The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Alpha Draft (Substantive)

MS 4960.25 · Documents and ordinances

The Alpha Draft (Substantive) is the working designation for a class of preparatory documents held on Floor 4,412, known locally as the Antechamber of Beginnings, and distinguished from every other draft in the Tower by a single property: it is the only draft class that is not a draft of anything. An Alpha Draft (Substantive) proposes no language, amends no provision, and is submitted to no register. It records, in the present indicative, a thing that has not yet been catalogued, in the expectation that a future instrument will one day make the record true. The Office of Substantive Assessment maintains a standing instruction that Alpha Drafts are to be read "as though already in force, and shelved as though they were not" (Office of Substantive Assessment, Standing Instruction 14(b)).

Origin and the Antechamber of Beginnings

Floor 4,412 was catalogued in Tower Gregorian Year 604 as a holding space for instruments awaiting introduction under the Requirements for Substantive Introduction set out in the Third Concordance. Within two decades the holding space had acquired shelving, then a clerk, then a doctrine. The doctrine is usually attributed to Librarian Orbet Vann, whose marginal note of 611 remains pasted inside the floor's day-book:

"A thing may be written before it is, provided the writing is filed where the thing intends to be."

— Antechamber day-book, entry for 3 Floréal, Year 611

The note was not adopted as a Concordance and has never been repealed, a combination the Tower treats as binding. Alpha Drafts have been deposited on Floor 4,412 continuously since, at an average of eleven a year, though the rate has fallen since the Department of Substantive Cataloguing began requiring each deposit to be countersigned by a second Librarian who has read it.

Form and citation

An Alpha Draft (Substantive) is written in a single hand on continuous paper, without clause numbering, and closes with the formula Held open to introduction. Each carries an alpha mark and a deposit date, and is cited by both, as in Alpha 61, deposited 9 Brumaire, Year 668. The alpha marks are not sequential; Alpha 61 precedes Alpha 12 in the sequence of deposit, and the Antechamber's keepers have declined four times to explain why. The floor's index is arranged by intention rather than by mark, so that a reader seeking a draft of a particular future instrument must first state what has not yet happened and be directed accordingly. Requests may be made in person at the desk. The desk closes at the ninth bell.

Alpha Drafts are frequently confused with instruments of the Draft Provisions class, which propose clause text, and with Draft Concordances, which propose Concordances proper. The distinction is set out in the Manual of Substantive Derivation (7th Revision), which assigns to the Alpha class zero ontological weight and full evidential weight — a ratio the Manual concedes is "unusual and has not been found elsewhere" (Manual, §9.4).

Substantive status and review

The central difficulty of the class is that an Alpha Draft makes a claim about a thing that does not yet exist, and under the Tenth Concordance a Substantive Declaration attracts the Principle of Substantive Primacy and so enters Substantive Review. Whether an Alpha Draft constitutes such a declaration has been the subject of a dispute running since Year 679. The Office of Substantive Assessment holds that it does, and reviews Alpha Drafts on a seven-year cycle alongside ordinary γ-7 forms; the Antechamber holds that it does not, and has declined to transmit the drafts for review since Year 681, filing its refusals in a separate sequence known as the Negative Register.

A Substantive Review of an Alpha Draft can conclude in one of two ways that the Tower recognises. The draft may be confirmed, in which case it passes to the Department of Substantive Cataloguing for introduction as a Substantive Annotation; or it may be found premature, in which case it is returned to Floor 4,412 with the finding not yet, and not yet sufficiently. The finding language was fixed by Librarian Sephine Ardo in 694 after a long correspondence, and has not been altered since, though the Negative Register contains at least forty attempts to reword it.

Notable instances

Alpha 33, deposited in Year 645, describes a stairwell connecting Floors 4,412 and 4,413 and gives its measurements, condition, and handrail material in thirteen pages. No such stairwell exists. The draft was reviewed in 722 and confirmed; the confirmation was quashed in 723 on the ground that confirmation cannot precede existence; the quashing was itself quashed in 726. The stairwell is presently recorded as pending, and the space where it would begin is marked off with cord and a small card reading Reserved. Travellers are asked not to move the cord.

Alpha 12, deposited 2 Ventôse, Year 702, is a two-line document anticipating the creation of a category of draft that would supersede the Alpha class entirely. It has been held open to introduction for twenty-three years, and the Antechamber has declined to assess it on the ground that assessing it would require the category it anticipates.

Scholarly dispute

The Precedent Register records, at P-Ω7-Draft/87, a draft pronouncement holding that an Alpha Draft may be cited as authority for the existence of its subject. The Office of Substantive Assessment has never registered the pronouncement, on the ground that it was submitted as a draft and so cannot bind. The Antechamber, by contrast, has applied it continuously since 709, and points out that the Office's own objection would, if accepted, invalidate the entire Alpha class, including the Office's reviews of it. Neither body has been willing to test the point, and the Manual of Substantive Verification, upon which the Manual of Substantive Derivation (7th Revision) is built, addresses the question only obliquely, in a footnote concerning "documents whose subjects are their own consequences" (Manual of Substantive Verification, note 3 to Proposition 2).

In 731 a reader requested all Alpha Drafts relating to the Gtmgedelta Draft and was given eleven documents, none of which mentioned it. The Antechamber's response, entered in the day-book, reads: "Nothing held; nothing expected; request filed under expected." The file remains open.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Tenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Tenth Concordance is a foundational document of administrative governance within the Tower, ratified on 14 Spiral, Year 412 of the Third Cataloguing Era. It is primarily known for its pivotal annex, Annex Ω, which au…

Tenth Concordance
Substantive Review: how is it conducted?

Substantive Review is the adjudicatory process administered by the Office of Substantive Assessment to determine the ontological stability and cataloguing posture of a holding following a qualifying event. Governed prima…

Substantive Review
Gtmgedelta Draft: what does it set out?

The Gtmgedelta Draft is the collective designation for four unrelated holdings that share a name by operation of the doctrine of Transitive Coincidence: a disputed instrument of the Chancery of Directives (the draft prop…

Gtmgedelta Draft
Draft Concordances: how is it conducted?

Draft Concordances are those instruments of Tower governance that have been composed, sealed, and circulated for adoption, but that have not yet completed the process by which a text becomes binding upon the floors. A Dr…

Draft Concordances

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.