The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Causal Attribution

MS 3162.06 · Practices and doctrines

Causal Attribution is the discipline concerned with establishing which event, agent, or document is to be held accountable for a given outcome within the Tower. It is among the oldest practices of the Directorate of Causal Forensics, and the only one whose findings are routinely appended to the findings of every other. A Causal Attribution, once entered, does not explain how something happened; it simply names the party answerable for it having happened, and is filed accordingly. The distinction is considered elementary and is the source of most disputes about the field.

The discipline should not be confused with Causal Modeling, which concerns the shape of causation, nor with Causal Re-enactment, which concerns its repetition. Causal Attribution concerns only the allocation: which name goes on the record.

History and jurisdiction

Causal Attribution was formalised under the Retro-Causal Ripple Model, which was developed to render the accounts of Causal Inversions legible at a distance of some years. The Model's early recensions attributed every ripple to a single originating name; the practice of assigning that name to a trained clerk rather than to the event itself is generally traced to Librarian Ossel Vane, whose memorandum of the winter of floor 2,904 ("The name is not the weather; the name is the clerk's opinion of the weather") was circulated in three copies and survives in one.

Jurisdiction over contested attributions is divided. The Causal Verification Bureau, the oldest continuously seated body of the Directorate, maintains the register of confirmed inversions and admits no entry without a named attribution. Where two names compete for a single outcome, the matter is deferred to the Office of Systematic Attribution under the Protocol for Contradictory Attribution, which operationalises Provisional Attribution pending hearing. Both offices report to the Directorate jointly and disagree about the order in which they do so.

The Principle of Singular Attribution and its limits

The governing doctrine is the Principle of Singular Attribution, which holds that a sound definitively linked to a single originating source may be attributed to that source and to no other. The Principle was drafted for sounds and has been extended to documents, weather, and the loss of keys; each extension required a separate annex, and the annexes have never been consolidated.

The practical difficulty is that the Principle is silent on sounds linked to no source at all. In the matter of the Hollow Bell of the Ninth Landing, which rings on no schedule and answers no instrument, three successive hearings concluded that the sound qualified for attribution and no party qualified to receive it. The hearing record notes, at clause 4, that the Bell was "attributed to the Tower, at large, for want of a smaller holder." The Nineteenth Concordance Amendment 7 later narrowed this, permitting attribution to the fabric of a structure where no other name is available, and specifically excluding stairwells.

Procedure and its failures

A standard attribution proceeds by the filing of Form 7,117-δ, a survey of the outcome's immediate antecedents by a clerk of the Directorate, and a ruling entered on the register. The form requires the claimant to name the outcome, the date of the outcome, and the party claimed; it does not require the claimant to explain the claim, which was a deliberate economy of the drafters and is now felt to have been optimistic.

The discipline's most cited failure is the Quill Dispute of Floor 1,118, in which a clerk attributed a fire in the reading room to the lamp, the lamp to its oil, the oil to its merchant, and the merchant to the merchant's mother, each attribution filed separately and each accepted. Forty-one years of hearings followed before the Directorate ruled that an attribution may name only one party at each register line, and that a chain of such lines is a modelling question rather than an attribution question. The ruling is remembered chiefly for its concluding sentence: "The clerk is to be commended for diligence and has been reassigned."

The Provisional register and the arbitration question

Provisional attributions are entered in a separate hand and are distinguished by a red marginal rule. They are valid for the duration of a hearing and no longer; a provisional attribution that outlives its hearing is void, though the register makes no automatic mark to that effect, and the Protocol MAP-4 was devised partly to catch these. Disputes over provisional entries are arbitrated under Attribution Arbitration for Contested Cantatas where the outcome is acoustic and under ordinary procedure otherwise.

Scholars disagree about whether Causal Attribution is a science of the past or a means of distributing blame. The Causal Mechanics Chapter holds, in its third recension, that attribution is purely descriptive and carries no fault; Subclause 9.2: Causal Imprint Analysis proceeds as though it carried fault and has been amended accordingly, adding a "degree of answerability" to every entry. Directive 7-Δ attempted to settle the matter by declaring that the question was one of vocabulary, not of cause, and is now cited by both sides.

Relation to conservation

Attribution is bounded by the Principle of Causal Conservation, under which causal mass cannot be created or destroyed, only redistributed. An attribution therefore does not add to the mass; it records where the mass currently sits. Clerks are reminded that a name entered on the register moves the mass, and that a careless attribution is not a clerical error but a transfer. The Directorate's standing notice on the subject is affixed to the door of the register room and reads: "Names are heavy. Sign in and out."

Attributions are not corrected by erasure. A superseded name is struck through, initialled, dated, and left legible, and the register of the Causal Verification Bureau has been described by its keepers as a palimpsest of everyone the Tower has ever held responsible.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Causal Verification Bureau: who are they?

The Causal Verification Bureau is the oldest continuously seated body of the Directorate of Causal Forensics, established to determine whether an event recorded in the Tower was caused by an event preceding it, or merely…

Causal Verification Bureau
Office of Systematic Attribution: who are they?

Office of Systematic Attribution is the permanent administrative body of the Taxonomic Purist School, seated at Mid-Spiral 622 and charged with reviewing and ratifying new taxonomic categories, arbitrating disputes over …

Office of Systematic Attribution
Causal Inversions: how is it conducted?

Causal Inversions are the class of recorded events in which the operative sequence of cause and effect within a Tower holding is found to have run in reverse, such that the effect precedes its cause in the archive withou…

Causal Inversions
Causal Re-enactment: how is it conducted?

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.