft Amendment 12-b in the adjacent bay is usually attributed to poor ventilation rather than to Draft 5, though the two were tabled in the same week and the Office has never ruled out a connection. Draft 5 leaves may not be removed from the reading room without a countersignature in green ink; the rule dates from that week and has not been reviewed.
Textual state
No complete copy of Draft 5 survives in a single hand. The Register's copy lacks Annex 6; the Office's copy has Annex 6 twice, differently; the copy held at Draft-Trace Analysis is complete and has been annotated so heavily that the annotation is now consulted before the text. Collation of the three is a standing task of the Concordance Revision Office, assigned each year to the most junior clerk and each year deferred.
Phantom Draft is sometimes given as a synonym in the older catalogues. It is not one.
See also
-
MS 5495.17
On the Inevitability of Precision
On the Inevitability of Precision is a treatise by Theoretician Pol, first issued as an annex to the 214th Consolidation and subse…
-
MS 1516.36
Twenty Second Concordance Document
The Twenty Second Concordance Document is the informal designation given to a family of manuscript recensions of the Twenty-Second…
-
MS 4945.24
Consolidation Phase of Cycle 188
Consolidation Phase of Cycle 188 refers to the third standard phase of the one hundred and eighty-eighth recorded Aperture Cycle, …
-
MS 7329.32
Protocol M-2001
Protocol M-2001 is a standing instrument of the Division of Precedent & Protocol, first sealed on the eleventh of Amsel, 2001, and…
-
MS 2389.35
Trigger Phase
Trigger Phase is the initial operational period within the Aperture Cycle, formally commencing upon the detection and verification…
-
MS 3511.56
Consolidation Phase
Consolidation Phase denotes the second operational period of the Aperture Cycle, succeeding the Trigger Phase and preceding the Pe…
Referenced by
- MS 9105.33 The Committee of Spatial Ethics Drafts (12 items)
- MS 9430.25 Draft-Phantoms
- MS 9866.26 Draft 7
- MS 4914.37 Draft 1
- MS 6310.44 Dust Draft Incident
- MS 4113.95 The Perpetual Draft Annex
Readers also asked
Draft Provisions: what does it set out?
The Draft Provisions are the subordinate class of instrument issued by the Chancery of Directives between the ratification of a Concordance and the publication of its implementing ordinance. Unlike a Draft Concordance, w…
Draft ProvisionsDispute of the Damp Draft: what happened?
The Dispute of the Damp Draft was a prolonged bureaucratic and environmental conflict waged across Archive Epochs 44,791 to 44,812, corresponding to Year 119 of the Third Catalogue. It centered on competing jurisdictiona…
Dispute of the Damp DraftCartographers' Auxiliary: who are they?
Cartographers' Auxiliary is a subordinate bureau of the Scrivener’s Auxiliary responsible for the curation, maintenance, and provision of mapping instruments, standardized charts, and drafting supplies for all sanctioned…
Cartographers' AuxiliaryDraft Provision 881.α: what does it set out?
Draft Provision 881.α is a foundational procedural document first proposed in the Year 312 of the Thirty-Seventh Concordance.It establishes the primary administrative framework and taxonomical nomenclature for the implem…
Draft Provision 881.αPassages cited from this record
-
A Draft that has been taken seriously in one place has, by that act, been taken seriously in the places that are prepared to take it seriously. The remainder is carriage.
Draft 5, Clause 14
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4724.39 Draft Pronouncement P-Ω7-Draft/87
- MS 4477.94 Concordance Revision Office
Because you consulted