The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Volumes of Calibration

MS 4435.36 · Documents and ordinances

The Volumes of Calibration are the twenty-two bound registers in which the standing measurements of the Tower are recorded, revised, and from time to time quietly abandoned. They are not instruments; they are the written record against which instruments are judged. Every span, weight, interval, and aperture in the Tower is nominally traceable to an entry in one of the twenty-two, and every such entry is nominally traceable to a meeting at which at least two Librarians were present. The word nominally appears in the preamble to Volume I four times.

The Volumes are held by the Chamber of Calibrated Volumes and are consulted only in the presence of a witnessing officer of the Calibration Quintet. They are not lent. They are not copied. Requests to photograph them were settled in 4,109 by the Ninth Concordance, Annex 11, which permits "the transcription of any entry into a separate book provided the separate book is subsequently destroyed."

Composition and Numbering

The twenty-two Volumes are designated by Roman numerals and bound in waxed linen of a colour specific to each. Volume I, the Primer of Spans, governs linear measure and has been rebound eleven times; Volume XXII, the Terminal Register, governs measures that no longer correspond to anything measurable and has never been opened since its sealing in 3,860. Its seal remains intact, which is itself treated as a measurement.

The Volumes do not share a single numbering system. Volumes I through XIV are paginated continuously; Volumes XV through XIX are paginated by aperture, each page bearing a pair of marked openings; Volumes XX and XXI are unpaginated and are cited by the hour at which an entry was made. Volume XXII has no pages. The Fifth Report on Non-Sequential Volumes devotes its fourth appendix to this anomaly and concludes, with evident relief, that the matter falls outside its remit.

The complete holdings, as last inventoried by the Census of Unattended Volumes, are:

  • I–IV, the Spans and Weights
  • V–IX, the Intervals
  • X–XIV, the Apertures
  • XV–XIX, the Recensions of the Apertures
  • XX–XXI, the Corrections
  • XXII, the Terminal Register (sealed)

Revision and the Problem of Substitution

An entry in the Volumes is superseded, not erased. Superseded entries remain legible and remain binding on any instrument calibrated before the supersession but not recalibrated since, a rule known as the standing of the older hand. In practice this produces a Tower in which two rulers may both be correct and disagree, and in which the disagreement is the property of the rulers rather than of the Tower. The Office of Spatial Reconciliation has objected to this on eleven occasions, most recently in its memorandum of 5,002, which was filed and acknowledged.

Revision is by the hand of the Keeper of the Volumes, an office held since 4,977 by Keeper Anselm Vey, whose corrections are distinguished by a slight rightward slope and by the fact that he dates them twice, once at the top of the entry and once at the foot, and the two dates occasionally differ by a day. The discrepancy is tolerated. Keeper Vey has stated in writing that the second date records the moment the correction became true and the first the moment he learned of it.

"Where the Volumes and the world disagree, the Volumes are corrected. Where the Volumes and the Volumes disagree, the later hand governs, unless the earlier hand was Keeper Vey's, in which case both are read aloud and the room decides."

— Manual of Adjudicative Protocol, Volume LXXIII, Applicative Annex 61

The Dispute with the Hall of Whispering Volumes

The Volumes of Calibration have never been classified as Negative Volumes, a point on which the Hall of Whispering Volumes has pressed for two centuries. The Hall's argument, set out in its petition of 4,844, is that Volumes XV through XIX describe apertures defined entirely by what does not pass through them, and that a space defined by absence is a Negative Volume by the Hall's own definition. The Chamber's reply, filed the same year, was three lines long and observed that the Volumes are books, and that books are catalogued by the office that holds them.

The dispute hardened in the winter of 4,851, when a junior indexer of the Hall entered Volume XVII in the Register of Unwritten Volumes at 4.1 cubic skeins, clearing the threshold by a margin of 0.4. The entry stood for nine days. It was struck not because the Hall was wrong but because the Chamber had failed to object within the period allowed, and the Discrepancy Volumes record that the Chamber's objection arrived on the tenth day and was "received, read, and returned unopened." The junior indexer, whose name the record gives only as Iseult of the Ninth Gallery, was subsequently transferred to the Receivers of Absence and is not mentioned again.

Relations improved only after the Guild of Unspooled Volumes lapsed and the administration of Contradictory Volumes passed to the Hall, which then found itself obliged to defend the same distinction it had spent two centuries attacking. The Hall's revised position of 4,902 concedes that the Volumes of Calibration are "not Negative but adjacent to Negative," a formulation the Chamber has never accepted and has never formally rejected.

Consultation and the Reading Room

The Volumes are consulted in the Long Room beneath the Chamber, a space of calibrated height whose ceiling is checked against Volume III each morning before the first reader is admitted. Readers are issued gloves, a witnessing officer, and a pencil of standard length. The pencil is returned. The gloves are not.

All consultation is recorded in the docket by the hour of entry and the hour of departure. Departures are recorded whether or not the reader has left. The Proceedings of the Chamber for 4,988 note that on eleven occasions in that year a reader was recorded as having departed before arriving, and that the resulting intervals were entered in Volume XX as corrections, where they remain.

Scholarly Disagreement

There is no agreement on the number of Volumes. The Third Concordance, Annex 2, fixes the count at twenty-two and forbids its revision; the Eleventh Concordance, Annex 2, fixes it at twenty-one and describes the Terminal Register as "a box, not a book." Both annexes remain in force. The Chamber complies with the first and the witnessing officers comply with the second, which is why Volume XXII is invariably counted aloud during consultation and never opened.

A minority position, advanced by the calendrical scholar Orm of the Fifth Stair and never formally answered, holds that the Volumes of Calibration are not twenty-two books but one book in twenty-two places, and that the question of number is therefore a question about the Tower's furniture. Orm's treatise was entered as a correction in Volume XXI and has since been cited chiefly as an example of what corrections are for. The Chamber of Calibrated Volumes has not commented on it. The Calibration of any instrument traceable to Volume XXI has, since 4,995, been performed with the treatise open on the bench, face down.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Register of Unwritten Volumes: what does it set out?

The Register of Unwritten Volumes (RUV) is the primary ledger of the Department of Latent Epistemology, located on Floor 451. It is the definitive catalogue of all books whose existence has been conclusively established …

Register of Unwritten Volumes
Receivers of Absence: what is it for?

Re Receivers of Absence are a class of Apparatuses maintained by the Realized Absence Guild to detect, quantify, and archive states of non-occurrence within designated Volumes of Calibration. Unlike standard Receivers, w…

Receivers of Absence
Eleventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Eleventh Concordance is a foundational administrative document ratified in Year 45 of the Third Librarianate, primarily concerned with establishing procedural guidelines for the cataloguing of non-entities and govern…

Eleventh Concordance
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.