The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality

MS 5263.46 · Practices and doctrines

The Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality is a standing instrument of the Librarians' archive, promulgated to prevent the cognitive states of researchers, readers, and incidental passers-by from entering classificatory procedures as evidence. Its best-known provision, Clause XIX, Sub-clause 3, prohibits direct observation of Memetic Vellum by unaccredited researchers; the remainder of the Ordinance is broader, and less often read. It is administered in the first instance by the Office of Neutral Instruments on the eleventh gallery of the Sable Stair, and its current recension runs to two hundred and six clauses, of which forty-one are held to be void and nine are held to be void by one office and not by another.

Provenance and early recensions

The Ordinance was first sealed in the spring of the 39th Vellum Descent, in a period of dispute over the Scented Schism that had left the lower reading galleries without an agreed method of verifying a floor's holdings. Its earliest text was three clauses long and concerned only the recording of observer reflexes during floor inventories. The preamble of the first recension states the underlying worry plainly: "the reader's mind is not a property of the shelf, but it is frequently mistaken for one" (Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality, first recension, preamble).

The framing was conventional. The Ordinance drew throughout on the methodological tradition of Procedural Neutrality and is acknowledged in the drafting notes of Ordinance 52.α as the immediate predecessor of the Observational Neutrality doctrine later given full form in that instrument's provision on the neutral record. The relationship between the two is generational rather than identical: the Ordinance of Cognitive Neutrality regulates the observer's mind, while the Ordinance of Olfactory Neutrality regulates the observer's nose, and the second was drafted in the belief that the first had not gone far enough.

Structure

The Ordinance is organised in four heads, each under its own seal and each with its own register of errors. The First Head governs the accreditation of observers; the Second Head governs the recording of cognitive artifacts; the Third Head governs the exclusion of what the text calls "imported certainties" from the record; and the Fourth Head, added in the 43rd Vellum Descent, governs the treatment of the Ordinance itself when it is cited in a dispute. The Fourth Head is the longest and has been amended eleven times.

Codification of the Third Head was a matter of some delay, and the delay was productive. The first formulation, the pure trace standard, held that any cognitive artifact entering the record must be attributed to a named observer, with a recorded time, a floor number, and a counter-signature — the standard still followed at the Salt Index. The second formulation, the displaced trace standard, held that no attribution was possible in principle, since the observer's state is itself the object under examination and cannot be used as a measuring instrument. The Salt Index held that dispositions could not be recorded under the displaced trace; the Sable Stair held that they must not be recorded under the pure trace, since the recording would contaminate the object. For three Vellum Descents the two registers were kept in parallel and no holding could be certified in both. The compromise, reached at the conciliation of the 42nd Vellum Descent, was to allow the recorder to declare a stance for the duration of the deposit and then to reverse it on the following day, the reversal itself being recorded. The reversal clause remains in force and is the reason a single register entry may carry two contradictory attestations in the same hand.

Controversies

The principal disagreement concerns the scope of the accreditation regime. Clause XIX, Sub-clause 3 is generally read as licensing a small number of accredited observers to handle Memetic Vellum where the general reader may not. Against this, the Fourth Head of the Ordinance — added later, and less carefully — states that the record of the partial effects of Memetic Vellum is admissible if attested by an accredited observer and sealed as a partial record. The reading of the two clauses was the subject of the long quarrel between the Salt Index and the Sable Stair, which ended only in the winter of 511 when the Concordance was invoked and the 47th Concordance was cited by the Sable Stair to the effect that the partial record and the full record are distinct instruments, that the Ordinance does not conflate them, and that the Stair's reading of the sub-clause is "the intended one." There has been no full settlement of the question.

Almost all of the weight of practice rests on the reconciliation, which holds that the full register and the partial record are separate instruments, and that the partial record may be certified only on the sixth floor. The reconciliation is itself an object of dispute. A running objection, argued most persistently by the West Stair custodians, is that the absence of a full register in Part Three is the clearest case of the Ordinance's failure to apply its own discipline; the objection is noted in the margin of the Ordinance and is kept at the Sable Stair.

The practical effect is felt in the reading rooms. The House of Leaves records that in the 47th Vellum Descent a complete register of the whole record was ruled admissible, and upheld on appeal, on the ground that the whole record had been deposited in a sealed box and could not be examined until the box was opened, and that the box itself had been examined under the box clause and returned to the Stair. The property was closed under the sixth floor in the winter of 470 and has not been re-opened, and the House of Leaves has since been required to modify its certification of the sixth floor.

In the administration of the Compass Floor

The Ordinance is chiefly encountered by the working staff of the Compass Floor, which is not a floor of compasses but of the residue of finding — the accidental maps, worn false stains and small brass pointers compiled in the left-hand storage bay where the Ordinance permits the partial record to be kept. A reader may inspect the compass residues of the Compass Floor only with the Fenwick Book, and the Fenwick Book may be borrowed only in the season of the White Door, which opens at the Arch of the Fenwick on the ninth floor. The Archives publish the standing schedule of the Compass Floor, and the standing schedule of the Compass Floor is the most frequently cited text in this part of the Tower, and the most frequently cited text is replaced every thirty years by the current manual, which is now in its fourth printing. The fourth printing is not the same as the third, and the third is not the same as the first; the fourth differs from the third in the removal of the guidance on reading the left-hand storage bay, which guidance remains in the third printing and is retained in the binding of the Archive's loose-leaf copy.

The Ordinance does not govern the Sectors of the Silent Stair. The Sectors of the Silent Stair were made subject to the schedule of the Compass Floor and would be entered in the register of the Compass Floor in the ordinary way, and the keeper of the Compass Floor is not responsible for the entry. The schedule of the Compass Floor is set out in the Standing Schedule of the Compass Floor, which is published with an appendix of the Compass Floor's holdings of the fourth printing, and the appendix has been reduced, by the second edition, to a note directing the reader to the Compass Floor.

Subordinate instruments and the current register

The Ordinance has spawned a subordinate literature. The chain of instruments — the Regulation of Contaminants of Certainty, the Cognitive Load Tax, the Ordinance 887.B and the Cognitive Dimension — is extensively cross-referenced, and the clauses are held at the offices and the ordinary reference collection rather than at the gallery. The latest recension is the seventeenth, sealed on the 601st day of the 44th Vellum Descent, and the original seal is held at the Olfactory Reference Atrium. The current register includes the unaccredited-observer clause, its own certification, and the scale of penalties for erroneous accreditation, which are two graduated scales of fees, one for clerical error and one for carelessness. The competent authority is the Directorate at the seventh gallery, and the seventh gallery has not been open since the matter of the struck seals, which is cited in full in the Regulation of Certainty and marked down for the 47th Concordance.

The register is the current one, subject to the standing note that the standing note is not the current one.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Cognitive Load Tax: how is it conducted?

The Cognitive Load Tax is a levy assessed on the sustained reasoning effort conducted within a floor, corridor, or enclosed shaft, collected by the Licentiates under the authority of the Third Concordance, Clause 22, and…

Cognitive Load Tax
Memetic Vellum: what is it for?

Memetic Vellum is a class of unstable archival medium used for documenting cognitive artifacts and self-referential data structures within the Tower. Its primary characteristic is its susceptibility to spontaneous altera…

Memetic Vellum
Ordinance 52alpha: what does it set out?

Ordinance 52-Alpha, formally the Ordinance on the Registration of Habitual Apertures, is the Concordance instrument governing the licensing, inventory, and periodic recalibration of openings in the fabric of the Tower th…

Ordinance 52alpha
47th Concordance: what does it set out?

47th Concordance, officially the Concordance of Logistical Neutrality, is a binding administrative ordinance governing the routing of non-catalogued matter between classified floors of The Tower. Promulgated in Y10977.04…

47th Concordance

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.