The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Anticipated Precedence

MS 4576.68 · Practices and doctrines

Anticipated Precedence is the doctrine, and the corresponding body of filings, by which the Tower assigns rank to a claim before the claim has been made. It is distinct from ordinary Precedence Assignment, which settles the order of parties already present, and from Precedence Dilemma, which arises when two present parties cannot be ordered. Anticipated Precedence concerns the party who has not yet arrived, has not yet filed, and in most recorded instances has not yet been born into the obligation that will bring them forward.

The doctrine is administered jointly by the Repository of Anticipated Forms on Floor -12: The Repository of Anticipated Forms and the Office of Provisional Seating, an arrangement that has been described in two Concordances and reconciled in neither.

Origins

The practice is conventionally dated to Year 745, the same year in which Marlo's Treatise on Anticipated Grounds fixed the four conditions for classifying an entity as a Potentialist. The Potentialist School holds that an entity capable of arriving is already, in the relevant sense, present, and that the archive is therefore obliged to hold a place for it. Marlo himself is not recorded as having said anything about seating. The extension from substance to rank was made by the Second Concordance on Order, Clause 31, which reads in full: "That which shall stand shall stand somewhere."

Clause 31 was intended as a remark about the stability of shelving. Its reinterpretation as a procedural principle is attributed to the registrar Hennet of the Fourth Landing, who in Year 902 refused to close a hearing on the grounds that a chair remained empty and that the empty chair would one day object. Hennet's ruling was overturned in Year 904 and has been cited in support of every subsequent Anticipated Precedence question.

Mechanism

A party seeking Anticipated Precedence files an Application for Rank in Advance (ARA-9) with the Office of Provisional Seating, naming the anticipated claimant, the anticipated claim, and the interval within which the claim is expected. The application is docketed, sealed with a grey wafer, and given a rank. The rank is binding on no one and is entered on the roll as though it were.

The roll is not a forecast. Librarians are careful to distinguish Anticipated Precedence from prediction: the rank assigned to an anticipated claimant does not alter the likelihood of that claimant's arrival, nor does the failure of an anticipated claim to materialise strike the rank from the roll. Ranks assigned to claimants who never arrive are transferred, by an instrument known as the Quiet Conveyance, to the general reserve, where they accumulate.

The general reserve currently holds 41,608 unclaimed ranks, of which 9,112 are of the first order. A proposal to redistribute them among junior clerks was raised in Year 1188 and suppressed. The suppression order was itself filed in advance, against the possibility of such a proposal, in Year 1102.

Relation to the Manifest Series

Anticipated Precedence is frequently confused with the filing requirements of the Manifest of Anticipated Arrival, which the Repository of Anticipated Forms holds in bulk as principal custodian. The distinction is procedural and is insisted upon. An Manifest of Anticipated Arrival records that something is expected. Anticipated Precedence records where it will sit when it comes. A manifest may be filed without any rank attaching, and a rank may be assigned to a claimant for whom no manifest has ever been lodged — a circumstance the Repository's own guidance describes as "untidy but regular."

The overlap is not merely conceptual. Both instruments were the subject of Precedence Edict 22/1, which attempted to fix a single filing date for the two and instead created a class of filings that are simultaneously anticipated and outstanding. Filings of that class are held in Sub-archive 72.8 pending resolution, and have been so held since the Edict's partial revocation.

"Where an anticipated party is ranked and unmanifested, the clerk shall not inquire after the party. The clerk shall inquire after the rank."

— Precedence Edict Protocol, Clause 15

Dispute: the Empty Chair Question

The doctrine's chief difficulty is what the Edicts of Precedence call the Empty Chair Question: whether a rank assigned in advance survives the abandonment of the anticipated claim. The Third Concordance holds at Annex 6 that ranks lapse upon abandonment, and that the chair is to be struck from the roll and carried to storage. The Concordance of the Fifth Stair holds at Clause 9 that no rank lapses, since the abandonment of a claim cannot be established until the claimant fails to appear, and the claimant cannot be established to have failed until the anticipated interval has run, which interval, in cases of Anticipated Precedence, is undefined.

The two provisions have not been reconciled. The practical effect is that most ranks are neither struck nor enforced, and the roll grows. The Bureau of Lapsed Ranks, established in Year 1204 to resolve the contradiction, adopted the Third Concordance's reading and was dissolved in Year 1209 for having resolved it.

Notable filings

The earliest surviving ARA-9 dates to Year 911 and anticipates a claimant identified only as "the one who will contest the matter of the west stair." The claim was never made. The rank remains on the roll at fourth order, and the west stair remains closed to traffic between the hours of the ninth and eleventh bell on the grounds that its anticipated contestant may be using it.

Hennet of the Fourth Landing, whose ruling opened the practice, later filed an ARA-9 anticipating his own successor. The application was accepted. The successor was never named, the position was never declared vacant, and the rank is held in perpetuity by a chair in the Office of Provisional Seating which is dusted on the first of each month and sat in by no one.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Precedence Assignment: how is it conducted?

The Precedence Assignment is the formal administrative act by which the Librarians resolve a conflict of precedence and designate the specific protocol, clause, or procedural standard that shall govern a pending archival…

Precedence Assignment
Potentialist School: who are they?

The Potentialist School is a modern interpretive and administrative body within the Tower dedicated to the stewardship, verification, and philosophical examination of Potentialist cataloguing. It is formally recognized a…

Potentialist School
Precedence Edict 22/1: what does it set out?

Precedence Edict 22/1 is an instrument of the Precedence Edict Protocol that formalized the principle of Exclusive Inference as the primary adjudicative mechanism for contradictions within the Silence Edict annexes. Prom…

Precedence Edict 22/1
Repository of Anticipated Forms: who are they?

The Repository of Anticipated Forms is an archival repository located on Floor -12 of the Tower, charged with the custody of documents, instruments, and notarized theoretical blueprints prior to the events those document…

Repository of Anticipated Forms

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.