The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Developmental Coherence Faction

MS 4576.21 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Developmental Coherence Faction is a body of Librarians of Coherence holding that a record acquires coherence not by satisfying it at once but by arriving at it, and that the intermediate stages of a holding's approach to coherence are themselves subject to appraisal. Formed in the winter of 6,029 out of a reading circle attached to the Stack Survey Office on Floor 4,410, the Faction is today the principal rival to the Strict Coherence Faction, which maintains that coherence is a condition a record either satisfies entirely or fails absolutely. The dispute between the two bodies has been before the Directorate of Archival Coherence continuously since 6,033 and is generally reckoned the longest-running unresolved item in the Directorate's ledger.

Origins and the Bud Question

The Faction's founding is traceable to a single procedural difficulty. In the spring of 6,028 a surveyor named Perpetua Vann was asked to attest a cone of the almost-cedar type then under review by the Scribes of the Penultimate. The cone was, by every measure available, a cone; but it was also, by every measure available, not yet properly a cone. Vann declined to attest it and declined to return it, recording simply that the holding appeared to be "somewhere in the course of being." The phrase was struck out by her superior and reinstated by appeal.

The Faction's answer was to adopt the developmental position set out in the Third Concordance, Annex 11, where the Bud Stage appears as a discrete and licensable state rather than as a defect in a later state. It was the Scribes of the Penultimate who supplied the formulation the Faction still quotes at its annual reading, describing the developmental stage of almost-cedar cones as "a green intended but never declared" (Scribes of the Penultimate, floor memorandum 4,410/11).

Relation to the Manual of Arboreal Reckoning

The Faction's most cited authority is the Manual of Arboreal Reckoning, which outlines three recognized developmental pathways for Proto-Silvanus Aggregates: Consolidation, Dispersion, and Transmutation. The Faction reads the Manual as settling the matter: a body that recognizes three pathways cannot simultaneously maintain that there is only one terminus, and a record on the Consolidation pathway is coherent differently at each stage and coherently so. The Strict Coherence Faction has never disputed the Manual's text, only its relevance, on the ground that a manual of arboreal reckoning cannot govern the coherence of records, however many records it may happen to describe.

"A pathway with three sanctioned routes is not a test with one permitted answer. The Manual does not ask whether the cone has become; it asks by which route."

— Developmental Coherence Faction, reading notes for the spring session of 6,041

The 6,037 Attestation Crisis

Matters came to a head over the Material Coherence Attestation. The Strict Coherence Faction insists that the Attestation be withheld from any holding that has at any time been incoherent, and applied this rule without exception during the winter of 6,037, when it held the chair of the attestation board on Floor 6,041. Some four hundred holdings were withheld, including eleven that had never left the Bud Stage and could not therefore have been incoherent in the first place, a distinction the board declined to recognize on the ground that a stage implies a prior stage.

The Faction's counter-position, drafted by its clerk-correspondent Halvard Reet, proposes a category of pending coherence: a holding whose incoherence is documented, dated, and scheduled for resolution is attested provisionally, the Attestation marked in the lower margin with the pathway and the expected date of Consolidation. Reet's memorandum of 6,038 records that of the first sixty provisional attestations issued under the scheme, fifty-eight were later confirmed and two were lost. The two were not pursued.

Posture toward Intermittent Coherence

The Faction is sometimes confused with the advocates of Intermittent Coherence, and has twice published a notice denying the association. The distinction is real: Intermittent Coherence concerns a holding that passes in and out of coherence without proceeding anywhere, whereas the Developmental Coherence Faction concerns a holding that is coherently incomplete and travelling. Reet put the difference in a letter to the Directorate of 6 September 6,039 — "the one flickers on the spot; the other walks" — a sentence the Directorate has never formally entered into the record, though it is widely quoted in the corridor outside.

Internal Divisions

The Faction is not of one mind on how far the developmental principle extends. Its more cautious members, who sit with the Gradualist Faction on joint committees, hold that developmental coherence applies to holdings and not to clauses. Its more radical wing, which has never named itself and is known in the reading rooms simply as the pathway party, argues that a repealed clause is a clause in Dispersion and that the Absolutist Faction's insistence on the total extinction of repealed text is a failure to read the Manual properly. This argument has been made to the Directorate four times and rejected four times, most recently in the summer of 6,040, on grounds the Directorate described as "developmental but not that developmental."

The Faction keeps no membership roll, a practice it adopted deliberately after the Strict Coherence Faction's roll went unread from the winter of 6,038, and which its critics call an evasion. It meets on Floor 4,410 on the second and fourth Thursdays. Attendees are asked not to reshelve anything on the way out, as the survey stacks are under interim arrangement.

Status

The Faction's standing within the Directorate of Archival Coherence remains contested. It has no seat on the attestation board and has petitioned for one in every session since 6,036. Its influence is chiefly textual: the provisional margin-note, the pathway record, and the practice of dating an incoherence rather than concealing it are now found in holdings that owe the Faction no allegiance whatever. Whether this constitutes coherence achieved by stages or merely incoherence prolonged is, the Directorate has said, a question for a later recension.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Absolutist Faction: how is it conducted?

The Absolutist Faction is one of the older surviving parties within the Librarians, distinguished from The Gradualist Faction chiefly by its insistence that a repealed clause retains no operational existence whatsoever. …

Absolutist Faction
Scribes of the Penultimate: who are they?

The Scribes of the Penultimate are an anonymous collective of copyists and compilers credited with the authorship of the Treatise on Perpetual Almost, the Tower's principal survey of states that never arrive at completio…

Scribes of the Penultimate
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Strict Coherence Faction: who are they?

The Strict Coherence Faction is a body of Librarians holding that coherence, properly understood, is not a quality that a record may possess in degrees but a condition it either satisfies entirely or fails absolutely. Th…

Strict Coherence Faction

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.