The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Protocol of Anticipated Presence

MS 8845.57 · Practices and doctrines

The Protocol of Anticipated Presence is a practice of negative inscription, established by Librarian ordinance and administered chiefly through the Bureau of Predictive Shelving. It does not record what is present. It establishes, in advance and in writing, what a phenomenon would have looked like had it manifested, so that its failure to manifest may be registered as a distinct and citable event rather than as silence. The Protocol is inscribed, never spoken, onto the inner surface of a Receiver of Absence's Frame, and the resulting inscription is commonly described in the calibration literature as a "negative template": a specification of an absence, held open until the absence either occurs or is withdrawn.

Origin and first recension

The Protocol is first attested in the Manual of Latent Topography, which cites it as already long established at the time of the Manual's third recension. The Concordance of Unfilled Frames, clause 12, fixes its legal character: the Protocol is a practice of anticipation, not of prediction, and an inscribed Frame that anticipates wrongly is not in error but is "merely anticipating something other than what occurred, which is a different instrument." The distinction has been litigated, inconclusively, for centuries.

The earliest surviving recension prescribes a single line of inscription per anticipated phenomenon. The current recension, revised in the winter of Floor -9 and never formally adopted, prescribes three, and the divergence has never been reconciled. The Bureau has continued to accept Frames inscribed to either recension, a latitude that later occasioned the Dispute of the Second Line.

Inscription and the negative template

Inscribing the Protocol requires that the Frame's inner surface be prepared first by the calibration procedure set out in the Manual of Latent Topography. The template is then written in the negative: the clerk inscribes not the phenomenon's properties but the exact form of its non-appearance, including the interval during which the non-appearance is to be counted. A Receiver so inscribed will register a null result as a positive reading. The distinction between a Receiver that has registered nothing and a Receiver that has registered the absence of something is the entire burden of the Protocol, and the source of nearly all its difficulties.

Where the anticipated phenomenon pertains to an object's material presence, the inscribed result must be confirmed under the Dual-Guild Verification Protocol by both a tactile and an optical guild before the reading is entered in the running sequence. Where the object in question is a reply, the reading is passed instead to the Anticipated-But-Unreceived Reply (A.B.U.R.) and does not enter the sequence at all.

The coining of Anticipated Precedence

The Protocol's best-known consequence is the doctrine of Anticipated Precedence, which arose from a routine dispute in the Room of Required Presence concerning the order of two inscriptions copied from a damaged register. Clerk Emeric Vaunt-Tolliver, then in his fourteenth year at the Bureau, argued that the Protocol itself conferred precedence on the earlier inscription, since an anticipation that preceded another anticipation had anticipated more of the interval and was therefore the more complete anticipation. The Repository of Anticipated Forms adopted the argument in its Ruling on the Ordering of Inscriptions, and Anticipated Precedence has been administered jointly by that Repository and by the Sub-Basement of Anticipated Echoes ever since — a joint administration described in the Repository's own minor annals as "structural rather than cordial."

"An anticipation entered first has waited longest, and a longer wait recruits a deeper frame. The practice is therefore ordered by the depth of its waiting, and not by the date on the register, which is often wrong."

— Ruling on the Ordering of Inscriptions, § 3

Vaunt-Tolliver later petitioned for the ruling to be reversed, on the ground that the register had been mislaid rather than damaged. The petition was refused, and he was transferred to the Bureau of Predictive Shelving's outlying desk, where he is recorded as having inscribed one hundred and eleven Frames to the superseded single-line recension before his grievance was noted. They remain in service.

Application to anticipated phenomena

The Protocol is applied wherever the Tower maintains an anticipated form. The Hum of Anticipated Rain, catalogued on Floor -12: The Repository of Anticipated Forms, is inscribed against the chronostatic dampening field of that floor, by a method of the same pattern as that used in the Chamber of Anticipated Sound. Motions awaiting arrival in the Corridor of Anticipated Motions are inscribed in advance of their transit, and their non-arrival is registered at the corridor's western aperture. The registration of anticipations that do not pertain to sound, form, or motion is governed by the more general practice of Presence Through Absence, with which the Protocol is frequently confused by junior clerks and never by senior ones.

No Frame is to be inscribed on a day on which the Bureau has already registered an absence, as the second inscription tends to be counted against the first.

Disputed readings

The principal scholarly disagreement turns on whether the Protocol registers non-manifestation or merely the expectation of it. The Third Concordance, Annex 4, holds that a properly inscribed Frame registers the absence itself, and that the absence is therefore a fact of the Tower from the moment of inscription. The Concordance of Unfilled Frames contradicts this directly at clause 19, asserting that the Protocol "establishes only what would have been, which is not a thing but a direction in which a thing might have been looked for."

The contradiction has been referred to the Triage Protocol Alpha on three occasions, and on each the matter was found insufficiently probable to justify review for a Class Alpha Anticipated Amendment — a determination that has itself been read as a ruling in favour of the Third Concordance, an interpretation the Bureau has declined to confirm. The Observer of Presence is not competent to resolve the question and has twice said so.

In practice, clerks resolve the difficulty by inscribing both readings on the Frame and accepting whichever the Receiver returns first. The Protocol of Anticipated Presence is unusual among the Tower's practices in that its most common working version is not the one written down anywhere.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Manual of Latent Topography: what does it set out?

“…a disciplinary architecture not of space, but of its absence.”

Manual of Latent Topography
Floor -12: The Repository of Anticipated Forms: where is it?

Floor -12: The Repository of Anticipated Forms is a sub-basement archive designated for the pre-custodial processing, validation, and temporary storage of procedural documents filed prior to the events they concern. Loca…

Floor -12: The Repository of Anticipated Forms
Class Alpha Anticipated Amendment: what does it set out?

Class Alpha Anticipated Amendment is a procedural instrument administered in the Tower when a Class Alpha holding is expected to enter active, cross-floortal legal contention before the contention is formally docketed. T…

Class Alpha Anticipated Amendment
Anticipated-But-Unreceived Reply (A.B.U.R.): how is it conducted?

Anticipated-But-Unreceived Reply (conventionally abbreviated A.B.U.R.) is a catalogued affective state of the kind administered by the Repository of Anticipated Forms on Floor -12: The Repository of Anticipated Forms. It…

Anticipated-But-Unreceived Reply (A.B.U.R.)

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.