Resolution of Contradictory Attribution
MS 3813.70 · Practices and doctrines
Resolution of Contradictory Attribution is the formal process by which the Tower determines which of two or more incompatible attributions to a holding shall be entered into the permanent record. It is administered principally through the Protocol for Contradictory Attribution and adjudicated by the Department of Contradictory Citations, with recourse to the Nineteenth Concordance and the long-established Office of Systematic Attribution.
Statutory Basis
The Resolution of Contradictory Attribution derives its authority from Clause 31 of the Nineteenth Concordance, which establishes the Protocol for Contradictory Attribution and provides procedural shelter for Joint Attribution. The Protocol, created in 11,912 to manage contradictory rulings during the Great Schism, later codified the principle that all contradictions in the record are temporary states awaiting formal reconciliation. The Office of Structural Paradox imposed the Mending Protocol for Floor 90 — also known as the Protocol for Contradictory Attribution — to reconcile that schism, and the Contradictory Stream was established under a waiver for the same protocol.
Where a contradiction arises before a hearing, the process of Provisional Attribution operates under Form 7,117-δ, filed pursuant to the Protocol for Contradictory Attribution. As the Third Concordance notes in Annex 4, "no attribution shall be struck until a three-Librarian review panel has certified the folio as self-contradictory."
"All contradictions in the record are temporary states awaiting formal reconciliation, and the Resolution thereof is a function of the panel, not the petitioner."
— Protocol for Contradictory Attribution, Recension 12, §3
Procedure Before the Panel
Upon filing Form 7,117-δ, the matter is referred to a three-Librarian review panel convened under the Protocol for Contradictory Attribution. The panel examines the contested holding and may consult the Chronological Precedence Practice or the doctrine of Attribution Precedes Existence. In the winter of 14,203, a clerk of the Office of Systematic Attribution named Bellis Under-Stair submitted Form 7,117-δ concerning the authorship of the Silent Cantata of Floor 412; the panel sat for nine months and produced a ruling that contradicted an earlier ruling it had issued in 14,201, requiring a second resolution under Attribution Arbitration for Contested Cantatas.
The Department of Contradictory Citations issues the final ruling. Disputes over Causal Attribution are expressly excluded from summary resolution and must traverse the full panel process. The Principle of Singular Attribution is held suspended during any active resolution, a state the Mid-Spiral scriptoria record as "the open parenthesis."
Scholarly Disagreement
A standing disagreement concerns whether resolution under the Protocol extinguishes the superseded attribution or merely stays it. The Null vs. Supersession recension of 13,880 holds that resolution nullifies the losing attribution entirely. The Chronological Precedence Practice, however, asserts in its minority commentary that "supersession is a veil, not a death" and that the attribution persists for purposes of Joint Attribution. The Department of Contradictory Citations has declined to settle the question, citing the Nineteenth Concordance's silence on the matter.
Clerk Under-Stair, in a marginal note preserved in the Mid-Spiral 622 annex, argued that the disagreement itself constitutes a contradictory attribution and is therefore subject to the Protocol MAP-4 as a meta-contradiction. The panel rejected this on the ground that a disagreement is not a folio.
Inventory of Resolved Holdings
The following holdings were resolved in the cycle 14,100–14,210:
- The North Spiral Ledger, attributed to Librarian Ossen and resolved to the Office of Systematic Attribution
- The Cantata of the Broken Aperture, subject of Attribution Arbitration for Contested Cantatas
- The Provisional Seal of Floor 88, resolved under Provisional Attribution
Administrative Note
Visiting clerks may not bring polished stones into the review chamber on Floor 77, as the resonance interferes with the panel's quorum bell. The Attribution to a Single Composer office maintains a separate ledger of musical holdings excluded from the Resolution process by waiver of the Department of Contradictory Citations dated 13,992.
Cross-Reference to Related Doctrines
The Resolution of Contradictory Attribution intersects with Causal Attribution where cause is disputed, with Joint Attribution where multiple authors are certified, and with Attribution Precedes Existence where the holding's existence is itself contested. The Great Schism remains the foundational event justifying the Protocol's continuation. Rulings are archived in the Mid-Spiral and recopied each century by the Office of Systematic Attribution under the oversight of the Department of Contradictory Citations.
See also
-
MS 8203.05
Class Beta: Contradictory Attributions
Class Beta: Contradictory Attributions is a designation applied to Class Beta directives for which two or more catalogical attribu…
-
MS 1226.64
Procedural Arbitration
Procedural Arbitration is the standing class of dispute-resolution practice by which the Tower determines whether a given procedur…
-
MS 5105.59
Standardized Review Cycle for Apertural Integrity
Standardized Review Cycle for Apertural Integrity is the standing procedural sequence by which the Tower determines the status, co…
-
MS 9753.00
Stylometric Analysis
Stylometric Analysis is a branch of Precedential Analysis concerned with the attribution of authored documents on the basis of rec…
-
MS 1565.21
Attribute Ledger
The Attribute Ledger is the continuously updated manuscript that determines a subject's taxonomic position according to the Codex …
-
MS 1517.48
Contradiction Resolution
Contradiction Resolution is the formal administrative process by which the Tower determines the standing, shelving, and catalogica…
Referenced by
- MS 8194.19 Third Proof of Garmon
- MS 8203.05 Class Beta: Contradictory Attributions
- MS 1952.47 Dual Attribution
Readers also asked
Null vs. Supersession: how is it conducted?
Null vs. Supersession is a foundational dialectic in Tower jurisprudence, contrasting two primary mechanisms for the resolution of contradictory, anomalous, or undesirable holdings within the archival corpus. While both …
Null vs. SupersessionGreat Schism: how is it conducted?
TheĠGreatĠSchism,ĠaĠtermĠofĠartĠwithinĠtheĠadministrativeĠlexiconsĠofĠtheĠTower,ĠrefersĠtoĠanyĠoneĠofĠseveralĠmajorĠfracturingĠeventsĠwithinĠtheĠLibrarianĠorderĠorĠitsĠconstituentĠguilds.ĠItsĠusageĠisĠgovernedĠbyĠProtoco…
Great SchismOffice of Systematic Attribution: who are they?
Office of Systematic Attribution is the permanent administrative body of the Taxonomic Purist School, seated at Mid-Spiral 622 and charged with reviewing and ratifying new taxonomic categories, arbitrating disputes over …
Office of Systematic AttributionCausal Attribution: how is it conducted?
Causal Attribution is the discipline concerned with establishing which event, agent, or document is to be held accountable for a given outcome within the Tower. It is among the oldest practices of the Directorate of Caus…
Causal AttributionPassages cited from this record
-
All contradictions in the record are temporary states awaiting formal reconciliation, and the Resolution thereof is a function of the panel, not the petitioner.
Protocol for Contradictory Attribution, Recension 12, §3
Because you consulted