The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Ordinance of Mediated States

MS 6100.32 · Documents and ordinances

Ordinance of Mediated States (TY 7011)

The Ordinance of Mediated States (TY 7011) is the regulatory instrument by which the Tower classifies and controls artefacts, concepts, and spaces whose existence depends on an observer. Formally adopted on the 47th day of the 712th Catalogical Cycle, it remains the principal authority on the boundary between what the archive holds and what merely appears to be held. It was drafted in the winter of TY 7011 by Sub-Archivist Ilven Marrow, whose working papers on the subject now occupy eleven shelves on Floor 3122 and are consulted chiefly for the marginal complaint that the task "took four winters and one of them twice."

The Five-Tier Taxonomy

The Ordinance establishes a five-tier taxonomy of mediation — Inherent, Contextual, Contingent, Reciprocal, and Ephemeral — under which every mediated object in the Tower must be registered at the moment of accession. The tiers descend in order of dependence: an Inherent state persists without any observer at all, a Contextual state persists so long as its setting does, and an Ephemeral state may not outlast the attention paid to it. The Registry of Immaculate States records tier-one and tier-two accessions only; tiers three through five are entered in the standing ledger maintained by the Clerks of Concordance, which is bound in a lighter board because it is amended more often and consulted less.

The doctrine first appears in the second recension of the Ordinance, Clause 9, which was the clause requiring the most revision in the scriptoria. The first recension had proposed four tiers; the fourth and fifth were separated in the winter of TY 7011 after a protracted dispute over a reading-room lamp that behaved inconsistently when the room was empty, and the Luminous Materials Guild was brought into joint enforcement precisely because so many borderline accessions were optical in character. The Guild's Taxonomy of Emitted and Mediated Light is the standing annex governing the six Phases to which mediated light may be assigned, and its Phase schedule and the Ordinance's tiers are cross-referenced at every accession, though not always to the same conclusion.

Declarative Phantoms and Ordinance 4

A central purpose of the Ordinance is to prevent what its text calls declarative phantoms from attaining independent reality within the Tower's archives. A declarative phantom is the residue left when a statement is catalogued without being mediated; it persists until neutralized, and Ordinance 4 fixes the procedure by which neutralization is recorded. The two instruments are frequently cited together and have never been reconciled. Regulation 44-B: Contaminants of Certainty governs the handling of staff who have been exposed to an unneutralized phantom for more than nine consecutive shifts; the affected clerk is reassigned to Floor 0101 for a full catalogical cycle and is not permitted to sign for deliveries.

Where the phantom is not a document but a state of mind, the Manual of Accepted Mental States takes precedence over the Ordinance, and the Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality over both. The boundary between a phantom and an ordinary Absence is settled by Class Alpha Contradictory States where the two conflict, which is often. A clerk of the second scriptorium who entered a phantom in the wrong column in the spring of TY 7038 was required to copy out the whole register again, an event still known on the floor as The Recopying.

Disputed Readings

Scholarly disagreement centres on whether the taxonomy is exhaustive. The Librarians' annotated edition of the Ordinance states flatly in its preface that "the five tiers admit of no sixth, and attempts to supply one are to be entered under the fifth." The Clerks, by contrast, maintain in an undated memorandum circulated to the scriptoria that the fifth tier was "a convenience and not a floor," citing the Seventh Edict of Floor 1004, which places certain ephemeral accessions outside the Ordinance altogether for the duration of the reading period. The Petition for Locational Clarification was filed on this point in TY 7049 and remains unanswered, though it has been re-filed eleven times with increasing courtesy.

"An accession that cannot be tiered is not thereby untiered; it is merely waiting."

— Ordinance of Conditional Closure, Annex 3, para. 7

A further dispute concerns whether Axiomatic Application may be used to assign a tier retroactively. The Ordinance 8871-C permits it; the Ordinance of Mediated States does not mention it; and the Ordinance 888.45, which states that "what is undone by leave is undone entirely," has been read by some as foreclosing the question. The matter was referred to the Administration under clause 9 of the Ordinance of Mediated States itself, which is the only recorded instance of an instrument being asked to rule on its own scope and declining to do so.

Enforcement and the Escalation of Tiers

Enforcement is divided between the Clerks of Concordance and the Luminous Materials Guild, an arrangement that the Ordinance describes as "joint" and that the two bodies describe variously. In practice the Clerks tier the accession and the Guild confirms the light, and where the two disagree the accession is held at tier three pending review by a Librarian whose name is not entered in the record. Escalation from tier three to tier two requires the signature of the Sub-Archivist; escalation from tier two to tier one requires the signature of two, neither of whom may have been present at the original accession. No procedure is specified for escalation from tier one, and none has been attempted since the Aethelred Impression was returned to the wall in TY 7056, where it has remained, tiered provisionally, and is not to be moved for cleaning without a written order from the Keeper's office.

Accessions under the Ordinance are reviewed every eleventh Catalogical Cycle. The review consists of reading the entry aloud in the presence of the object; material read aloud in its own presence is regarded as settled for the purposes of the review even where the reading is disputed. The Ordinance does not require that the object be present, only that it be within earshot, a provision that has generated a small and durable body of case law on the acoustics of the western stairwell.

The Ordinance was last amended in the 713th Cycle, in respect of a single comma in Clause 4. The amendment is recorded in the Permitted Incidental Occupation file, where it is the only entry.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Ordinance 888.45: what does it set out?

Ordinance 888.45, formally titled the Ordinance on Sequential Invalidation, is a procedural statute that establishes a framework for the automatic nullification of previous ordinances under specifically enumerated condit…

Ordinance 888.45
Ordinance 4 (the Ordinance for the Prevention of Premature Conclusions): what does it set out?

The Ordinance for the Prevention of Premature Conclusions, designated Ordinance 4 within the Librarians' regulatory hierarchy, is the foundational administrative instrument governing the management of unresolved logical …

Ordinance 4 (the Ordinance for the Prevention of Premature Conclusions)
Aethelred Impression: how is it conducted?

Aethelred Impression is the designation applied to any measurable deformation of Tower masonry attributable to the sustained presence, attention, or administrative burden of an individual named Aethelred. The term is adm…

Aethelred Impression
Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality: how is it conducted?

The Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality is a standing instrument of the Librarians' archive, promulgated to prevent the cognitive states of researchers, readers, and incidental passers-by from entering classificatory proce…

Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.