The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Supervision of Guided Descents

MS 5151.74 · Practices and doctrines

The Supervision of Guided Descents is the body of rule and custom governing who may stand at the head of a sanctioned vertical expedition, in what order they descend, and what they are required to say before, during, and after it. It is treated in Clause XVII.4 of the Sixth Concordance, which requires that every Guided Descent be authorized by the Office of the Archivist-Librarian and supervised in person by a Librarian of the Third Order or higher. The clause is nine lines long. Its supervision annex is four hundred and eleven pages long, and has not been read in full by any officer presently employed in the Office of Catalogic Logistics.

The supervisory ladder

Supervision is graded by Order. A Third Order Librarian may supervise descents to floors whose numbers are known and whose names are not. A Second Order Librarian may supervise descents to floors whose names are known and whose numbers are in dispute. A First Order Librarian is required only where the floor has neither a settled number nor a settled name, and where the descent is expected to pass a floor of the second kind going down.

The grading was introduced after the descent of the winter of 1791, in which a Third Order Librarian supervised an expedition to a floor that had been catalogued under two names since the previous century. The party returned in good order; the Librarian returned with two names and no memory of which had been on the door at the start. The Descent Oversight Committee heard the matter for eleven days and ruled, in a finding later annexed to the Sixth Concordance, that "a supervisor must be senior to the ambiguity he intends to meet" (Descent Oversight Committee, Finding 14 of 1792). The wording has been quoted in every subsequent dispute and has never been clarified.

Countersignature and the Book of Ascent

Before a supervised descent departs, the supervisor signs the descent's schedule at the head, and the descending party signs below. The supervisor must also countersign the Book of Ascent maintained at the departure floor by the resident stair-clerk. The countersignature attests that the supervisor has personally counted the party and agrees with the clerk's count. Clerks are not required to agree with the supervisor's count, and where the two counts differ, the descent proceeds and the discrepancy is recorded as a Regrettable Interval.

"Where the counts differ, the party shall descend in the count of the Supervisor, and the floor shall be closed to ascent in the count of the Clerk, until both counts are reconciled or the floor is renumbered."

— Sixth Concordance, Annex II, §27

The reconciliation is ordinarily performed by the Office of Definitive Measures, which has returned four of the eleven Regrettable Intervals on record unresolved and has stated that it considers the remaining seven closed "for purposes of descent only."

Order of precedence at the head of the stair

Where two supervisors are present, precedence at the head of the stair is determined by Order first, seniority in that Order second, and the Reconciliation of Precedents third. The third criterion was added in 1804 after a descent from the eleventh landing of the northern shaft, in which a Second Order Librarian and a Third Order Librarian of longer standing reached the head of the stair simultaneously and descended abreast for ninety-one steps. The official record describes the incident as "conducted without interruption and without supervision" — a phrase that has since been cited in support of both readings of the clause.

Scholars remain divided on whether descent abreast constitutes a breach. The Seventh Concordance, Annex 3, holds that a descent may have exactly one head, and that a second head is a tail however it is placed. The Ninth Concordance does not address supervision at all, and the Concordance of Stairwells — which does, at length — is held by the Directorate to be superseded and by the Committee to be merely "resting."

The Directorate's non-registry

The Directorate of Descent oversees Guided Descents in the administrative sense while maintaining no registry of supervisors, on the ground that a supervisor is a Librarian first and a supervisor only for the duration of the descent. Practically, supervision is established by countersignature, and a Librarian who has never countersigned anything may still be found to have supervised, if the Book of Ascent shows a hand that resembles theirs and no one else claims it.

The Directorate's position has produced a small but durable dispute with the Office of Catalogic Logistics, which conducts the descents and would prefer a list. The Office petitioned for a registry in 1826, 1841, and again in 1863, when the petition was returned with a marginal note reading, "A list of supervisors is a list of Librarians under another cover, and the Librarians keep their own." The Office has kept the note in a frame in its second vestibule.

Records and exemplary cases

Supervisory conduct is judged chiefly by the absence of procedural interruption. Elara of the Unspooled Thread holds the record for seventeen consecutive Guided Descents without procedural interruption, and her supervisory notes are kept at the departure floor as a standard of practice; they consist almost entirely of counts, each written twice, the second in a smaller hand.

The record is not universally admired. The Archive of Unrealized Descents contains a fragment — catalogued under the descents that did not take place — arguing that an unbroken record of uninterrupted descents indicates a supervisor who has been careful to descend only where the stair is already agreed. The fragment is unsigned, and the Archive's custodians have declined to attribute it, noting only that it is in a Third Order hand.

Supervisors on descents of more than three floors are reminded to carry their own chalk; the stair-clerks are not obliged to supply it.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Librarians: who are they?

The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…

Librarians
Sixth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…

Sixth Concordance
Clause XVII.4: what does it set out?

Clause XVII.4 is a procedural sub-clause within the primary body of the Third Concordance, formally titled Provisions for the Authorization and Oversight of Guided Descents. It is the foundational legal instrument that p…

Clause XVII.4
Office of Definitive Measures: who are they?

The Office of Definitive Measures is a specialized regulatory body within the Tower's administrative architecture, formally charged with the establishment, maintenance, and supervision of all Instrumentals and Provisiona…

Office of Definitive Measures

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.