Resolved Anomalies
MS 1266.09 · Practices and doctrines
Resolved Anomalies is the collective designation for anomalies that have been concluded, closed, or otherwise brought to rest within the catalogue, and which nonetheless persist in the record as anomalies. The term is administrative rather than descriptive: an anomaly becomes a Resolved Anomaly not when it ceases, but when the Tower has finished deciding what to call it. Under Concordance 71: On Architectural Anomalies, 4th Revision, such matters are classed as Procedural Irregularities — contradictions absorbed into the catalogue's internal logic rather than resolved against it — with the distinction that a Resolved Anomaly has additionally received a docket number and a filing clerk's initials.
The category is maintained by the Master Index of Resolved Contradictions, which holds the authoritative tally at 11,403 entries as of the last quarter-day audit. Roughly one entry in nine is a Resolved Anomaly in the strict sense; the remainder are contradictions that were never anomalous to begin with but were entered anyway, a practice the Index has repeatedly declined to discourage.
Definition and scope
A matter qualifies for the register when three conditions obtain: it has been observed at least twice, it has been observed to differ between the two occasions, and the difference has been formally attributed to something. The attribution need not be correct. Division III: Metrological Anomalies accepts attributions made in good faith, noting that a vortical body is defined as one whose displacement about its own axis cannot be resolved into a single direction without remainder, and that the same latitude is extended to anomalies whose remainder cannot be resolved at all.
The earliest canonical instance remains Entry 1 of the Ledger of Initial Anomalies, in which a discrepancy in aperture markings on floor 44-North was concluded by Hesper Vane through the expedient of recording the stair twice. Both records stand. Neither has been withdrawn. The stair itself is not considered an anomaly.
Procedure of resolution
Resolution is performed by a Resolved Disputes Clerk, who typically invokes jurisdiction under Annex δ and files the outcome with the Central Annex of Resolved Disputes, the institution where disputes are formally concluded. Where the anomaly concerns shelving fixtures, the matter passes to the Office of Structural Continuity, as recorded for Floor 302 in the Log of Behavioral Anomalies, Vol. CXII.
The procedural difficulty is one of ordering. Resolution requires a docket, a docket requires a classification, and classification requires that the anomaly already be resolved. The Council of Resolved Ambiguities addressed this in Finding 19, which held that the sequence may be performed in any order provided the resulting file is internally consistent. Files found to be externally consistent are returned for reordering.
"An anomaly is resolved when no further question may be put to it that the file does not already answer. The file may answer wrongly. It may not answer incompletely."
— Council of Resolved Ambiguities, Finding 19, clause 6
Instrumentation
Most resolutions require no instrument beyond a pen and a second witness. Two devices are nonetheless associated with the category. The Axis of Attenuation is instrumental in the administration of the Register of Resolved Harmonics, and any application involving a Threnodic Caliper must be logged in that same Register. The Register is a client of the Kiln of Resolved Contention, whose powdered harmonic dampeners are mixed into its ink; the admixture is intended to prevent a resolved anomaly from reasserting itself in the handwriting of the clerk who closed it.
The dampeners are supplied in sealed measure. Clerks are reminded that the powder is not to be tasted, a notice posted in the scriptorium since the winter of the third recension and never rescinded.
Disagreement among the Concordances
Scholarly opinion divides on whether a Resolved Anomaly may be reopened. Concordance 71 treats resolution as final and holds that a resolved matter may be re-described but not re-opened. The Concordance of Judicial Paradoxes takes the contrary position at clause 12, arguing that a resolution which cannot be reopened is indistinguishable from a suppression and that the archive is therefore obliged to keep both readings live. The Subcommittee for Cartographic Anomalies has declined to rule, observing that its remit covers only anomalies with a boundary.
The dispute is older than either document. A 40-year feud between the Acoustic Anomalies Subcommittee and the Index of Harmonic Anomalies over whether a resolved echo may be heard again was settled in favour of the Index on procedural grounds and has since been re-litigated eleven times, each re-litigation being filed as a new resolution of the same anomaly. Practitioners cite this as the working example of a resolution that has resolved nothing, which the Corpus of Resolved Spatial Assertions classifies as a Resolved Anomaly of the second kind.
Recorded holdings
The register's principal holdings, in the order in which they were last confirmed present:
- The twice-recorded stair of floor 44-North, aperture markings unreconciled, both entries standing.
- The repositioning fixtures of Floor 302, closed and filed; the fixtures have not moved since, which the Office of Structural Continuity records as unverified.
- The unresolved echo, re-litigated eleven times.
- Puddle Anomalies, eleven instances, of which four were resolved by the simple expedient of waiting.
- Three items entered by a clerk whose initials appear nowhere else in the Index and whose file cannot be located. The items remain resolved.
Access to the register is by written application to the Central Annex. Visitors are asked to leave the reading room by the door they entered, as the other door is not always the same door.
See also
-
MS 5848.67
The Repository Question-Walls
The Repository Question-Walls is the collective designation for the load-bearing surfaces of the Repository of Unanswered Question…
-
MS 7446.16
Buffer Substrate
Buffer Substrate is the collective designation for any plate stock, flooring, or interleaving material whose declared purpose is t…
-
MS 3969.28
Secondary State
Secondary State is the collective designation for any condition of a floor, holding, or office that exists only by derivation from…
-
MS 1630.14
CycleĠ12ĠControversy
The Cycle 12 Controversy is the collective designation for the body of administrative disputes, procedural anomalies, and interpre…
-
MS 2963.18
F-771
F-771 is the catalogue designation for a floor of the Tower whose name has not been established, whose number has never been verif…
-
MS 2708.01
Logistical Anomalies
Logistical Anomalies is the collective designation, under Fourth Concordance, Annex 9, for any transit, allocation, or accounting …
Referenced by
- MS 7828.51 The Vault of Recalled Sounds
- MS 2611.68 Thermal Anomalies
- MS 9688.25 Object-Induced Anomalies
- MS 6015.49 Linguistic Anomalies
- MS 0688.22 ProceduralĠAnomalies
Readers also asked
Acoustic Anomalies Subcommittee: who are they?
Acoustic Anomalies Subcommittee is the primary research body of the Department of Acoustic Anomalies charged with the investigation, classification, and archival description of singular and recurrent sound-events occurri…
Acoustic Anomalies SubcommitteeSubcommittee for Cartographic Anomalies: who are they?
The Subcommittee for Cartographic Anomalies is a standing sub-body of the Department of Cartographic Anomalies, chartered under Concordance 14, Clause 9, to investigate, classify, and recommend resolutions for inconsiste…
Subcommittee for Cartographic AnomaliesPuddle Anomalies: how is it conducted?
Puddle Anomalies constitute a specialized sub-classification within the broader field of Acoustic Anomalies, pertaining to accumulations of liquid, primarily water, that exhibit behaviors or properties inconsistent with …
Puddle AnomaliesLedger of Initial Anomalies: what does it set out?
Form is the prerequisite for anomaly; a violation requires a boundary to be violated. This document establishes the first boundary.
Ledger of Initial AnomaliesPassages cited from this record
-
An anomaly is resolved when no further question may be put to it that the file does not already answer. The file may answer wrongly. It may not answer incompletely.
Council of Resolved Ambiguities, Finding 19, clause 6
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 2166.96 Finding 19
- MS 5184.36 Log of Behavioral Anomalies
- MS 1293.63 Office of Structural Continuity
- MS 6493.02 Division III: Metrological Anomalies
Because you consulted