The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Intentional Review Board

MS 6567.51 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Intentional Review Board is a standing body of the Tower entrusted with the examination of intent where intent has been recorded but not yet discharged. It is not to be confused with the Intentional Cross-Examination, a separate procedure of longer standing, nor with the Epistemological Review Board, whose concern is whether a thing may be known rather than whether it was meant. The Intentional Review Board sits in three chambers on Floor 812, Stairwell Meridian, and its seal — a closed hand above an open register — appears on all findings issued since its reconstitution in Year 1,104 of the Current Recension.

Its founding instrument is Declaration of Clarification 42.β, which distinguishes the Board from the Board of Equitable Review instituted under 42.α of the same year. The two Declarations were drafted in the same scriptorium within a fortnight of one another, and the resemblance has caused confusion in every decade since.

Jurisdiction

The Board hears matters in which an intention has been entered into the record and subsequently left unresolved — neither performed nor formally abandoned. Such an entry is termed a pending intention, and the Board's task is to determine whether the pending intention remains live, has lapsed by the passage of twelve floors or more, or has been absorbed into a later entry without notice. The third category, absorption, accounts for roughly seven parts in ten of the Board's caseload and is the source of most of its difficulties.

The Board does not adjudicate the truth of an intention, only its standing. A question as to whether an intention was ever truly held belongs to the Dialectical Review Board, which has contested this boundary since Concordance 19, Annex 6, without success. Questions of intent as it bears on unfinished business are remitted to the Review Board for Unfinished Business, and questions concerning adjacent intentions — those recorded on a neighbouring floor within the same quire — to the Board of Adjacent Review. Where a pending intention has been entered against a ledger account, the Ledger Reconciliation Board must be notified before any finding issues.

Procedure and the Question of Standing

A matter reaches the Board by petition, by referral from the Central Review Board, or by the automatic operation of the Rotation, under which every intention unexamined for nine years is brought forward without a petitioner. The Rotation was introduced by Concordance 23 and has never been fully implemented; the Board's own estimate, appended to its Annual Return for Year 1,196, places the unexamined remainder at some 41,000 entries.

Petitioners are heard in writing. Oral hearing is granted at the discretion of the presiding Librarian and, since the Ruling of the Closed Hand (Year 1,151), only where the petitioner can demonstrate that the intention in question was recorded in a hand other than their own. The Ruling followed an incident in the winter of Year 1,150, in which a petitioner named Clerk Ovren Halloway addressed the Board for six hours on an intention he had himself entered and afterwards withdrawn; the Board found for the withdrawal and charged him for the ink.

"No intention shall be pleaded by the hand that wrote it, save where that hand can show it wrote against its will."

— Ruling of the Closed Hand, paragraph 2

Doctrine of the Unstated Intent

The Board's most cited finding is the Doctrine of the Unstated Intent, issued in Year 1,162, which holds that an intention omitted from the record altogether does not thereby cease to exist but acquires what the Board called "a standing of silence" — neither live nor lapsed, and reviewable only upon the discovery of evidence that it was intended. The Doctrine has been applied sparingly. In the case of Matter of the Ninth Annotation, the Board held that a marginal note written and then erased on Floor 344 constituted evidence of an intention to annotate, which, being unstated in the fair copy, stood silent and therefore reviewable indefinitely; the finding was reversed on appeal to the Board of Equitable Review on procedural grounds and the substantive doctrine left undisturbed.

Disputes with the Concordances

Scholars differ as to whether the Board's authority derives from Concordance 23 or from the earlier Third Concordance, Annex 11, which is sometimes read as anticipating it. The Office of Concordant Interpretation has declined to resolve the question, noting in its Opinion of Year 1,188 that "the two instruments support the Board in unequal measure and in opposite directions" — a formulation the Board has adopted in its own preamble without evident discomfort.

A second dispute concerns the Board's relationship to the Gamma Review Board, which administers Floor 7, Access Gamma, and which claims concurrent jurisdiction over intentions recorded below Floor 400. The claim rests on a reading of the Gamma Recension no longer extant; the Intentional Review Board has answered it, consistently since Year 1,174, by referring the Gamma Review Board to Concordance 31, Annex 2, and taking no further step.

Records and Premises

The Board maintains a single register, the Register of Standing Intentions, bound in nineteen volumes and held under seal in the Meridian chamber. Volumes I through XII have not been opened since Year 1,089 owing to the condition of the bindings. The Board's seal is impressed in wax and the wax is warmed on a small brazier kept for the purpose; the brazier is not to be carried beyond the threshold of the chamber, a rule posted at the door and repeated in the Board's Annual Return without explanation.

Findings issue in triplicate: one copy to the petitioner, one to the Institute for Bureaucratic Metaphysics for calendaring, and one retained. Correspondence concerning the Board should be addressed to the Third Chamber, Floor 812, and not to the Second, which has been closed to petitioners since the Recess of the Second Chamber in Year 1,191.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Epistemological Review Board: who are they?

The Epistemological Review Board is a standing body of the Tower charged with adjudicating disputes over whether a given proposition has been established, and by whom. It is not to be confused with the Office of Epistemo…

Epistemological Review Board
Board of Equitable Review: who are they?

The Board of Equitable Review is a standing adjudicatory body chartered under the revised annex to the Third Concordance, charged with the arbitration of inter-departmental resource allocation disputes and the review of …

Board of Equitable Review
Intentional Cross-Examination: how is it conducted?

The Intentional Cross-Examination is a formal procedural mechanism, authorized under Addendum 17 and standardized by the Lyceum of Intentional Design, for adjudicating disputes over architectural intent. It requires the …

Intentional Cross-Examination
Review Board for Unfinished Business: who are they?

The Review Board for Unfinished Business is a standing body of the Tower constituted to hear appeals arising from matters that have entered the docket but not departed it. It sits on Floor 4471, in a chamber adjoining th…

Review Board for Unfinished Business

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.