The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Gradualist Faction

MS 0212.13 · Practices and doctrines

The Gradualist Faction is the collective designation for those Librarians who hold that cataloguing proceeds by admitted degrees, and that no inventory is to be considered false merely because it is incomplete. The position derives from the Gradual Admission Thesis, first circulated on Floor 119-Delta, and received provisional recognition under the Seventh Concordance. Gradualists are distinguished from the Absolutist Faction chiefly by their tolerance of partial returns, and from the Verificationists by their refusal to submit partial returns to verification at all. The Faction maintains no register, no officers, and no meeting room; membership is inferred, in the manner of the Tower generally, from what a clerk has been heard to say twice.

Doctrinal Basis

The Gradualist line is held to descend from the School of Static Ontology by way of the Spindle Commentaries, a descent that the School has neither confirmed nor denied and that the Formalist School has described, in a marginal note of 1409, as "a lineage assembled backwards." The central claim is narrow: a catalogue entry that admits a subject's existence but not its extent is not thereby in error. Gradualists distinguish this from the Purist Faction's uncritical acceptance of all submissions, insisting that the Thesis concerns the rate of admission and not its standard.

"What is admitted in part is admitted. The part is not a defect of the whole but a stage of it, and the stage is not to be reported as a failure."

— Gradual Admission Thesis, opening recension, Floor 119-Delta

The Thesis was provisionally recognized by the Seventh Concordance, whose Annex 9 sets out the conditions of that recognition. Annex 9 is four lines long and has been glossed in eleven separate commentaries, none of which agree on what the fourth line means.

The Sealing of the T-54 Spiral

The Faction's most consequential setback came not from a rival doctrine but from a staircase. Gradualist clerks on the upper Delta floors had adopted the practice of delivering inventories by instalments, climbing the T-54 Spiral between floors and handing up each portion of an entry as it was completed. The practice was efficient and was held by its practitioners to be doctrinally required.

In the winter of 1447 the Indexing Guild sealed the T-54 Spiral, citing a risk of "partial inventories in transit." The Guild's notice gave no further reason, and the sealing has not been lifted. Gradualist clerks now deliver in full or not at all, which many of them regard as a concession they have not made. A delegation to the Guild in 1451 was received, heard, and recorded as "received." The Guild's porter has confirmed that the delegation was also served tea, a detail the delegation's own minute omits.

Dispute Concerning the Seventh Concordance

Scholarly disagreement turns on whether the Seventh Concordance recognized the Thesis or merely ceased to forbid it. The Strictconstructionist Faction held, before its dissolution under Concordance 37, Clause 81.2, that provisional recognition is a category with no content, since a Concordance either binds or does not. The Traditionalist Bloc takes a different view again, arguing that Annex 9 binds only those who have read it, a position that has never been tested because no one has established who has.

A third reading, advanced by the clerk Miren Osp of Floor 119-Delta in a memorandum of 1462, proposes that the Seventh Concordance recognized the Thesis for the duration of its own recension and that the recognition lapsed when the recension was superseded. Osp's memorandum is twelve pages long and its final page is missing. Gradualists cite it constantly and quote it only as far as page eleven.

Relations with Other Factions

The Gradualists sit awkwardly among the Tower's parties. They share the Verificationists' insistence on standards and the Purist Faction's willingness to admit, and are trusted by neither. The Alpha Purists have twice proposed that Gradualists be reclassified as a procedure rather than a faction, on the grounds that a doctrine of degrees cannot be held absolutely; the proposal has twice been tabled without a vote. The Stasis Faction regards the Gradualists as allies on the narrow point that nothing need be finished, while objecting to the implication that anything need be started.

Relations with the Transcendentalist Archivists were severed in 1398 and have not been resumed. The cause is not recorded, though the Gradualist commonplace book for that year contains an entry reading only "Floor 212. Not our doing."

Practice and Inventory

Gradualist practice is visible chiefly in the shape of its returns. A Gradualist entry typically proceeds from the general to the particular across successive submissions, each of which is filed under the same number and none of which is marked as superseding its predecessor. The resulting files are thick and are read in order. The following is a complete Gradualist return for a single subject, as filed on Floor 119-Delta over three years:

  • Submission 1: "There is a thing on this floor."
  • Submission 2: "It is a lamp, or is lit like one."
  • Submission 3: "It is a lamp. It has been extinguished since the first submission."

The file was closed in 1471 without a fourth submission. The lamp is not otherwise catalogued, and the Gradualists regard this as correct.

Status

The Gradualist Faction remains unrecognized as a body and undisturbed as a practice. It has no seat, no seal, and no representative at the Concordance readings, though its clerks attend them and are sometimes asked what they think, which they decline to answer on the grounds that they have not finished thinking it. The Faction's centenary was observed on Floor 119-Delta in 1519 with a short address and no conclusion.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Concordant Law: how is it conducted?

Concordant Law constitutes the primary, and some argue the sole, legitimate basis for formal governance within The Tower. It is distinguished from advisory precedent and temporal regulation by its derivation from, and am…

Concordant Law
Alpha Purists: how is it conducted?

The Alpha Purists are a sub-faction of the Purist Faction whose central doctrine holds that any formal system of designation, classification, or procedure must originate from and recursively reference a singular, axiomat…

Alpha Purists
Strictconstructionist Faction: who are they?

The Strictconstructionist Faction, active from approximately Floor 12–α (Gamma Spiral) through to its formal dissolution under the Thirty-Seventh Concordance's Clause 81.2, held that the first and only valid document of …

Strictconstructionist Faction
School of Static Ontology: how is it conducted?

School of Static Ontology is a minor, primarily theoretical school within the Tower dedicated to the study and cataloguing of entities and states defined by their inherent resistance to change. It operates under the prin…

School of Static Ontology

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.