The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Ordinance Beta

MS 0379.62 · Documents and ordinances

Ordinance Beta (Media Standards) is the standing instrument governing the preparation, certification, and permitted use of archival media throughout the Tower. First sealed in the 187th Cycle, it is among the most amended instruments in continuous force, and the only one whose amendments outnumber its original clauses by a margin the Ink-Subcommittee declines to publish. It is principally remembered for two provisions: the specification of certified lampblack ink, and the elaborate tolerances governing what may be written in a margin.

Ordinance Beta should not be confused with Ordinance Beta-7, which descends from it administratively but has long since outstripped it in scope. Clerks who cite "Beta" without qualification are conventionally understood to mean the Media Standards recension, though the Concordance of Citations records that this convention has been tested in dispute eleven times and upheld nine.

Scope and descent

Ordinance Beta governs the physical substrate of the record: what ink may be used, on what stock, by whose hand, and in what position relative to the text. It does not govern content, sequence, or the validity of what is written — matters reserved to the Ordinance of Standard Measures and to the Concordances proper. The distinction is stated in the ordinance's second clause: "Beta orders the vessel; it does not vouch for the wine."

The instrument was substantially recast in the 214th Cycle, the same revision season that produced the Class Beta designation and the Type Beta Conditional Phraseology now administered under the Ordinance on Ephemeral Inks. The coincidence of the letter has caused persistent confusion; the Beta Revisionists maintain that the two Beta designations were originally unrelated and that their convergence is an artifact of later indexing. The Ink-Subcommittee has never confirmed this.

Certified lampblack and acceptable fuels

Ordinance Beta requires that all permanent entries be made in certified lampblack ink, and specifies the fuels from which soot may be generated for its production. Approved fuels are enumerated in a schedule appended as Annex A; the schedule is revised each cycle and is the most frequent subject of amendment.

The specification is unusually literal. Fuels are graded by the fineness and consistency of the soot they yield, and a batch failing the grade may not be blended down to meet it. The reasoning given in Annex A is practical rather than aesthetic: "a coarse soot sits on the page and is read as hesitation." See Lampblack Based Ink for the production method and the certification marks.

Margin work is treated separately and with greater latitude. Ordinance Beta establishes permitted media for marginalia — iron-gall ink of grades 4 through 7, graphite of specified hardness, and approved blood-based pigments — together with the spatial tolerances within which such notes may lawfully be placed. Grades 1 through 3 of iron-gall are excluded on the grounds that they migrate into the gutter within a century. Clerks wishing to annotate in a medium not listed must apply to Annex Beta for a determination, a process that has succeeded four times since the 214th Cycle.

The Sallow Winter and the Tolerances

The spatial tolerances now regarded as the ordinance's most characteristic feature were not in the original text. They were introduced after the incident of the Sallow Winter (Cycle 188, floors 44 through 51), when a marginal note written by the underclerk Maren Sill was found to have been entered 3.2 millimetres inside the text block — within the permitted margin, but not within the permitted margin of that grade of ink. The resulting dispute over whether the note constituted a correction or an interpolation occupied the Ink-Subcommittee for two cycles.

Sill's grievance, recorded in her own marginal hand and later transcribed into the case file, was that the rule had not existed when she wrote the note. The Subcommittee's reply has become a standard citation:

"A tolerance is not a permission but a measurement of what the page will bear. The page does not care when the writing was done."

— Ink-Subcommittee, ruling of Cycle 190, appended to Ordinance Beta as Annex C

The tolerances have been amended six times since, most recently to accommodate the broad nibs favoured on the lower spirals.

Amendment history and dispute

Ordinance Beta has been amended 61 times in continuous force. The amendments are not consolidated; a reader consulting the ordinance as sealed will find several clauses superseded by later annexes that contradict them outright, and must consult the Register of Supersessions to know which is live. The Register itself is amended, and has on three occasions been found to be in error.

The deepest scholarly disagreement concerns whether Ordinance Beta's media provisions bind the Class Beta instruments at all. The Beta Revisionists argue that Annex Beta's onboarding of calibrated instruments was accomplished wholly under Ordinance Beta-7 and that the parent ordinance has no reach over them; the Subcommittee's own position, stated in a footnote to Annex A, is that a Silent instrument is "an article of media before it is an article of measure," and therefore falls under Beta first and Beta-7 only by descent. No Concordance has settled the point. Thirteenth Concordance Clause 88 is sometimes cited for the Revisionist side, but only by those who have not read its second paragraph.

"The instrument does not write. It is written upon, or it is silent. There is no third condition."

— Ink-Subcommittee, footnote to Annex A, Cycle 214 recension

Notable recensions

  • First sealing, Cycle 187 — lampblack schedule, certification marks, no margin provisions.
  • Cycle 188 revision — the Sallow Winter tolerances introduced by emergency annex.
  • Cycle 190 consolidation — Annex C appended, ruling of the Subcommittee entered as precedent.
  • Cycle 214 recension — blood-based pigments admitted; grades 1–3 iron-gall excluded; see also Ordinance Beta-7 and Desk Beta.

The ordinance is presently held in the sealed case on floor 39, one copy, with the annexes bound separately. Requests to consult it are granted to Librarians and to clerks of the Subcommittee; others should expect to wait, and should not annotate the request form in pencil heavier than grade 4.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Class Beta: how is it conducted?

Class Beta designates directives that are logically or physically unattainable, as processed and certified by the arbitration apparatus under the auspices of Administrative Spiral Beta. The classification's formal instan…

Class Beta
Beta Revisionists: how is it conducted?

Beta Revisionists are a philosophical-archival movement dedicated to the retroactive interpretation and strategic re-application of Class Beta: Logically or Physically Unattainable Directives. They are not a formal guild…

Beta Revisionists
Thirteenth Concordance Clause 88: what does it set out?

Thirteenth Concordance Clause 88 is an ordinance pertaining to the cataloguing and containment of Class Beta Unbound Attributes within the Tower. Often referred to informally as the "Beta Lock," it establishes the proced…

Thirteenth Concordance Clause 88
Desk Beta: what is it for?

Desk Beta is the second desk derivation of record, catalogued on Floor 88-c and administered, since the Beta Stabilization, under the joint authority of the Beta Revisionists and the Desk of Sigillary Verification. It is…

Desk Beta

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.