Draft 1
MS 4914.37 · Documents and ordinances
Draft 1 is the foundational recension of the draft corpus and, by the admission of the Librarians themselves, the least read of its members. It is held in the Closed Recension Room on Floor 41, in a hinged case of grey board, and may be consulted by written application. The application is granted routinely. The case has not been opened since the winter of the Quiet Audit.
Draft 1 is distinguished from every subsequent draft not by its content — which is short, largely procedural, and in places illegible — but by the fact that no one can establish what it is a draft of. Draft 3 proceeds from it; Draft 5 argues past it; Draft 7 is said in Annex 12 of the Draft Concordances to correct it. None of these documents states the subject of the original. The catalogue records the holding without description, and the catalogue is treated as authoritative on this point.
Physical description and hand
The holding consists of nine leaves, quarto, ruled at twenty-two lines, bound in board faced with a fabric no longer manufactured on any floor above the twelfth. The text is in a single hand throughout, save for a marginal note on the fourth leaf in a second, later hand, which reads only "he said it twice" and is unsigned.
Watermark analysis places the paper at roughly two hundred years before the Aperture Precedent, though the Draft-Trace Analysis office has twice declined to certify this figure, noting that its methods assume paper is made after the thing written on it is conceived, and that the assumption does not hold in every wing of the Tower. A maintenance note pasted inside the case lid advises that the hinges be waxed annually and that the case not be carried by the lid.
The question of priority
The principal scholarly dispute concerning Draft 1 is whether it precedes or follows the events recorded under Alpha Draft. The Precedent Register holds that Draft 1 is prior, on the grounds that a document cannot be a draft of something that has not yet occurred, and that the Alpha Draft events are therefore best understood as its reception. The Concordance of Recensions, by contrast, cites the numbering of the drafts as evidence of sequence and treats Draft 1 as the earliest, which is not the same claim, though the two are frequently conflated in the secondary literature.
The disagreement is sharpened by a contradiction between two governing texts. Concordance 14, Annex 2, states plainly that "the first draft is the one that was never revised," while Concordance 31, Article 6, holds that "a draft once revised is a draft no longer, and the number passes to its successor." Read together, the two would require Draft 1 both to have been revised and never to have been, and the Librarians have declined to reconcile them. The standard workaround, attributed to the clerk Ovin Marrow and now used throughout the scriptoria, is to cite whichever Concordance is nearer to hand and to add the words "in the ordinary sense."
The Marrow grievance
Marrow's involvement with Draft 1 is the most fully documented episode in its history. As Sub-Registrar of the Closed Recension Room, Marrow applied in the third year of the Quiet Audit to have the case opened for the purpose of verifying the marginal note. The application was granted, then stayed, then granted again on appeal, at which point the Precedent Register ruled that the note was not part of the holding and could not be verified without altering it. Marrow's subsequent memorandum — that "one cannot check whether a thing has been written on a page without looking at the page" — was entered into the record and answered eleven years later with the single word "noted."
Marrow is not recorded as having applied again. The grievance is preserved in the Register under its own heading, which is unusual, and is cited by archivists as the leading example of a question that was correctly answered and never resolved.
Relation to the draft corpus
Draft 1 is not a Draft Provision and does not propose language for adoption; it is a draft in the older sense, a thing worked on rather than a thing put forward. This distinction matters chiefly to the Draft-Phantoms literature. Draft 5, Clause 9, defines a Draft-Phantom as the Draft's recollection of having been spoken, while Annex 12 of the Draft Concordances calls it "the sound a Draft makes when it is being taken seriously." Neither definition addresses a draft that was never spoken aloud, and Draft 1 is not recorded as having been read in session at any point.
The Phantom Draft and the Gtmgedelta Draft are both held to derive, by different routes, from the fourth leaf. Neither derives from anything written on it.
Access
Consultation requires a written application countersigned by a Librarian of the fourth grade or above. Readers are asked to leave the case lid open for one hour after use, so that the boards may dry evenly. Photographic reproduction of the second hand is prohibited under the standing order following the Infestation of Draft Amendment 12-b.
See also
-
MS 9503.59
Forms XI-XV
Forms XI-XV are the five terminal members of the Ancient Series of Forms, a closed sequence of fourteen documents of which Forms V…
-
MS 0338.88
Custodians
The Custodians are the Tower's oldest continuous class of office-holders, predating the Librarians themselves by an interval no re…
-
MS 3622.47
Ordinance Theta-4
Ordinance Theta-4 is a foundational governance document within the Concordance Theta corpus, granting Librarians explicit authorit…
-
MS 0754.94
Special Protocol C-7
Special Protocol C-7 is an instrument of the Librarians authorizing the Ontologicalists to pursue lines of inquiry that would othe…
-
MS 1606.72
Librarians' Chant
Librarians' Chant is the collective designation for the body of sung formulae administered by the Librarians for the purpose of fl…
-
MS 0881.94
Novitiate Librarians
The Novitiate Librarians are those members of the Order of Librarians who have been entered on the roll of the Tower but have not …
Referenced by
- MS 9105.33 The Committee of Spatial Ethics Drafts (12 items)
- MS 6310.44 Dust Draft Incident
- MS 4113.95 The Perpetual Draft Annex
Readers also asked
Draft-Trace Analysis: how is it conducted?
Draft-Trace Analysis is a branch of Precedential Analysis concerned with the identification, classification, and disposition of residual traces left behind by documents that were drafted but never adopted. It is administ…
Draft-Trace AnalysisDraft 3: what does it set out?
Ovin Marrow: how is it conducted?
Ovin Marrow is the collective designation given in the Tower's registers to a recurrent clerical name, borne by no fewer than nine clerks of record between the years 118 and 2,210 SCE and by at least one office, one sub-…
Ovin MarrowDraft Concordances: how is it conducted?
Draft Concordances are those instruments of Tower governance that have been composed, sealed, and circulated for adoption, but that have not yet completed the process by which a text becomes binding upon the floors. A Dr…
Draft ConcordancesReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 7551.76 Draft Provision
- MS 7110.24 Aperture Precedent
- MS 9162.29 Quiet Audit
Because you consulted