Second Citing Concordance
MS 7296.37 · Documents and ordinances
Scope and standing
The Second Citing Concordance is the second of the Twelve Citing Concordances, the governing instruments of the Tower's catalogue. It is the operative source of the Permanent Designation Code and of the procedural authority under which inquiries are opened, numbered, and — in the ordinary case — closed. Unlike the First Citing Concordance, which concerns only the ordering of floors, the Second is cited in disputes on average eleven times per working season, making it the most frequently invoked of the Twelve after the Twelfth Citing Concordance.
The Second Citing Concordance is conventionally cited by annex rather than by clause, a habit dating from the Ninth Scriptoria recension of 408.E, in which the marginal annotations were bound so tightly to the text that subsequent copyists could not distinguish them. The confusion has never been fully corrected, and two annexes remain in dispute as to whether they are annexes at all.
Annex VII and the Permanent Designation Code
Annex VII establishes the Permanent Designation Code, the alphanumeric scheme by which every inquiry receives a designation that it retains for the duration of its existence regardless of changes in purview, custodianship, or floor. The Code's structure — a Series numeral, a three-letter Process Designation, and a sequential integer — was not invented by the Second Citing Concordance but was merely inherited from it; the drafting committee of the First Citing Concordance had already used an identical structure in a provisional appendix that was never ratified.
The consequential sentence of Annex VII is the one that distinguishes designation from ontological standing:
"A Series 3 designation does not confer reality upon the inquiry's subject, merely its 'investigative potential'."
— Second Citing Concordance, Annex VII
This clause was inserted during the Dispute of the Silenced Subjects and has since been relied upon by the Third Spiral Index in declining to open inquiries into matters already adjudicated under Citing Concordance 4 Clause 112. Its practical effect is that a designation is a promise of attention and nothing more, a distinction that visitors to the Tower frequently fail to appreciate.
Process Designation
The formal authority for Process Designation — the three-letter middle element of every code — rests in Annex VII's second subsection, which enumerates the admissible letter combinations and forbids reuse within a Series. Enforcement of this rule is nominally the responsibility of the Botanical Registry, whose own custodianship of the Desk-Fern under Clause 22 of the Second Concordance is a separate matter and not governed by the Second Citing Concordance at all.
The enumerated combinations run to just over four thousand, and the registry of used combinations is kept on Floor 411 in a drawer that is opened on the third Tuesday of each month. In practice, clerks have found it simpler to propose a new combination and let the drawer be consulted afterward, which has produced a small body of case law on whether an issued designation can be withdrawn for collision. The prevailing view, per the Seventy-Second Concordance, Annex C, is that it cannot; the drawer records collisions but does not reverse them.
Relationship to the other Citing Concordances
The Second Citing Concordance is subordinate to the Twelfth Citing Concordance on all questions of subject status, and to Citing Concordance 4 Clause 112 on questions of access to the Vault of Unfinalized Sums. It predates both, and its drafters could not have anticipated the provisions that would later be read into their words. The Twelfth's Scholium acknowledges this openly, noting that "the phrasing of the Forty-Seventh Concordance's colophon" leaves the temporal priority of the Second ambiguous in at least one reading.
The most persistent scholarly disagreement concerns whether Annex Sigma, which is sometimes filed under the Ninety-Second Concordance and sometimes appended to the Second, was ever properly part of the Second at all. The Addendum to the Second Concordance asserts that it was; the Second Concordance, Annex D asserts that it was not. Neither document dates itself.
Custody and physical condition
The exemplar of the Second Citing Concordance is held on Floor 88, in a case that is unsealed for reading twice per season. It is written on a vellum substitute that the scriptoria no longer know how to manufacture, and two leaves are missing from the annexes. The missing leaves are not thought to contain anything of consequence, as the surrounding text scans continuously across the gap, but the Librarians have declined to certify this.
Visitors may read the exemplar by appointment; they may not turn the leaves with damp hands, and they may not cite it in a dispute without first consulting the Conflict Check register maintained on the same landing.
See also
-
MS 2494.03
Procedural Manuals
The Procedural Manuals are the operative instructional texts of the Tower, distinguished from the Concordances by function and fro…
-
MS 8090.64
Concordance Document
Concordance Document refers to any of the individual, ratified formal texts that collectively comprise the Tower’s governing Conco…
-
MS 4369.63
Concordance of Instruments
Concordance of Instruments is the collective designation for the standing instruments governing the making, sealing, depositing, a…
-
MS 9148.60
Latency Clause
Latency Clause is the collective designation for a class of jurisdictional instruments within the Tower by which a governing text …
-
MS 7093.39
Canonical Concordances
The Canonical Concordances are the official legal instruments of Tower governance, comprising every numbered Concordance ratified …
-
MS 9614.36
Concordance 34
Concordance 34 is one of the core procedural concordances governing the documentation of provisional classification within the Tow…
Referenced by
- MS 0271.80 Second Concordance, Annex Ω-7
- MS 1739.32 Decorum Code 127
- MS 7652.58 Sanitary Code 44-A
- MS 6370.27 Assignment of Disposition Code
- MS 7757.17 Process Designation
- MS 0926.68 Annex VII
- MS 2231.65 Inquiry Classification Code
- MS 3891.74 Twelve Concordance
- MS 3909.33 Anomaly Code A-77
- MS 8538.79 Permanent Designation Code (PDC)
- MS 1286.66 Source Authority
- MS 1504.83 Permanent Assignment
Readers also asked
Vault of Unfinalized Sums: where is it?
Vault of Unfinalized Sums is a dedicated archival space on Floor 1,747 (“The Abacus”) designated for the indefinite storage of provisional tallies, incomplete audits, and interim financial reconciliations rendered obsole…
Vault of Unfinalized SumsNinety-Second Concordance: what does it set out?
The Ninety-Second Concordance is a foundational administrative text concerning the procedural authorization of movement, consultation, and temporary resource reallocation within the Tower. Ratified in Year 47 of the Seco…
Ninety-Second ConcordanceBotanical Registry: who are they?
Botanical Registry is the principal executive bureau of the Office of Botanical Concordance, responsible for the primary cataloging, standardization, and procedural oversight of all documented flora within the Tower. It …
Botanical RegistryThird Spiral Index: who are they?
The Third Spiral Index is a foundational body of administrative doctrine and a primary spatial designation encompassing the Third Spiral Administrative Wing and its contiguous holdings within the Spiral Sectors. Its auth…
Third Spiral IndexPassages cited from this record
-
A Series 3 designation does not confer reality upon the inquiry's subject, merely its 'investigative potential'.
Second Citing Concordance, Annex VII
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3692.34 Dispute of the Silenced Subjects
- MS 3268.03 Ninth Scriptoria
- MS 6732.66 First Citing Concordance
Because you consulted