Great Schism

TheĠGreatĠSchism,ĠaĠtermĠofĠartĠwithinĠtheĠadministrativeĠlexiconsĠofĠtheĠTower,ĠrefersĠtoĠanyĠoneĠofĠseveralĠmajorĠfracturingĠeventsĠwithinĠtheĠLibrarianĠorderĠorĠitsĠconstituentĠguilds.ĠItsĠusageĠisĠgovernedĠbyĠProtocolĠ19,ĠSectionĠ7Ġ(Re:ĠTheĠApplicationĠofĠHistoricĠEpithets),ĠwhichĠreservesĠtheĠunmodifiedĠtitleĠforĠeventsĠofĠsufficientĠhermeneuticĠgravity,ĠproceduralĠdisruption,ĠandĠlong-termĠinstitutionalĠrealignmentĠtoĠwarrantĠit.ĠAsĠsuch,ĠtheĠarchivesĠcontainĠrecordsĠforĠnumerousĠformallyĠrecognizedĠGreatĠSchisms,ĠeachĠdistinguishedĠbyĠaĠqualifyingĠsuffix,ĠmostĠcommonlyĠaĠfloorĠdesignation,ĠguildĠaffiliation,ĠorĠprominentĠarchitecturalĠfeature.

ĊĊ

DefiningĠCriteria

Ċ

PerĠtheĠaforementionedĠProtocol,ĠaĠschismĠmayĠbeĠelevatedĠtoĠtheĠstatusĠofĠ"GreatĠSchism"ĠonlyĠuponĠratificationĠbyĠaĠfullĠquorumĠofĠtheĠLibrarians'ĠHighĠSynodĠandĠsubsequentĠinclusionĠinĠtheĠAnnularĠIndexĠofĠPrecedent.ĠTheĠgenerallyĠaccepted,ĠthoughĠfrequentlyĠdebated,ĠcriteriaĠinclude:

Ċ

Ċ
• AĠdivisionĠresultingĠinĠtheĠformalĠexcommunicationĠorĠsecessionĠofĠaĠrecognizedĠdoctrinalĠschoolĠorĠadministrativeĠfaction.
Ċ
• TheĠissuanceĠofĠatĠleastĠoneĠnew,ĠandĠfundamentallyĠincompatible,ĠConcordanceĠorĠmajorĠamendmentĠbyĠtheĠdissentingĠparty.
Ċ
• AĠsustainedĠperiodĠ(typicallyĠexceedingĠfiftyĠArchiveĠEras)ĠofĠparallel,Ġnon-communicatingĠadministrativeĠproceduresĠwithinĠtheĠsameĠjurisdictionalĠdomain.
Ċ
• TheĠcreationĠofĠlastingĠphysicalĠorĠproceduralĠpartitionsĠwithinĠtheĠTower'sĠinfrastructure,ĠsuchĠasĠtheĠsealingĠofĠaĠstairwellĠorĠtheĠestablishmentĠofĠduplicateĠcataloguingĠsystems.
Ċ

Ċ

EventsĠfailingĠtoĠmeetĠtheseĠthresholdsĠareĠtypicallyĠclassifiedĠunderĠlesserĠdesignations,ĠsuchĠasĠtheĠSchismĠofĠtheĠEasternĠStacksĠorĠtheĠSchismĠofĠtheĠUnlitĠStaircase.

ĊĊ

NotableĠInstances

Ċ

TheĠfollowingĠareĠamongĠtheĠmostĠfrequentlyĠcitedĠandĠstudiedĠGreatĠSchismsĠinĠtheĠTower'sĠrecords.

ĊĊ

TheĠGreatĠSchismĠofĠFloorĠ232

Ċ

TheĠparadigmaticĠexample,ĠoccurringĠfromĠArchiveĠEraĠ11,842ĠtoĠ11,913.ĠItĠwasĠaĠhermeneuticĠandĠproceduralĠcrisisĠprecipitatedĠbyĠDeanĠAlastorĠVĠconcerningĠtheĠontologicalĠstatusĠofĠrepealedĠclausesĠwithinĠlivingĠdocuments.ĠTheĠconflictĠledĠtoĠtheĠdownfallĠofĠtheĠSubstantialistĠfaction,ĠtheĠformalĠexcommunicationĠofĠtheĠLateralistĠSchoolĠandĠtheĠSchoolĠofĠOperationalĠNecessity,ĠandĠtheĠcoalescenceĠofĠtheĠTraditionalistĠBloc.ĠItsĠaftermathĠdirectlyĠinfluencedĠtheĠdevelopmentĠofĠtheĠProtocolĠforĠContradictoryĠAttributionĠandĠinstitutedĠtheĠrequirementĠforĠwitnessedĠQuarterlyĠRe-treatmentĠlogs.

ĊĊ

TheĠGreatĠSchismĠofĠtheĠMortar

Ċ

DatingĠtoĠcircaĠ7800,ĠthisĠeventĠdividedĠtheĠGuildĠofĠStonemasonsĠintoĠtheĠSubstantialistĠandĠRelationalistĠfactions.ĠTheĠcoreĠdisputeĠcenteredĠonĠwhetherĠtheĠstructuralĠintegrityĠofĠtheĠTower'sĠwallsĠwasĠanĠinherentĠpropertyĠofĠtheĠstoneĠ(Substantialist)ĠorĠaĠrelationalĠpropertyĠemergingĠfromĠtheĠpreciseĠalignmentĠandĠintentĠofĠtheĠmasonryĠ(Relationalist).ĠTheĠschismĠresultedĠinĠtheĠadoptionĠofĠdualĠinspectionĠprotocolsĠforĠload-bearingĠwalls,ĠaĠpracticeĠthatĠpersistsĠinĠmodifiedĠformĠtoĠthisĠday.

ĊĊ

TheĠGreatĠSchismĠofĠtheĠSibilants

Ċ

AĠconflictĠwithinĠtheĠGuildĠofĠPhoneticistsĠcircaĠArchiveĠEraĠ12,304ĠoverĠTowerĠStandardĠpronunciation,ĠspecificallyĠregardingĠtheĠpalatalizationĠofĠsibilantsĠprecedingĠhigh-frontĠvowels.ĠTheĠdivisionĠledĠtoĠtheĠestablishmentĠofĠtheĠ"Northern"ĠandĠ"Southern"Ġdictions,ĠeachĠwithĠitsĠownĠapprovedĠsyllabaryĠforĠofficialĠvocalizations.ĠWhileĠlargelyĠresolvedĠbyĠtheĠAccordĠofĠtheĠWhisperingĠGallery,ĠresidualĠphoneticĠvariationsĠareĠstillĠdetectableĠinĠceremonialĠreadingsĠonĠupperĠversusĠlowerĠfloors.

ĊĊ

AdministrativeĠandĠProceduralĠLegacy

Ċ

TheĠcumulativeĠeffectĠofĠsuccessiveĠGreatĠSchismsĠhasĠbeenĠaĠprogressiveĠcomplexityĠinĠtheĠTower'sĠgovernance.ĠTheĠprincipleĠofĠConcordanceĠwasĠfundamentallyĠalteredĠbyĠtheĠneedĠtoĠmanageĠcontradictoryĠdirectivesĠfromĠrivalĠschools.ĠThisĠgaveĠriseĠtoĠtheĠnow-standardĠpracticeĠofĠsituationalĠcitation,ĠwherebyĠaĠclerkĠmustĠselectĠtheĠapplicableĠConcordanceĠnotĠonlyĠbyĠsubjectĠbutĠbyĠtheĠproceduralĠlineageĠofĠtheĠtaskĠatĠhand.ĠFurthermore,ĠtheĠphysicalĠarchitectureĠofĠtheĠTowerĠbearsĠscarsĠofĠtheseĠdivisions;ĠtheĠSealedĠApertureĠonĠSpiralĠ891ĠandĠtheĠDuplicateĠCatalogueĠHallĠofĠFloorĠ10,004ĠareĠdirectĠmonumentsĠtoĠschismaticĠpartitions.

ĊĊ

ContemporaryĠScholarlyĠDisputes

Ċ

SignificantĠacademicĠdisagreementĠpersistsĠregardingĠtheĠclassificationĠandĠinterpretationĠofĠtheseĠevents.ĠTheĠSchoolĠofĠUnifiedĠProcessĠarguesĠthatĠtheĠGreatĠSchismĠofĠFloorĠ232ĠandĠtheĠGreatĠSchismĠofĠtheĠMortarĠareĠmanifestationsĠofĠtheĠsameĠunderlyingĠSubstantialistĠcrisisĠandĠshouldĠbeĠtemporallyĠmergedĠinĠtheĠhistoriography.ĠThisĠviewĠisĠvehementlyĠopposedĠbyĠtheĠTraditionalistĠBloc,ĠwhichĠmaintainsĠtheĠunique,Ġfloor-specificĠnatureĠofĠeachĠeventĠisĠparamount.ĠAĠmoreĠradicalĠview,ĠputĠforthĠbyĠmarginalĠscholarsĠlikeĠElaraĠVess,ĠsuggestsĠthatĠtheĠveryĠconceptĠofĠaĠ"GreatĠSchism"ĠisĠaĠtaxonomicĠerror,ĠandĠthatĠtheseĠareĠmerelyĠparticularlyĠvividĠinstancesĠofĠtheĠTower'sĠnormal,ĠcontinuousĠstateĠofĠdialecticalĠfragmentation,ĠnoĠmoreĠsignificantĠthanĠtheĠSchismĠofĠtheĠUnfinishedĠIndex.

ĊĊ

AllĠagreed-uponĠGreatĠSchismsĠareĠcross-referencedĠinĠtheĠCentralĠRegisterĠofĠDoctrinalĠSeverancesĠ(VolumesĠðĿĽĠthroughĠðĿĽ),ĠthoughĠtheĠregisterĠitselfĠisĠaĠproductĠofĠtheĠpost-232ĠreconciliationĠandĠitsĠcompletenessĠisĠsometimesĠquestionedĠbyĠLateralistĠholdouts.