The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Gallery of Literal Portraits

MS 3076.94 · Places and structures

The Gallery of Literal Portraits is the eastern annex of Floor 2001: The Garden of Literal Meanings, established under Amendment 47 to the Seventh Concordance. It houses the Tower's principal collection of portraits executed under the doctrine of Literal Intent, by which the declared intent of a representation governs its truth rather than its resemblance to the sitter. The Gallery comprises nine hanging halls, a comparing room, and the sealed alcove containing the Foundation Nail. It is open to accredited readers during the third and sixth watches.

Foundation and the Amendment

Before Amendment 47, portraits on Floor 2001 were governed by the older Convention of Faithful Outline, which required of a likeness only that it not be narrower than the sitter's actual shoulders. The Convention failed decisively in the winter of AC 611, when a portrait of the Third Warden was returned to the school for correction eleven times, each correction reducing the painted shoulders by one finger-width, until the canvas held a vertical line. Amendment 47 abandoned resemblance altogether. A portrait is now true if the subject's declared intent, properly witnessed and sealed, has been honoured in the painting, whether or not the painting contains the subject.

The Annex was carved from four storage galleries and a stairhead; the stairhead remained in service until AC 704, when the last of the porters agreed to walk the long way round.

Procedure of Declaration

A sitter appears before a notary of the Bureau of Literal Reckoning and states, in the presence of two clerks, what the portrait is to accomplish. The declaration is entered on a schedule of fixed forms — the sitter does not compose the language, but chooses among some three hundred approved intents — and the painter is then bound to that form. Common declarations include To be looked at from the left, To be the only portrait in a room, and To be mistaken, briefly, for a window.

Disputes arise chiefly when a declaration is honoured too thoroughly. In AC 842, a sitter declared that her portrait should hang where the light falls; the Gallery's clerks, reading the form strictly, removed the portrait from its frame and nailed it to the roof of the eastern lantern. It remained there for two years. The subsequent ruling, recorded as Reckoner's Note on the Lantern Portraits, established that a declaration governs the painting and not the building, and that no declaration may compel alterations to the fabric of a floor.

The Foundation Nail

The Foundation Nail is a ceremonial spike driven into the chamber floor at the centre of the Annex and declared immutable in its placement by the Office of Final Forms in AC 892. It is the fixed point from which all hanging positions in the Gallery are measured; every hook in the nine halls carries a lead tag giving its distance from the Nail in spans and digits. Clerks wishing to rehang a portrait must submit the new measurement and receive a countersignature. The Nail has been moved once, in AC 903, during a flood, and the resulting correction notices were still being issued in AC 940.

Relationship to Neighbouring Galleries

The Gallery of Literal Portraits is frequently confused with its neighbours and does little to discourage this. It shares a service corridor with the Gallery of Missing Portraits on Floor 419 and a comparing room with Floor 407: The Gallery of Unseen Portraits; both borrow the Annex's light table on the second and fifth days. Jurisdiction over sitters who have not yet declared an intent falls to the Gallery of Unfinished Portraits, while the principal collection on Floor 331 claims all portraits abandoned mid-declaration, a claim the Annex has never conceded in writing and has never tested in practice.

The Gallery of Unpainted Portraits on Floor 707 has twice requested the loan of the Foundation Nail for calibration and been refused both times, on the ground that the Nail is not a standard but a floor.

Scholarly Disagreement

The date of the Gallery's founding is contested. The Seventh Concordance places Amendment 47 in the year AC 688; the Eleventh Concordance, which recodifies the Seventh "for clarity" and alters it in forty-one particulars, gives AC 691. The Society for Literal Concordance holds that both dates are correct, since the Amendment was passed in 688 and the Annex opened in 691, and that the two Concordances differ only in which event they name. The School of Literal Mechanics rejects this on the ground that a Concordance may not be reconciled by appeal to facts.

"Where two Concordances assign different years to one amendment, the earlier year governs the amendment and the later governs the building. This is not a compromise. It is arithmetic."

— Eleventh Concordance, Annex 12

A smaller dispute concerns the comparing room, which appears in the inventory of the Floor 2001 annexes but not in the plan drawn for Amendment 47. It has been suggested that the room was built from the abandoned stairhead and that its doorway, which is narrower than the stair it replaced, is the only surviving witness to the original geometry. The Gallery's keepers decline to comment, though they have twice repainted the doorway and once, in AC 958, bricked it up for a season.

Visitors are asked not to bring umbrellas into the eastern lantern.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Gallery of Unfinished Portraits: how is it conducted?

The Gallery of Unfinished Portraits is a curatorial complex at Floor 11,507 specializing in the archival and restorative care of portrait artworks whose subjects remain officially unidentified. It occupies the entirety o…

Gallery of Unfinished Portraits
Office of Final Forms: who are they?

The Office of Final Forms is the administrative body responsible for the official ratification and archival declaration of a form's transition from conditional or provisional status into its permanent, immutable state wi…

Office of Final Forms
Floor 2001: The Garden of Literal Meanings: where is it?

Floor 2001: The Garden of Literal Meanings is a mid-tier repository primarily associated with the curation of linguistic artifacts and administrative case studies related to the School of Literal Adherence. Formally desi…

Floor 2001: The Garden of Literal Meanings
Floor 407: The Gallery of Unseen Portraits: where is it?

Floor 407: The Gallery of Unseen Portraits is a curated annex, formally designated under the Third Concordance (Clause 12.7.δ), dedicated to the cataloguing of portraits whose subjects have never been, and by the logic o…

Floor 407: The Gallery of Unseen Portraits

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.