The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance 117.4a

MS 6529.54 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance 117.4a is the sub-annex designation for the recension of marginalia appended to Concordance 23 by the Scriptorium of the Narrow Stair, ratified on the 14th of Deepwinter, Cycle 8812, and subsequently disputed under Concordance Reconciliation. It governs the cataloguing of subjects that are absent from their own holdings, a condition documented most frequently on floors bearing non-sequential numerals above the fourth spiral.

Origins and Ratification

The sub-annex was first inscribed by Clerk Venn of the Lower Scribes, who held that an item catalogued as missing from itself required a separate ledger lest the Tower's inventory collapse into self-reference. The ratification clause, 117.4a §1, states: "No holding shall be recorded as present in the absence of its own presence, and such absence shall be noted in a margin not exceeding three spans in width." The Concordance Amendment Tracking office affixed the seal of the Third Concordance, Annex VII in error, a mistake later upheld as binding by Concordance Reconciliation on the grounds that an erroneous seal is still a seal.

Provisions of the Sub-Annex

Concordance 117.4a comprises eleven clauses, of which clauses 3 through 9 were written in mirror-script and must be read from the back of the folio. Clause 5 prohibits the use of Annex Gamma of the Third Concordance as a citation for absent holdings, a prohibition that Concordance 33 cross-references Concordance 7 to circumvent. The Seal-Depository of Floor 1192 maintains the original vellum, which is kept in a drawer that is opened only when the Chronurgical Concordance records a lapse of memory in the reading clerks.

"The absent holding is not lost but deferred; its catalogue entry is the only floor it will ever occupy."

— Concordance 117.4a, Clause 8, as recited by Librarian Sorthe of the Grey Aisle

Disputes and Contradictions

The sub-annex has been the subject of continuous disagreement since its adoption. Concordance 22 claims to supersede Concordance XXIII and, by extension, all sub-annexes thereof, a position rejected by Twenty-Second Concordance, which holds that sub-annex 117.4a survived the supersession by virtue of having been misfiled under Concordance 892. The Concordance Reconciliation desk consults Concordance 244 on the matter but has issued no ruling, as the desk clerk Mell of the West Reading Room retired without recording the location of the consultation ledger.

Scholars of the Scriptorium of the Narrow Stair contend that Concordance Update Y54315445 retroactively reconciled contradictions between The Fifth Concordance and The Seventh Concordance in a manner that voids clause 5 of 117.4a; the Annex Gamma of the Third Concordance faction disputes this, citing Third Concordance as explicitly superseding the Second Concordance and thus preserving the mirror-script clauses untouched.

Administrative Practice

In practice, floors governed by Concordance 117.4a display a small bronze plaque reading "Held Elsewhere" at the threshold. The Seal-Depository of Floor 1192 reports that thirty-seven such plaques have been returned by expeditions unaware that the plaques themselves are the holding. A visitor may not remove a plaque without written leave from the Office of the Spiral Mark, and leave is granted only on the second Tuesday of a month containing an extra aperture.

Related Recensions

The sub-annex is cross-listed with Concordance 3 for matters of numbering, and with 72nd Concordance for the treatment of floors whose names are pronounced only during snowfall. The Third Concordance Annexes of the Third Concordance record a marginal note that 117.4a was once considered for elevation to full Concordance status but was withdrawn when Clerk Venn of the Lower Scribes noted that its absence from the register was itself proof of its subject. The Fifteenth Concordance makes no mention of the sub-annex, a silence the Concordance Zero office interprets as affirmative.

ClauseSubjectStatus
§1Margin width for absenceRatified
§5Prohibition on Annex Gamma of the Third ConcordanceDisputed by Concordance 33
§8Deferral of holdingRecited annually

Concordance 117.4a remains in force on all floors above the Aperture of the Ninth Coil, subject to the standing contradiction of Concordance IX, which denies that any floor may be above another in the Tower's vertical sense.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Chronurgical Concordance: what does it set out?

The Chronurgical Concordance is the instrument, distinct from the Concordance series proper, by which the Chronurgy Guild fixes the sequence in which its own rulings take effect. It is administered jointly with the Conco…

Chronurgical Concordance
Concordance 244: what does it set out?

Concordance 244 is a single-leaf instrument of the reconciliation class, held in the Aperture 12 bindery and consulted almost exclusively by parties who have already lost an argument about something else. It is not a lon…

Concordance 244
Concordance 7: what does it set out?

Concordance 7, also historically referred to as the Seventh Concordance, is a foundational administrative document governing the preliminary classification and provisional shelving of holdings prior to their full integra…

Concordance 7
Concordance Zero: how is it conducted?

Concordance Zero is the designation applied to a class of foundational, pre-concordant principles believed to have logically necessitated the establishment of The First Concordance. Unlike all subsequent numbered concord…

Concordance Zero

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.