The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Permitted Incidental Occupation

MS 5306.16 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and scope

Permitted Incidental Occupation is a classification under which a space within the Tower may be occupied by parties who hold no work order, no assignment, and no recorded intent to remain, provided the occupation is found to be incidental to some authorized activity occurring nearby. The classification was formalised in the Eleventh Concordance, Annex 9, and is administered by the Office of Procedural Reconciliation in consultation with the Register of Permitted Silences. The distinguishing feature of Permitted Incidental Occupation is that it is never declared in advance. A space is found to be so occupied; a report is filed; the occupation is then either ratified or struck out. Attempts to pre-authorise incidental occupation are treated as contradictions in terms and are returned to the submitting office unmarked.

Relation to occupancy doctrine

The doctrine governing occupancy in the Tower is unsettled and has been amended three times since the Tenth Reconciliatory Session ruled in 1904 that latent retention does not constitute occupation, and that occupation does not constitute catalogue. That ruling is still cited, though it is usually cited against itself. Permitted Incidental Occupation sits awkwardly between the two poles. It is occupation — bodies are present, furniture is used, candles are lit — but it is incidental, and therefore not attributable to any occupant's will. The Watcher orders hold that incidental occupation of a Watch station by a credentialed watcher during a Candlelight Watch is the paradigm case. The custodial orders hold that it is merely Watcher Occupation by another name, and that the Permitted category exists to avoid accounting for the candles.

The Twelfth Concordance and the Fourteenth Concordance disagree directly on this point. The Twelfth (Annex 3) states that incidental occupation "arises without the knowledge of the party occupying"; the Fourteenth (Annex 11) states that it arises "without the knowledge of the party whose space is occupied." Both remain in force. Officers of the Office of Procedural Reconciliation have been instructed to quote whichever annex is cited to them first.

The Aethelred position

Senior Archivist Aethelred, in the Treatise on Incidental Pressure, advanced the view that footnote apparatus is a record of Incidental Surfaces, observed without the observer's notice. Aethelred extended this reasoning to occupancy: a person who sits in a room while reading something else is an incidental surface upon the room, and their occupation of it is an incidental pressure rather than a deliberate taking of possession. The passage is frequently invoked in support of Permitted Incidental Occupation, though Aethelred's own gloss, added to the second recension, cautioned that the observation cuts both ways:

"The surface does not know it is being read, and the reader does not know they are being recorded. Both are nonetheless present, and both leave marks."

— Treatise on Incidental Pressure, 2nd recension, p. 44

Interaction with vacancy declarations

Permitted Incidental Occupation is the principal mechanism by which the Vexation of Persistent Occupation is managed, though it does not prevent it. A declaration of vacancy is issued; the space is surveyed; occupants are found. If the occupants hold no order and their presence is incidental to work being lawfully performed on an adjacent floor, the space is reclassified rather than cleared. This has the practical effect of converting a vexation into a filing. The consequence is that certain floors have been in continuous Permitted Incidental Occupation for longer than any officer can remember, each new occupant's presence incidental to the previous one's. Floor designation 88-Grave was recorded as such a case in the winter of the Long Inventory. The surveyor, Clerk Mirren of the Second Reconciliatory office, noted that the last authorized worker had left in 1897 and that every subsequent occupant had been incidental to that departure. Mirren's report was accepted without amendment. Visitors to such floors are asked not to extinguish any candle they did not themselves light.

Procedural record

Permitted Incidental Occupation is recorded in the Register of Permitted Silences rather than in the Master Ledger of Permitted Phrases, a division of labour that has caused repeated confusion. The Register records the space and the date of ratification; the Ledger records the phrases a party may use when questioned about their presence. A party found in Permitted Incidental Occupation who cannot produce a permitted phrase is not expelled but is instead referred to the Registry of Permitted Silences for a phrase to be drafted, a process which has taken between four days and eleven years. Applications are made on form 712-C/ii, filed in triplicate, with the third copy retained by the Office of Procedural Reconciliation and the second copy deliberately illegible. The first copy is returned to the applicant with the classification stamped but undated, in accordance with Clause 74409.

Standing disputes

Three matters remain open. First, whether Permitted Incidental Occupation may be inherited; the Provisionary Allotment rulings say no, while the practice of floor 88-Grave says otherwise. Second, whether an occupant who has been permitted incidentally for more than one century has, by duration, become an intentional occupant — a question the Tenth Reconciliatory Session declined to reach and which the Eleventh inherited. Third, whether the category applies outside the Tower, which the Librarians hold to be a category error and which is therefore not discussed. The Mutual Exclusivity of Presence doctrine does not apply, as Permitted Incidental Occupation explicitly permits several parties to occupy the same space provided none of them can be shown to have intended to.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Tenth Reconciliatory Session: what happened?

The Tenth Reconciliatory Session was the plenary sitting of the Curatorial Council at which Clause 14.7.δ (the Statute of Latent Potential) was formally ratified, and at which the School of Latent Potential was founded c…

Tenth Reconciliatory Session
Mutual Exclusivity of Presence: how is it conducted?

The Mutual Exclusivity of Presence is a regulatory doctrine of the Librarian order holding that no two catalogued subjects may occupy the same designated position at the same enumerated moment, and that where such an occ…

Mutual Exclusivity of Presence
Office of Procedural Reconciliation: who are they?

The Office of Procedural Reconciliation (OPR) is an independent bureau responsible for the adjudication, cataloguing, and reconciliation of procedural conflicts arising from the establishment or dissolution of Tower juri…

Office of Procedural Reconciliation
Watcher Occupation: how is it conducted?

Watcher Occupation denotes an official, credentialed role within the Tower's custodial orders, specifically one certified to conduct a Candlelight Watch. The designation is formalized under Annex Γ of the Third Concordan…

Watcher Occupation

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.