Mandated Declarations
MS 4598.04 · Practices and doctrines
The Mandated Declarations are a class of formal instrument distinct from the voluntary instruments catalogued elsewhere in the Tower: a Mandated Declaration is one whose issuer is not, strictly speaking, its declarant. The distinction is administrative rather than metaphysical. Where a procedural declaration records what a party asserts, a Mandated Declaration records what a party has been caused to assert by a competent office, and carries the signature of the office rather than the party. The instrument is recognised chiefly in the settlement of disputes whose underlying events have already been declared, but not by the right person, and it is the standard remedy for what the Concordances call declaratory heredity — the circumstance in which a declaration passes from one bearer to another without sufficient documentation of the transfer.
Origin and first recension
The form appears first in the annotations of Sorrel of the Fifth Recension, whose working register for the winter of the year generally cited as the Third Quiet records fourteen instruments issued to parties who had not requested them. Sorrel's marginal note notes with irritation that eleven recipients "accepted the seal and asked for a second copy." The practice was regularised by the Ordinance of Bearing Declarations (clause 9), which fixed the present form: an opening statement of the compelled fact, a middle attestation of the compelling office's authority, and a closing paragraph in which the declarant — who may not be present, and need not be informed — is named. Clause 9 further requires that the named declarant be given the document at some point, though it does not specify when.
Mandated Declarations are not to be confused with Assertoric Declarations, which assert their own content and require no compelling office, nor with Declarations of Clarification, which clarify other declarations and are themselves a species of Mandated Declaration when issued under compulsion by the Board of Concordant Interpretation. The Board has issued exactly one such instrument and has since declined to discuss it.
Procedure of compulsion
A Mandated Declaration is issued when an adjudicating body finds that a fact requiring declaration has not been declared by the party best placed to declare it. The finding must name the fact, name the party, and state what would have happened had the party declared voluntarily — the practice is called the counterfactual recital, and its omission is among the most common grounds for objection. The office then composes the instrument and submits it to the Office of Seals, which has lodged a standing objection since the Concordance revision of the forty-second cycle on the grounds that it is asked to seal documents whose declarants have not consented and whose existence it cannot independently confirm. The objection is reproduced annually and annually noted.
"A declaration compelled is a declaration nonetheless, and a refusal unrecorded is a refusal all the same."
— Ordinance of Bearing Declarations, clause 9
The counterfactual recital is not read aloud at sealing. Sealing takes place on the second landing of the eastern stair, in daylight, and no one below may speak during it.
Dispute over the declarant
The principal scholarly disagreement concerns who, in law, is the declarant of a Mandated Declaration. The doctrine of the Adjudicators of Precedent holds that the named party is declarant and the issuing office merely a scribe, so that the instrument takes effect on signature by the office acting in the party's stead. The contrary doctrine, advanced in a long and undecided memorial by the Cessationists and cited approvingly in the Register of Anomalous Claims, holds that the office is the declarant and the named party is a subject of the declaration, in which case the instrument is not a declaration about the party but a declaration against the party, and falls under the rules governing Negatory Declarations.
The distinction has practical consequences. Under the first doctrine, a Mandated Declaration may be withdrawn by the named party; under the second, only the issuing office may withdraw it, and it has never done so. Clerks resolving the question in the ordinary course are directed to the Frame of Adjudication, which settles the legal weight of procedural instruments but does not reach the question of declaratory identity. The Frame is silent on identity, and its silence has been interpreted both ways.
Notable instruments
The most cited Mandated Declaration remains Mandate 2-B, issued in the matter of the disputed freight inventory on floor 1788, in which an office compelled a declaration from a party who had been dead for two recensions. The instrument was upheld. The party's heirs received the document in accordance with clause 9 and requested a second copy, which was refused on the grounds that the first had not been read.
Mandated Declarations have also been used to regularise the Ledger of Echoed Declarations, which records instances in which an Assertoric Declaration was followed by a different declarative form. Twelve such instances have been retrospectively converted into Mandated Declarations, a procedure that the Ledger's compilers describe as tidy and the Custodians of the Vertical describe as a forgery with better penmanship.
Filing and custody
Mandated Declarations are filed in the eastern annex of the Unfinished Declarations Wing, in the sequence of compelling office rather than named party, so that the depositor and the subject sit in different stacks. Retrieval requires both names. The annex keeps a reading table, four chairs, and a rule that chairs are not to be moved between stacks. Each instrument is copied twice: one copy for the office, one copy for the party, and one copy retained, though the ordinance mentions only two.
See also
-
MS 3178.26
Voluntary Declarations
A Voluntary Declaration is a formal, anticipatory notification filed with the Office of Voluntary Correspondence stating the decla…
-
MS 2568.18
Statement of Voluntary Assertion
The Statement of Voluntary Assertion is the popular designation of the document formally catalogued as OVC-1a, a single-leaf instr…
-
MS 2827.63
Voluntary Declaration
A Voluntary Declaration is a formal statement submitted by any citizen or authorized visitor to the Tower, affirming the existence…
-
MS 9939.63
Clause 22 of the Third Concordance
Clause 22 of the Third Concordance is the statutory instrument establishing the Office of Voluntary Correspondence and defining it…
-
MS 6121.55
Declaration of Nonexistence
The Declaration of Nonexistence is the generic designation for the class of instruments filed under Form M-7 'Declaration of Nonex…
-
MS 8165.07
Substantive Declaration
A Substantive Declaration is a formal instrument by which a named floor, office, or body asserts that a matter within its register…
Referenced by
- MS 1447.49 Procedural Declarations
- MS 7405.25 Ledger of Echoed Declarations
Readers also asked
Negatory Declarations: what does it set out?
A Negatory Declaration is an official, formal document filed with the Department of Matriculation to assert, under the stipulations of the Third Concordance, that a procedural step, a prior declaration, or a catalogued s…
Negatory DeclarationsAssertoric Declarations: how is it conducted?
An Assertoric Declarations is a formal pronouncement issued under the authority of a Third Concordance concerning the existence or categorical status of a non-existent entity within the Tower. Unlike a Declaration of Cla…
Assertoric DeclarationsRegister of Anomalous Claims: what does it set out?
The Register of Anomalous Claims is the primary docket for all petitions, discoveries, and formal declarations pertaining to subjects which challenge the Tower's established taxonomic or spatial frameworks. Its purpose i…
Register of Anomalous ClaimsBoard of Concordant Interpretation: who are they?
The Board of Concordant Interpretation is the secondary appellate body for disputes regarding the proper application of Concordant Law within The Tower. Located on the 310th floor (The Aula of Precision), its twelve perm…
Board of Concordant InterpretationPassages cited from this record
-
A declaration compelled is a declaration nonetheless, and a refusal unrecorded is a refusal all the same.
Ordinance of Bearing Declarations, clause 9
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3353.45 Sorrel of the Fifth Recension
- MS 9936.09 Frame of Adjudication
- MS 7049.50 Mandate 2-B
- MS 2538.23 Unfinished Declarations Wing
Because you consulted