Descent and Ascent Protocols
MS 5790.15 · Documents and ordinances
Descent and Ascent Protocols is the collective designation for the two parallel bodies of procedural writing that govern movement along the Tower's vertical thoroughfares, together with the accumulated commentary, annexes, and recensions that have grown around them. The term is a convenience of the reading room rather than an instrument of law: no single document bears the title, and the Office of Protocol Consolidation has twice declined to issue one, on the grounds that "the joining of an ascent instrument to a descent instrument produces a third instrument whose authority no ordinance has yet assigned" (Concordance of the Ninth Landing, Appendix 2). In practice the Protocols are consulted as a pair, and disputes arising between them are heard by the Chamber of Vertical Claims.
The two halves are not symmetrical. Ascent is governed by the Ordinances of Ascent, an old and comparatively settled set of instruments cited chiefly for traffic and right-of-passage. Descent is governed by the Descent Protocols, which are longer, revised more frequently, and — according to their own prefatory note — "regarded by their drafters as provisional in all particulars" (Descent Protocols, Preface, 2nd recension). Readers are reminded that the Descent Protocol as a singular object, and the numbered issue Descent Protocol Delta-7-22, should not be confused with the collective.
Composition and order of reading
The Protocols comprise, for the ascending side, the Ordinances of Ascent with Ordinance 4, Annex C on traffic direction; and, for the descending side, the Descent Protocols together with the supplementary series Descent Protocols Sigma-1 through Sigma-9 and the practice manual Descent Protocols Practice. An unnumbered bridge text, the Ascent/Descent Dichotomy, is bound between the two in all complete editions after the Vorhalt Recension of 9 BR, though the Chamber has ruled that it is "descriptive and without operative force" (Chamber of Vertical Claims, Ruling 1188). The prescribed order of reading is ascent first, then dichotomy, then descent; the reverse order is permitted but must be recorded on the reader's slip, and returning readers are asked not to annotate the bridge text.
The question of priority
Scholarship divides on whether the two bodies derive from a common source or were drafted independently and only later harmonized. The Prefects of the Archive hold for a common origin, pointing to the identical phrasing of the traffic clauses and to a shared defective line-break in the third annex of each, which they argue cannot have arisen twice. Against this, the Keeper of the Lower Margins has observed that the phrase in question — the traveller facing the wall — is a copyist's hallmark of the Sixth Scriptorium, which produced both recensions and would have introduced the same error into wholly unrelated texts. The dispute is unlikely to close, as the Sixth Scriptorium's copying ledgers for the relevant years were consumed in the Lower Margins Fire and survive only as a list of titles.
"That the two instruments agree is not evidence of a common parent. It is evidence that the same tired hand set both, in the same winter, from the same poor candle."
— Keeper of the Lower Margins, marginal note to the Vorhalt Recension, folio 41v
Conflict and precedence
Where the halves disagree, precedence is determined not by subject but by the seal under which the contested clause was issued; a descent clause sealed in the Bureau of Seals outranks an ascent clause sealed in a floor office, regardless of which is more recent. The rule produces outcomes that practitioners find unintuitive. In the winter of 1211 a party ascending the Gradient of Ascent/Descent in the counter-clockwise direction required by Ordinance 4, Annex C was challenged by a descending party relying on a sealed descent clause directing the same direction of travel for all users of the route. The Chamber of Vertical Claims found for the descender, noting that the annex's mandate "is not suspended by the ascent it was drafted to serve" (Ruling 1209). The ascent party were fined the Stair Tax on both passages and directed to climb in the opposite direction on their return.
Practitioners consequently advise that the descent clauses be read before setting out and the ascent clauses before arriving, and that neither be read while in motion.
Identifiers and documentation
Each traveller moving under the descent half of the Protocols is assigned a Descent Identifier governed by the Descent Protocols themselves; the ascent half assigns no corresponding identifier, a gap the Office of Protocol Consolidation has described as "not an omission but a courtesy" (Appendix 3). Identifiers are entered on the reader's slip and may not be altered except by a Warden of Descent, of whom one must be present wherever a descent clause is invoked. Where the route in question is recursive — most notably under Recursive Descent — the Protocol directs that the identifier be re-entered at each recurrence, and the route logged in the Vellum Descent register. The special register Vellum Descent Sigma-1 is reserved for descents that change direction without a recorded cause; entries there are not numbered and are not counted in the annual returns.
Practical notes
The Protocols are held in the Reading Room of the Second Landing and may be consulted by any holder of a valid slip. The following are the only items the room permits at the desk, and the list is given as it appears on the notice board:
- one pencil, unsharpened;
- one slip;
- one seal, if the reader is entitled to one.
Readers ascending to the room are asked to enter by the west door; readers descending, by the east. The Gradient of Ascent/Descent itself is not a reading room and the notice board says so twice.
See also
-
MS 7128.71
P. Vel's Notice
P. Vel's Notice is the collective designation given in the accession registers to two instruments filed by Archivist P. Vel of the…
-
MS 8829.19
Vacancy As a Juridical State Document
The Vacancy As a Juridical State Document is the collective archival designation for the surviving recensions of a commentary on O…
-
MS 0222.29
Procedural Substrate Annex
The Procedural Substrate Annex is the collective designation for the schedule of clauses appended to Procedural Substrate and amen…
-
MS 9459.16
Procedural Commentary
Procedural Commentary is the class of written matter that accompanies a Tower instrument without amending it. The distinction is o…
-
MS 9758.39
First Inquest protocols
First Inquest protocols is the collective designation for the procedural instruments governing the convocation, conduct, and ratif…
-
MS 2355.20
Transfer Protocols
Transfer Protocols is the collective designation for the body of procedural instruments governing the movement of holdings — physi…
Referenced by
- MS 6001.39 Supply Chain Logistics
- MS 3390.86 Office of Ascent and Descent
- MS 9459.16 Procedural Commentary
- MS 8366.12 Unitary Ascent
- MS 0571.29 Bureau of Recensions
- MS 4125.74 Ascent
- MS 7220.29 Intentional Descent for Ascent
Readers also asked
Descent Identifier: how is it conducted?
Descent Identifiers are the unique alphanumeric codes assigned to all authorized routes into the substructure of The Tower. Governed by the Descent Protocols and administered by the Directorate of Descent, a Descent Iden…
Descent IdentifierVellum Descent: how is it conducted?
Vellum Descent refers to a specialized subset of Guided Descent protocols authorized exclusively for the inspection and preservation of the Nictitating Vellum artifacts housed within the Tower. These descents are governe…
Vellum DescentRecursive Descent: how is it conducted?
Recursive Descent is a procedural status that suspends the application of Guided Descent protocols upon the determination that the subject of a Descent is, itself, a documented Descent process. The status, once invoked, …
Recursive DescentSixth Scriptorium: where is it?
Sixth Scriptorium is a scriptorium of the Tower, situated on floor 118, from which Ordinance 4.3.1δ is administered and where inventories were taken and holdings countersigned by Librarian-Scribe Elara Vex may be consult…
Sixth ScriptoriumPassages cited from this record
-
That the two instruments agree is not evidence of a common parent. It is evidence that the same tired hand set both, in the same winter, from the same poor candle.
Keeper of the Lower Margins, marginal note to the Vorhalt Recension, folio 41v
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4499.00 Lower Margins Fire
- MS 2189.11 Stair Tax
- MS 2638.86 Reading Room of the Second Landing
- MS 3873.79 Vorhalt Recension
Because you consulted