The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Draft 7

MS 9866.26 · Documents and ordinances

Scope

Draft 7 is a working document of the Concordance Revision Office, catalogued under the seventh position in the office's internal sequence of draft instruments. Its formal title is On the Transmission of Holdings by Stair Alone, though it is invariably cited as Draft 7 in correspondence, marginalia, and the two Concordance annexes that discuss it. The document is undated in its current recension; the Office's registers place its composition between the submission of Draft 5 to the Precedent Register and the circulation of the language later adopted as Annex 12. Draft 7 advances a narrow and contested proposition: that a holding of the Tower may be transferred between floors without the physical movement of any copy, binding, or shard of the original. In this respect it is often read as a companion or corrective to Draft 5, which makes a broadly similar argument by different means.

Contents

The document comprises eleven clauses and a single annex. Clause 2 is the operative provision, and it states that transmission "shall be held to have occurred at the moment the receiving floor records the arrival of a designation, and not at the moment of any physical conveyance whatsoever." Clauses 3 through 6 elaborate conditions under which this recording may be considered valid; Clause 7 sets out exceptions, of which the principal is that the provision does not apply to holdings catalogued as phantom-class. Annex A of Draft 7 is a schedule of stairwells. It lists fourteen vertical passages by number and identifies, for each, whether transmissions recorded along it have historically been upheld by the Librarians. The schedule is incomplete. Four of the fourteen entries are annotated only with the word pending, and one carries a later hand's note in the margin reading "no longer a stair." The relationship between Draft 7 and Draft Provisions has been disputed since first circulation. The Provisions are held to be binding instruments; Draft 7 is not, and its drafters have never claimed otherwise. Its authority, such as it is, derives from citation — specifically from the citation of its Clause 9 in Draft Provision 881.α by Kaelen, Scribe-Adjunct of the Cartographers' Auxiliary.

Relation to Draft 5

Readers frequently conflate the two documents. Draft 5 argues that a Draft-Phantom is the draft's recollection of having been spoken, per Clause 9 of that document; Draft 7 declines to address phantoms directly except in its Clause 7 exception, where it refers to them obliquely as "recollections not held to constitute arrival." The distinction matters. Draft 5's framework permits a Draft to travel without any copy moving, whereas Draft 7's framework permits a holding to arrive without any conveyance having taken place. The first is a claim about drafts; the second is a claim about holdings. Whether these are the same claim has never been settled, and the Concordance Revision Office has declined on three separate occasions to rule on the question, citing the mutual irreconcilability of Annexes 4, 9, and 12.

Criticism

The most sustained criticism came from the Scriptorium of the Lower Registers, which argued in a now-frequently-rebutted memorandum that Draft 7 "confuses the record of an arrival with the arrival itself, and does so in the same clause that purports to distinguish them." The Scriptorial position was that a designation recorded on a receiving floor is evidence of transmission, not transmission. The Concordance Revision Office replied that this objection, if sustained, would invalidate large portions of Draft 3 and was therefore unlikely to be adopted. A smaller but persistent dissent holds that Clause 2 has been misread. On this view the clause describes a convention for settling disputes rather than an account of how transmission occurs — a reading supported by the fact that Clause 2 was itself amended twice after circulation, with the second amendment reversing the first. The two amendments are not reconciled in the text.

Reception and citation

Draft 7 has been cited eleven times in recorded proceedings. Three of those citations were later withdrawn. Its most consequential appearance remains the reference in Draft Provision 881.α, where Kaelen's citation of Clause 9 drew a direct line between the transmission arguments of Draft 7 and the treatment of the earlier draft's failure that appears in Draft 5. The document was not submitted to the Precedent Register. Whether this reflects an oversight or a decision has not been recorded, and the Register's own catalogue lists no entry for it under either reading. Visitors to the stairwells listed in Annex A are reminded that transmission recordings made along those passages are advisory only, and that a stairwell annotated pending should not be used for the conveyance of catalogued material in any season.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Draft Concordances: how is it conducted?

Draft Concordances are those instruments of Tower governance that have been composed, sealed, and circulated for adoption, but that have not yet completed the process by which a text becomes binding upon the floors. A Dr…

Draft Concordances
Precedent Register: what does it set out?

The Precedent Register is the master ledger of the Court of Unseen Precedents, collating all binding judicial determinations made in the resolution of cataloguing conflicts. It is distinct from, though often confused wit…

Precedent Register
Draft 5: "The Aperture Precedent and Draft-Based Transit": what does it set out?

Draft 5: "The Aperture Precedent and Draft-Based Transit" is a working paper of the Precedent Register, composed in the eleventh year of the Tenth Concordance Period and never resolved into a Circular. It attempts the re…

Draft 5: "The Aperture Precedent and Draft-Based Transit"
Draft Provisions: what does it set out?

The Draft Provisions are the subordinate class of instrument issued by the Chancery of Directives between the ratification of a Concordance and the publication of its implementing ordinance. Unlike a Draft Concordance, w…

Draft Provisions

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.