The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Draft 3

MS 0032.42 · Documents and ordinances

Scope and status

Draft 3 is an unadopted instrument of the Tower's archival apparatus, catalogued under the Draft-Trace Analysis division of Residual Analysis. It is a proposed amendment to an unnumbered provision of the Concordance governing floor-numbering reconciliation, prepared by the Office of Scriptorial Residue and never submitted for concordance. Its principal significance lies in the fact that, although unadopted, it has been cited four times in adopted instruments — a status the Librarians' annotation desk classifies as "operative without effect," a category that exists for this document and two others. The Draft is dated Frost 14 of the Year of the Fourth Recension and measures 61 cm in standard Tower sheet, though the surviving copy carries a second, shorter leaf of differing stock bound behind the first. The second leaf has never been transcribed.

Textual history

Draft 3 was composed by Under-Scrivener Halbren Voss during a period of general re-copying on Floor 912, and is the third of seven drafts Voss produced in a single winter. The first two are lost; the fourth through seventh are held in the Gtmgedelta Draft annex under an unrelated shelf-mark assigned during the Recension of Shelves. The Draft proposes that floors whose numbers have been disputed for more than one hundred years be assigned provisional letters until reconciliation is complete. The proposal is stated in four clauses and one annex, the annex being a list of one hundred and fourteen floors proposed for provisional lettering. The list has never been checked against current holdings; the Office of Reconciliation notes that "the annex is not the point of the instrument," a remark recorded in the margin of the concordance file without attribution. Voss submitted the Draft to the Precedent Register in the same season but withdrew it before registration, citing an error in clause three. The error has never been specified.

Citations in adopted instruments

The four citations are as follows:
  • Concordance 41, Annex B, referencing "the lettering proposal" in a clause about stairwell signage.
  • Draft Provision 881.α, which cites Draft 3's clause two as an example of drafting to avoid.
  • The Transit Manifest regulations of the Ninth Recension, which borrow the Draft's definition of "provisional" without credit.
  • An internal memorandum of the Office of Reconciliation, not adopted, but frequently re-circulated.
The citation in Draft Provision 881.α is of particular interest to Draft-Trace Analysis: the Provision was authored by Kaelen, Scribe-Adjunct of the Cartographers' Auxiliary, who had not been posted to Floor 912 and is not recorded as having had access to Voss's winter papers. Kaelen's own marginalia on the Provision describes the referenced clause as "an obvious blunder," which has been read by some archivists as evidence of independent invention rather than transmission, and by others as a sign that the blunder was obvious enough to be reached without help.

Disputed interpretation

The Librarians hold no official position on whether Draft 3 was ever operative. The Draft Concordances school, represented principally by the annotator known only as Second Hand, argues that a document cited four times has functionally entered the record regardless of its submission status, and that the provisional letters it proposed are therefore in force on the one hundred and fourteen listed floors. The Office of Reconciliation disputes this, holding that citation of a clause for the purpose of avoiding or borrowing it does not enact it. The disagreement was put to a formal ruling in the winter of the Damp Draft and was not resolved; the ruling itself is held as an addendum to the Dispute of the Damp Draft file and has been amended twice since. Visitors to the affected floors will find stairwell markings either numbered or lettered according to which office last repainted, and are advised that the two conventions do not always correspond to the same landing.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Transit Manifest: what does it set out?

A Transit Manifest is a compound document comprising the primary Form L-29 "Manifest of Arrival" and its attached situational maps, filed by a licensed Tower Guide to authorize and catalog a sanctioned vertical transit b…

Transit Manifest
Drafting: how is it conducted?

"No draft shall be bound before it has been trial-read aloud in a room containing at least one reader who did not write it."

Drafting
Draft-Trace Analysis: how is it conducted?

Draft-Trace Analysis is a branch of Precedential Analysis concerned with the identification, classification, and disposition of residual traces left behind by documents that were drafted but never adopted. It is administ…

Draft-Trace Analysis
Residual Analysis: how is it conducted?

Residual Analysis is the general discipline concerned with the identification, classification, and interpretation of residues — the material, acoustic, procedural, and documentary traces that remain after an act has conc…

Residual Analysis
Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.