The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Strict Coherence Faction

MS 4097.70 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Strict Coherence Faction is a body of Librarians holding that coherence, properly understood, is not a quality that a record may possess in degrees but a condition it either satisfies entirely or fails absolutely. The Faction is best known for its long resistance to the Intermittent Coherence standard and for its insistence that the Material Coherence Attestation be withheld from any holding that has at any time been incoherent, however briefly and however fully repaired. Its seat is the reading room on Floor 6,041, and its membership roll has not been read aloud since the winter of 6,038.

Origins and the Reading of 5,912

The Faction traces its foundation to the dispute over Intermittent Coherence that followed the resurvey of Floor 5,912. A ledger recovered from that floor was found to cohere on eleven of its twelve leaves; the twelfth had been corrected in a later hand. The Office of Verification accepted the ledger, holding that its coherence had been restored. A minority objected that the correction had produced a second coherence, not a recovery of the first, and that the ledger now held two incompatible claims to the same property.

That minority adopted the name Strict Coherence Faction in a memorial of 5,913 addressed to the Librarian of Coherence. The memorial's central sentence has been quoted in every subsequent proceeding: "A record that has been incoherent remains a record with an incoherent past, and no attestation may be issued over a past" (Memorial of the Eleventh Leaf, 5,913, cl. 3). The Librarian of Coherence declined to rule, noting that the memorial raised a question of definition rather than of fact, and referred it to the standing committee on definitions, where it remains.

The Single-Attestation Rule

The Faction's operative position is that the Material Coherence Attestation is indivisible. Where the Office of Verification issues attestations in stages — provisional, partial, and final — the Faction holds that a partial attestation is a contradiction in terms and that its use has produced holdings whose status cannot be stated without qualification. In practice the Faction's examiners return a holding unexamined rather than examine it partially, a policy that has made Floor 6,041 the slowest-attesting floor in its decile.

The policy has had consequences. In 6,044 the Faction refused to attest a shipment of 340 floor-plans on the ground that one plan, a schematic of the eastern spiral, had been amended twice in the same century. The plans were held in the vestibule for nine years. They were eventually attested in full, unamended, after the schematic was withdrawn and refiled under a different floor number entirely.

"Coherence is not a destination to which a record may be conveyed by degrees. It is the record's address or it is nothing."

— Librarian of Coherence Adwen Marr, dissenting note appended to the Standing Committee minutes, 6,027

Relations with neighbouring factions

The Faction is frequently confused with the Strict Concordantists, and the confusion is resented on both sides. The Strict Concordantists adhere to the letter of the most recently amended Concordance; the Strict Coherence Faction holds no particular view of which recension is authoritative and will accept an obsolete text provided it coheres. The two bodies have nevertheless voted together on eleven occasions, a fact the Vossian Traditionalists have cited as evidence of a concealed alliance. No such alliance has been shown, and the Faction's secretary has described the claim as "arithmetic without a ledger" (Letter to the Office of Verification, 6,051).

Closer and more troubled is the Faction's relationship with the Substantialist school, which holds that coherence inheres in the substance of a record rather than in its attestation. The Faction regards this as a category error of the plainest kind, since substance cannot be examined without an attestation to establish what is being examined. The Substantialist reply, drafted on Floor 6,040, is that the Faction has confused the certificate with the thing certified — a charge the Faction has never answered in writing.

The Sundering of 6,052

In the spring of 6,052 a schism divided the Faction over the question of repaired bindings. The majority held that a rebound volume retained its original coherence, the binding being external to the text. A minority, led by the examiner Ossia Vane, held that the binding was part of the record and that a volume rebound after damage had been incoherent and remained so. Vane's party withdrew and styled itself the Absolutist Faction, taking with it the Faction's only working collation table. The table was returned in 6,059, missing its third folio, and has not been replaced.

The schism cost the Faction its majority on the standing committee on definitions, where it has not since held more than four of eleven seats. Its current programme is confined to the maintenance of the Single-Attestation Rule and the annual reading of the Memorial of the Eleventh Leaf, held each year on Floor 6,041 in the first week of the eleventh month.

Admission and observances

Candidates for the Faction are examined on the eleven leaves of the Floor 5,912 ledger and are expected to state, without notes, which of the two coherences they would attest. Either answer is accepted. Neither answer is recorded. Visitors to the reading room on Floor 6,041 are asked to leave their coats in the vestibule and to take nothing from the third shelf.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Absolutist Faction: how is it conducted?

The Absolutist Faction is one of the older surviving parties within the Librarians, distinguished from The Gradualist Faction chiefly by its insistence that a repealed clause retains no operational existence whatsoever. …

Absolutist Faction
Intermittent Coherence: how is it conducted?

Intermittent Coherence is a catalogical and ontological condition wherein a subject, object, or concept within the Tower exhibits periods of full coherence interspersed with intervals of partial or absent coherence. It i…

Intermittent Coherence
Office of Verification: who are they?

The Office of Verification is a regulatory body within the Librarianate responsible for assessing the procedural validity of petitions, requisitions, and classifications submitted by other departments. Its primary functi…

Office of Verification
Material Coherence Attestation: what does it set out?

The Material Coherence Attestation (MCA-57) is the standardized document and procedural mechanism by which a holding is certified as compliant with the Axiom of Material Coherence. Issued by the Directorate of Archival C…

Material Coherence Attestation

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.